PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 6 practice questions

Corrected Misstatements and Control Deficiencies

Correcting a misstatement does not resolve the control failure that allowed it. Below, judge the auditor's responses to corrected sales cutoff errors and a missed review.

The ruleCorrecting identified misstatements does not resolve the underlying control failure. Investigate cause and extent, reassess risk and planned control reliance, modify procedures as needed, and evaluate the deficiency's severity and communication implications.

Try one first

In a nonissuer financial statement audit under U.S. GAAS, the auditor's substantive testing of year‑end sales cut‑off identified invoices recorded in Year 1 for goods that were actually shipped in Year 2. The identified errors were not clearly trivial. Management recorded an adjustment, and the financial statements are no longer materially misstated. The auditor traced the errors to a condition that allowed warehouse supervisors to manually override shipping dates in the sales system without independent review; this condition existed throughout Year 1. Which response is required?
Hint

Do not stop at whether the financial statements were corrected, consider what the errors reveal about the process and the auditor's responsibilities regarding control deficiencies.

What should you do?

The situation

In Lark Co.'s nonissuer audit, you reduced year-end sales cutoff testing based on a shipping-document review control. Substantive testing finds $60,000 of premature sales entries from the same missed review. Management corrects them and calls them isolated. The total is below overall materiality. You have not determined whether other errors exist or whether another control could detect them.

  1. Investigate causes and extent, reassess risks and planned control reliance, and evaluate deficiency severity and communication implications.

    Best The adjustment fixes known errors. The missed review still calls for investigating other errors, modifying procedures as needed, and evaluating the control issue.

  2. Verify the corrections and retain the original audit plan because the errors were immaterial.

    Wrong Correction addresses only identified amounts. It does not show that the review worked or that remaining cutoff risk is unchanged.

  3. Expand cutoff testing, but skip control evaluation because substantive procedures found the errors.

    Wrong Substantive results also provide evidence about control effectiveness. More testing does not replace evaluating the missed review.

  4. Accept management's explanation that the errors were isolated and keep relying on the review.

    Wrong An explanation is not evidence that the errors were isolated. The shared missed review calls planned reliance into question.

  5. Immediately classify the missed review as a material weakness.

    Wrong Severity depends on likelihood and potential magnitude of misstatement. Multiple errors do not automatically establish a material weakness.

Key points

  • Remember: Correcting the entries fixes the known amounts, not the failed control or the risk of more errors.
  • Substantive testing can reveal failed controls even when earlier control testing supported reliance.
  • Severity depends on the likelihood and potential magnitude of misstatement, not just the corrected amount.

How the exam traps you

  • Stopping after management corrects the known errors. Investigate the missed review and determine whether the audit plan still provides sufficient evidence.
  • Accepting management's claim that the errors were isolated. Obtain evidence about cause and extent before retaining planned control reliance.
  • Automatically calling repeated errors a material weakness. Evaluate likelihood and potential magnitude before classifying the deficiency.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

During substantive cutoff testing, an auditor finds three Year 1 sales that were recorded before shipment. The total overstatement of revenue is not material, and management agrees to record an adjustment. The same supervisor had approved each sale even though company policy requires evidence of shipment before revenue is recognized. What is the auditor's best next action?
Hint

Do not stop at whether the amount is material or corrected. Ask what the repeated error suggests about the related control.

Question 3

In an audit of a nonissuer's financial statements, the auditor planned to rely on a control requiring the cost accounting manager to review and approve standard-cost changes before they are uploaded to the inventory system. During substantive testing of 15 year-end standard-cost changes, the auditor finds that 4 changes lacked the required approval. Two of those 4 caused inventory to be overstated, and management records the auditor's proposed adjustment. Assume the exceptions arose from the same process, no compensating controls have been identified, and the aggregate misstatement is below overall materiality. Which consequence is best supported?
Hint

Do not stop at materiality or whether management booked the adjustment. Ask what the pattern of exceptions implies about the control the auditor intended to rely on.

Question 4

During a nonissuer financial statement audit, which finding from further procedures most strongly suggests an internal control deficiency that the auditor should evaluate for possible communication, even if management records a year-end adjustment before the financial statements are issued?
Hint

Focus on which finding shows a breakdown in the entity's process or review controls, not just a single error or a reasonable estimate difference.

Question 5

During the Year 2 audit of Lark Co., the auditor tests purchases and accounts payable. Lark has a control requiring the accounts payable supervisor to review a system-generated duplicate-invoice exception report before invoices are posted. In substantive testing, the auditor finds four duplicate invoice postings at one location, totaling $36,000. All four occurred because the exception report was generated but was not reviewed for several months. Management records an adjustment before the financial statements are issued and says the errors were isolated clerical mistakes. The amount is not material to the financial statements as a whole, and no fraud indicators were identified. What is the auditor's best action?
Hint

Separate the financial statement adjustment decision from the internal control evaluation. A corrected error can still matter.

Question 6

During the year-end audit of a nonissuer, the auditor set performance materiality at $180,000. In the revenue cycle, substantive testing identified (1) a $62,000 cutoff overstatement from Year 2 shipments recorded in Year 1, (2) a $51,000 understatement of sales returns caused by delayed credit-memo processing, and (3) smaller projected sample errors. Management immediately recorded the two specific adjustments; the remaining known uncorrected amount was $18,000. The auditor also learned that the month-end review control over shipping documents and credit memos was not performed for the last three weeks of Year 1. Assume no fraud indicators and no scope limitation. Under generally accepted auditing standards, when is the auditor most clearly required to consider modifying the nature, timing, or extent of further audit procedures?
Hint

Don't focus only on the remaining uncorrected dollar amount; consider whether the concentration of errors and the missed control activity increase the risk that the original plan is no longer adequate.

Drill all 132 Misstatements and Internal Control Deficiencies questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Do corrected audit misstatements still affect control reliance?

Yes. Errors caused by a missed review remain evidence against that control's effectiveness, so reassess reliance and whether planned procedures remain sufficient.

Should auditors expand testing after management corrects cutoff errors?

Investigate the cause and likely extent. In this scenario, the shared missed review and unknown extent call for additional cutoff procedures.

Do corrected cutoff errors automatically mean a material weakness?

No. Evaluate the likelihood and potential magnitude of misstatement, not just the amount corrected, before determining severity and communication implications.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Misstatements and Internal Control Deficiencies, worked step by step.

Uncorrected Misstatements & Control Deficiencies | CPA AUD TBS on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Misstatements and Internal Control Deficiencies

All Misstatements and Internal Control Deficiencies practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.