AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 6 practice questions
Corrected Misstatements and Control Deficiencies
Correcting a misstatement does not resolve the control failure that allowed it. Below, judge the auditor's responses to corrected sales cutoff errors and a missed review.
Try one first
Hint
Do not stop at whether the financial statements were corrected, consider what the errors reveal about the process and the auditor's responsibilities regarding control deficiencies.
Answer A. Under GAAS, identifying misstatements, even if corrected, may provide evidence about deficiencies in control design or operation. The auditor must evaluate the severity of any deficiency, reassess risks and whether additional or modified audit procedures are needed, and determine whether the deficiency should be communicated to management and those charged with governance.
Why not B: Tempting because the statements were corrected, but incorrect: GAAS requires the auditor to consider what caused the misstatements, control weaknesses may remain and could affect risk assessment, additional procedures, and reporting obligations.
Why not C: Tempting because a failed control produced a misstatement, but incorrect: a single or observed misstatement does not automatically establish a material weakness; the auditor must evaluate the magnitude and likelihood of misstatements and the severity of the deficiency before concluding it is a material weakness.
Why not D: Tempting because confirming the correction seems efficient, but incorrect: understanding and evaluating internal control is part of risk assessment under GAAS; identified control deficiencies can require additional testing, risk reassessment, and communication.
What should you do?
The situation
In Lark Co.'s nonissuer audit, you reduced year-end sales cutoff testing based on a shipping-document review control. Substantive testing finds $60,000 of premature sales entries from the same missed review. Management corrects them and calls them isolated. The total is below overall materiality. You have not determined whether other errors exist or whether another control could detect them.
Investigate causes and extent, reassess risks and planned control reliance, and evaluate deficiency severity and communication implications.
Best The adjustment fixes known errors. The missed review still calls for investigating other errors, modifying procedures as needed, and evaluating the control issue.
Verify the corrections and retain the original audit plan because the errors were immaterial.
Wrong Correction addresses only identified amounts. It does not show that the review worked or that remaining cutoff risk is unchanged.
Expand cutoff testing, but skip control evaluation because substantive procedures found the errors.
Wrong Substantive results also provide evidence about control effectiveness. More testing does not replace evaluating the missed review.
Accept management's explanation that the errors were isolated and keep relying on the review.
Wrong An explanation is not evidence that the errors were isolated. The shared missed review calls planned reliance into question.
Immediately classify the missed review as a material weakness.
Wrong Severity depends on likelihood and potential magnitude of misstatement. Multiple errors do not automatically establish a material weakness.
Key points
- Remember: Correcting the entries fixes the known amounts, not the failed control or the risk of more errors.
- Substantive testing can reveal failed controls even when earlier control testing supported reliance.
- Severity depends on the likelihood and potential magnitude of misstatement, not just the corrected amount.
How the exam traps you
- Stopping after management corrects the known errors. Investigate the missed review and determine whether the audit plan still provides sufficient evidence.
- Accepting management's claim that the errors were isolated. Obtain evidence about cause and extent before retaining planned control reliance.
- Automatically calling repeated errors a material weakness. Evaluate likelihood and potential magnitude before classifying the deficiency.
Question 2
Hint
Do not stop at whether the amount is material or corrected. Ask what the repeated error suggests about the related control.
Answer B. A detected misstatement, even if corrected and immaterial, can indicate that a control did not operate effectively. The auditor should evaluate whether these misstatements suggest a deficiency in internal control over revenue cutoff and reconsider planned audit procedures or additional testing. Because the same supervisor approved multiple pre-shipment entries despite the policy, reassessment of control effectiveness and possible further procedures are warranted.
Why not A: This is tempting because the amount was corrected and immaterial, but correction does not eliminate the need to investigate why the error occurred. Repeated exceptions by the same approver may indicate a control deficiency that affects future reliability and the audit approach.
Why not C: This is attractive because revenue recognition is significant, but a control failure does not automatically constitute a material weakness. The auditor must evaluate the severity and whether the deficiency (or combination of deficiencies) results in a reasonable possibility of a material misstatement before concluding a material weakness.
Why not D: Candidates may recall that misstatements must be accumulated for materiality assessment, but that is incomplete here. Identified misstatements can also provide evidence about control effectiveness and may require changes to further audit procedures or control conclusions.
Question 3
Hint
Do not stop at materiality or whether management booked the adjustment. Ask what the pattern of exceptions implies about the control the auditor intended to rely on.
Answer B. Misstatements identified through substantive procedures can indicate that a related control is not operating effectively. Multiple unapproved standard-cost changes arising from the same process, and some causing actual misstatement, are evidence that the auditor should reconsider reliance on the approval control and potentially increase substantive testing of inventory valuation, even though management corrected the amounts and the aggregate misstatement is below overall materiality.
Why not A: This is tempting because it focuses on correction and materiality, but corrections do not erase evidence that the control failed to operate as intended. The auditor still must reassess whether the control can be relied upon and whether additional substantive procedures are necessary.
Why not C: Students may wrongly separate substantive testing from control evaluation. In reality, misstatements detected by substantive procedures can reveal control deficiencies, particularly when they originate from the same process and relate to a control the auditor planned to rely on.
Why not D: Repeated exceptions are concerning and may indicate a deficiency, but concluding a significant deficiency requires evaluation of severity (likelihood and magnitude). The facts support reassessing control reliance and possibly communicating a deficiency, but do not mandate an immediate conclusion that it is a significant deficiency.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on which finding shows a breakdown in the entity's process or review controls, not just a single error or a reasonable estimate difference.
Answer B. This finding indicates a process problem in revenue cutoff (recording sales before shipment) and a failure of a review control to detect the misstatements in a timely manner. Even if management corrects the balances before issuance, the recurring nature of the cutoff errors and the ineffective period-end review suggest a control deficiency that the auditor should evaluate for possible communication.
Why not A: Tempting because an actual misstatement was identified, but the facts describe an isolated clerical mistake with no pattern or control breakdown identified. That makes it less persuasive evidence of a systemic control deficiency than repeated errors tied to a failed review process.
Why not C: Estimate differences can be high risk, but when management's estimate falls within the auditor's acceptable range and is supported by evidence, there is not a misstatement or clear control failure on these facts, so it is a weaker basis for identifying a control deficiency.
Why not D: Omitted liabilities can indicate weak completeness controls, but this fact pattern points to a single misfiled document with no similar exceptions found in testing. That isolated omission is less indicative of a systemic control deficiency than recurring cutoff errors that the entity's review failed to catch.
Question 5
Hint
Separate the financial statement adjustment decision from the internal control evaluation. A corrected error can still matter.
Answer A. Even though management corrected the misstatements before issuance, the auditor must evaluate whether the related control failed to operate effectively. Corrected misstatements provide evidence about the operating effectiveness of controls, so the auditor should perform additional procedures to determine the significance of the control failure and then classify and communicate the deficiency (control deficiency, significant deficiency, or material weakness) if appropriate. The immaterial amount and lack of fraud indicators reduce the likelihood of a material weakness but do not eliminate the need for evaluation and possible communication.
Why not B: Tempting because the financial statement effect was corrected, but corrected misstatements still provide evidence about whether a control operated effectively; the auditor cannot stop at accepting the adjustment without evaluating the underlying control failure.
Why not C: This overstates the requirement. While a misstatement resulting from a control failure is serious, it does not automatically equal a material weakness; the auditor must assess severity considering likelihood and magnitude. The facts (single location, immaterial amount, no fraud indicators) support further evaluation rather than an automatic material‑weakness conclusion.
Why not D: This choice reflects focusing only on uncorrected misstatements, which is incomplete. Corrected errors can still reveal that a control did not function as intended and may require communication, so the auditor must evaluate the control deficiency as well as the financial statement impact.
Question 6
Hint
Don't focus only on the remaining uncorrected dollar amount; consider whether the concentration of errors and the missed control activity increase the risk that the original plan is no longer adequate.
Answer A. Auditing standards require the auditor to reassess risks and to modify the nature, timing, or extent of further procedures when audit evidence suggests the original plan may no longer be appropriate. Misstatements concentrated in the revenue process together with a failure of the month‑end review control increase the likelihood of additional undetected errors. The auditor should therefore consider changing procedures during fieldwork even if the remaining known uncorrected misstatements are below performance materiality.
Why not B: Tempting because dollar thresholds are familiar, but incorrect: the need to revise procedures is driven by the nature, pattern, and implications of detected misstatements and control failures, not solely by whether known uncorrected misstatements exceed performance materiality.
Why not C: Tempting because severity classifications matter for communication, but incorrect: the auditor must respond to evidence of increased risk by modifying procedures as appropriate before or regardless of formally labeling the deficiency; waiting for a formal classification can leave risks unaddressed.
Why not D: Tempting because overall evaluation occurs near completion, but incorrect: evidence obtained during fieldwork that indicates increased risk can require immediate reconsideration and expansion of procedures rather than waiting until the final evaluation.
Common questions
Do corrected audit misstatements still affect control reliance?
Yes. Errors caused by a missed review remain evidence against that control's effectiveness, so reassess reliance and whether planned procedures remain sufficient.
Should auditors expand testing after management corrects cutoff errors?
Investigate the cause and likely extent. In this scenario, the shared missed review and unknown extent call for additional cutoff procedures.
Do corrected cutoff errors automatically mean a material weakness?
No. Evaluate the likelihood and potential magnitude of misstatement, not just the amount corrected, before determining severity and communication implications.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Misstatements and Internal Control Deficiencies, worked step by step.
Uncorrected Misstatements & Control Deficiencies | CPA AUD TBS on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Misstatements and Internal Control Deficiencies
All Misstatements and Internal Control Deficiencies practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.