AUD · Ethics and Professional Responsibilities and General Principles · 6 practice questions
AICPA Nonattest Services: Client SKE and Oversight
For a nonissuer attest client, permitted nonattest work requires capable client oversight, client responsibility, and a documented understanding, without the CPA assuming management duties. Use this checklist to evaluate a financial statement preparation request.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on whether the CPA crossed into a management role, not merely on whether the CPA helped with the financial statements or proposed entries.
Answer B. Under the AICPA Code, preparing financial statements and proposing journal entries for a nonissuer attest client are nonattest services that do not automatically impair independence. The crucial requirements are that management has suitable skill, knowledge, and experience, oversees and reviews the work, and accepts responsibility for the financial statements and entries, while the CPA does not assume management responsibilities. The stem states these conditions are met, so independence is not impaired on these facts.
Why not A: This overgeneralizes the self-review threat. For nonissuer attest clients, preparing financial statements is a permitted nonattest service if management retains responsibility and the CPA does not assume management functions.
Why not C: Proposing adjustments is not the same as making management decisions. As long as management reviews, approves, and accepts responsibility for proposed entries and the CPA does not perform a management function, independence is not automatically impaired.
Why not D: AICPA rules do not require zero CPA assistance. The requirement is that management oversee the service, have suitable skill, knowledge, and experience, and accept responsibility while the CPA avoids assuming management responsibilities.
Step by step
- Identify the requested service
Hill, a nonissuer audit client under AICPA rules, asks the firm to prepare year-end financial statements and disclosures from its adjusted trial balance. This creates a self-review concern, but the service is not automatically prohibited.
- Check client SKE
Hill's owner and board lack the ability to oversee the service. Hill must designate someone, such as a qualified controller, with suitable skill, knowledge, and experience (SKE) to provide that oversight.
- Keep responsibility with Hill
Hill must make all management decisions, evaluate the service's adequacy and results, and accept responsibility for the statements. The CPA may draft statements and disclosures but cannot take over Hill's significant judgments.
- Document the understanding
Before providing the service, the CPA must document the understanding in writing. Include the objectives, services, Hill's acceptance of its responsibilities, the CPA's responsibilities, and any engagement limitations.
- Reject substitutes for client oversight
An owner's signature, separate firm staff, or partner review cannot replace capable client oversight. Without a client designee able to oversee and evaluate the service, independence is impaired even for drafting statements.
- Reach the independence conclusion
If Hill designates a capable controller and all required conditions are met, the firm may prepare the statements without impairing independence. The key is who oversees the work and makes management decisions, not who prepares the draft.
Key points
- Remember: The CPA may prepare statements, but a capable client designee must oversee the work and accept responsibility.
- Preparing a draft is not the same as making the client's significant judgments.
- A self-review concern does not automatically prohibit this preparation service under AICPA rules.
How the exam traps you
- The owner's signature proves adequate client oversight. Require suitable SKE and actual oversight, evaluation, and acceptance of responsibility.
- Separate firm staff can replace a capable client designee. Firm staffing and internal review do not satisfy the client's oversight responsibilities.
- Client approval eliminates the need to document the understanding. Document the nonattest-service understanding in writing before providing the service.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on the line between assisting management and acting as management. A permitted nonattest service cannot give the CPA authority over client decisions, personnel, or assets.
Answer D. Under AICPA independence rules for a nonissuer client, preparing financial statements can be a permitted nonattest service when management accepts responsibility, has the ability to oversee the service, and will review and approve significant judgments. The CPA must not assume management responsibilities (make client decisions or sign off on management's judgments), but a mechanical preparation of statements from client-provided trial balance information is allowable given the stated safeguards.
Why not A: This appears administrative but would give the CPA control over client assets and the authority to make disbursements, an actual management function that impairs independence.
Why not B: Supervising client personnel and approving performance evaluations are management duties. Taking that authority would constitute performing management functions and would impair independence.
Why not C: While auditors propose adjusting entries, deciding what should be recorded and posting them without management's approval places the CPA in a management role and assumes client responsibility, which impairs independence.
Question 3
Hint
Ask whether the firm's action would require making management decisions or controlling client assets/staff versus preparing information that management (or its designated individual) will oversee and accept.
Answer B. The AICPA Code permits preparing financial statements as a nonattest service if management retains responsibility, designates an appropriate individual to oversee the service, evaluates the results, and accepts responsibility for the statements. Here Gray would only draft statements from client records and proposed adjustments while the designated management individual oversees, reviews, and accepts responsibility, so Gray would not be performing management functions and independence would not be impaired.
Why not A: This is tempting because auditors commonly propose adjustments, but selecting and recording final entries when management cannot evaluate alternatives requires the firm to make management judgments and assume management responsibility. That assumption of management functions impairs independence.
Why not C: This distractor seems practical as a temporary replacement, but authorizing and signing disbursements gives the firm control over client transactions and assets, a clear management function. Such control impairs independence.
Why not D: Supervising and directing client personnel may appear helpful, but making daily personnel or operational decisions involves performing management functions rather than providing preparatory assistance. Delegating that authority to the firm impairs independence.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on who must remain responsible for a nonattest service provided to an attest client.
Answer D. For a nonissuer attest client, the AICPA independence rules permit certain nonattest services only if the client retains management responsibility for the service. That requires the client to designate an individual with suitable skill to oversee the service, evaluate the adequacy and results, and accept responsibility for them. Because Lake already makes key payroll decisions, independence is preserved only if Lake formally designates and accepts responsibility as described in option A.
Why not A: A passive review of outputs is not sufficient under the AICPA framework; the client must designate an appropriate individual to oversee the service and formally accept responsibility, not merely examine results after the fact.
Why not B: This is tempting because separating staff sounds like it avoids self-review, but staffing separation alone does not satisfy the independence requirement; the client must retain oversight and accept responsibility for the nonattest service.
Why not C: Fee arrangements do not substitute for client management responsibility; separate billing or a fixed fee does not preserve independence if the client does not oversee and accept responsibility for the service.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on what the client must do, who must oversee and accept responsibility for the nonattest service, and whether that person has the required accounting competence.
Answer C. Under the AICPA Code, preparing financial statements as a nonattest service for an attest client is permitted only if the client accepts responsibility for the results and designates an individual with suitable skill, knowledge, and experience to oversee the service, evaluate its adequacy, and accept responsibility for the statements. Because Hill's owner and board lack the necessary accounting competence, only the appointment of a qualified controller satisfies that requirement and preserves independence.
Why not A: This is tempting because separating staff and adding an internal review sounds like a safeguard against self-review. However, internal staffing and partner review do not transfer management responsibility to the client nor provide a competent client designee to oversee and accept responsibility, so independence remains impaired.
Why not B: A signed representation letter may look like client acceptance, which is why this option tempts. But a signature does not establish the owner's accounting competence, and authorizing the firm to determine disclosures would shift management responsibility to the auditor, which impairs independence.
Why not D: Governance review can appear to provide oversight and is therefore tempting. However, mere review, especially when the board lacks accounting expertise and has not been designated to oversee, evaluate, and accept responsibility, does not meet the AICPA requirement and does not preserve independence.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on the limiting conditions for nonattest services: who keeps responsibility for the records and whether the client is an issuer or a nonissuer.
Answer D. Under the AICPA independence rules, certain nonattest services such as some bookkeeping may be provided to a nonissuer attest client without impairing independence if management accepts responsibility for the results, designates a competent individual to oversee the service, and the CPA does not assume management functions. The facts state that management oversees, approves, and accepts responsibility for the records and the firm does not take on management duties; therefore independence is not impaired solely by performing the bookkeeping.
Why not A: This choice reflects scope confusion with issuer (PCAOB) restrictions. For issuers restrictions are stricter, but for privately held nonissuer attest clients the AICPA permits some bookkeeping services when the client accepts responsibility and the CPA does not assume management duties.
Why not B: This is tempting because of the self-review concern, but it overstates the rule. The AICPA does not impose a blanket ban on all bookkeeping for nonissuer attest clients when management retains responsibility and appropriate safeguards exist.
Why not C: Materiality is not the primary limiting condition here. Independence depends on whether management retains responsibility and the CPA avoids management functions; entries being immaterial alone does not determine whether the service impairs independence.
Common questions
What does suitable SKE mean for AICPA nonattest services?
It means suitable skill, knowledge, and experience to oversee the service and evaluate its adequacy and results. Hill's owner's signature cannot replace that ability.
Can an auditor prepare a nonissuer client's financial statements?
Yes, when the client provides capable oversight, makes management decisions, evaluates the work, and accepts responsibility. The CPA must document the understanding and must not assume management responsibilities.
What must the CPA document for a nonattest service?
Document the objectives, services to be performed, client's acceptance of its responsibilities, CPA's responsibilities, and any engagement limitations. Establish this written understanding before providing the service.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Ethics and Independence and Professional Conduct, worked step by step.
Covered Members and Financial Interests | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Ethics and Independence and Professional Conduct
All Ethics and Independence and Professional Conduct practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.