PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Ethics and Professional Responsibilities and General Principles · 6 practice questions

AICPA Nonattest Services: Client SKE and Oversight

For a nonissuer attest client, permitted nonattest work requires capable client oversight, client responsibility, and a documented understanding, without the CPA assuming management duties. Use this checklist to evaluate a financial statement preparation request.

The ruleA nonissuer attest client must designate an individual with suitable SKE, make management decisions, evaluate the nonattest service, and accept responsibility. The CPA must document the understanding and avoid management responsibilities.

Try one first

A CPA firm is performing a financial statement audit of a private company under AICPA independence rules. In addition to the audit, the firm prepares the draft year-end financial statements and proposes adjusting journal entries. The client's controller has suitable skill, knowledge, and experience, reviews and approves the financial statements and all proposed entries, and accepts responsibility for them. The firm does not authorize transactions or otherwise assume management responsibilities, and assume all required nonattest-service safeguards are in place. Which conclusion is most appropriate regarding the firm's independence?
Hint

Focus on whether the CPA crossed into a management role, not merely on whether the CPA helped with the financial statements or proposed entries.

Step by step

  1. Identify the requested service

    Hill, a nonissuer audit client under AICPA rules, asks the firm to prepare year-end financial statements and disclosures from its adjusted trial balance. This creates a self-review concern, but the service is not automatically prohibited.

  2. Check client SKE

    Hill's owner and board lack the ability to oversee the service. Hill must designate someone, such as a qualified controller, with suitable skill, knowledge, and experience (SKE) to provide that oversight.

  3. Keep responsibility with Hill

    Hill must make all management decisions, evaluate the service's adequacy and results, and accept responsibility for the statements. The CPA may draft statements and disclosures but cannot take over Hill's significant judgments.

  4. Document the understanding

    Before providing the service, the CPA must document the understanding in writing. Include the objectives, services, Hill's acceptance of its responsibilities, the CPA's responsibilities, and any engagement limitations.

  5. Reject substitutes for client oversight

    An owner's signature, separate firm staff, or partner review cannot replace capable client oversight. Without a client designee able to oversee and evaluate the service, independence is impaired even for drafting statements.

  6. Reach the independence conclusion

    If Hill designates a capable controller and all required conditions are met, the firm may prepare the statements without impairing independence. The key is who oversees the work and makes management decisions, not who prepares the draft.

Key points

  • Remember: The CPA may prepare statements, but a capable client designee must oversee the work and accept responsibility.
  • Preparing a draft is not the same as making the client's significant judgments.
  • A self-review concern does not automatically prohibit this preparation service under AICPA rules.

How the exam traps you

  • The owner's signature proves adequate client oversight. Require suitable SKE and actual oversight, evaluation, and acceptance of responsibility.
  • Separate firm staff can replace a capable client designee. Firm staffing and internal review do not satisfy the client's oversight responsibilities.
  • Client approval eliminates the need to document the understanding. Document the nonattest-service understanding in writing before providing the service.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

West & Co., CPAs, audits Lake Company, a privately held business. For this question, apply AICPA independence rules only and assume Lake's management has agreed to accept responsibility for any nonattest service, has the skill, knowledge, and experience to oversee it, and will review and approve all significant judgments. Which additional service could West perform without impairing independence?
Hint

Focus on the line between assisting management and acting as management. A permitted nonattest service cannot give the CPA authority over client decisions, personnel, or assets.

Question 3

Gray & Co. audits Redd Co., a private company. Redd's controller resigns shortly before year-end, and management asks Gray to provide interim assistance until a replacement is hired. Assume the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct applies (no SEC or PCAOB rules). Also assume Redd will designate an individual with suitable skill, knowledge, and experience to oversee any permitted nonattest service, evaluate the results, and accept responsibility for them. Which service could Gray perform without impairing independence?
Hint

Ask whether the firm's action would require making management decisions or controlling client assets/staff versus preparing information that management (or its designated individual) will oversee and accept.

Question 4

A CPA firm audits Lake Co., a privately held company. In Year 2, Lake asks the firm to process its payroll and prepare related payroll tax filings. Assume Lake determines employee classifications, pay rates, and other key payroll decisions before the firm performs the service, and no other independence issues exist. Under the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, the firm's independence would be preserved only if which additional condition is met?
Hint

Focus on who must remain responsible for a nonattest service provided to an attest client.

Question 5

Assume Hill Co. is a nonissuer and the firm's independence is evaluated solely under the AICPA Code. The firm performs Hill's annual audit and is asked to prepare Hill's year-end financial statements and note disclosures from Hill's adjusted trial balance as a nonattest service. The firm will document the understanding before the work begins. Hill's owner is willing to sign the final statements but lacks accounting competence, and Hill's board (those charged with governance) also lack accounting expertise. Which additional fact would allow the firm to perform the financial statement preparation service without impairing independence?
Hint

Focus on what the client must do, who must oversee and accept responsibility for the nonattest service, and whether that person has the required accounting competence.

Question 6

A CPA firm performs the annual audit of a privately held, nonissuer client. During the engagement, the client asks the firm to post routine journal entries to the general ledger based on information prepared and approved by client management. Assume client management designates a competent individual to oversee the service, evaluates the results, and accepts responsibility for the books and records. The CPA firm does not authorize transactions or assume any management responsibilities. Under the AICPA independence rules, which conclusion is most appropriate?
Hint

Focus on the limiting conditions for nonattest services: who keeps responsibility for the records and whether the client is an issuer or a nonissuer.

Drill all 90 Ethics and Independence and Professional Conduct questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

What does suitable SKE mean for AICPA nonattest services?

It means suitable skill, knowledge, and experience to oversee the service and evaluate its adequacy and results. Hill's owner's signature cannot replace that ability.

Can an auditor prepare a nonissuer client's financial statements?

Yes, when the client provides capable oversight, makes management decisions, evaluates the work, and accepts responsibility. The CPA must document the understanding and must not assume management responsibilities.

What must the CPA document for a nonattest service?

Document the objectives, services to be performed, client's acceptance of its responsibilities, CPA's responsibilities, and any engagement limitations. Establish this written understanding before providing the service.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Ethics and Independence and Professional Conduct, worked step by step.

Covered Members and Financial Interests | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Ethics and Independence and Professional Conduct

All Ethics and Independence and Professional Conduct practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.