AUD · Ethics and Professional Responsibilities and General Principles · 13 practice questions
AICPA Nonattest Services: Assistance vs. Management Decisions
Under AICPA rules, a CPA impairs independence by making management decisions for a nonissuer audit client. Below, the same depreciation entry shows how changing who decides or posts changes the independence analysis.
Try one first
Hint
Separate services that help management from services that require the CPA to make management's decision.
Answer B. AICPA independence rules permit certain nonattest services for nonissuers only when management assumes responsibility for the service and designates an individual to oversee, evaluate, and accept responsibility for the results. Deciding which adjusting entries the client should record is a management decision; because the firm would be making that decision and no client representative has been designated to evaluate the entries, independence is impaired.
Why not A: This is tempting because preparing schedules and drafting financial statements can be permissible when the client accepts responsibility. However, the additional service of deciding which entries to record is a management function that impairs independence.
Why not C: A written understanding is required for allowable nonattest services, but it cannot cure the firm performing substantive management functions. If the CPA decides which entries will be recorded, the engagement crosses the line regardless of a client acknowledgment.
Why not D: Posting entries is mechanical, but the disqualifying action is the firm making the determination about which entries to record. That decision alone represents a management responsibility that impairs independence.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Lane audits Harbor, a nonissuer, under AICPA rules. Harbor's designated controller has suitable skill, knowledge, and experience and oversees, evaluates, and accepts responsibility for nonattest services. Required understandings are documented. Lane calculates depreciation using management-selected methods and useful lives and proposes an entry. The controller specifically approves the entry, which Harbor's staff posts.
Answer: Independence is not impaired by this service.
Lane performs the calculation and proposes the entry. Management selects the methods and useful lives, approves the entry, and retains responsibility under the stated oversight.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1Lane, rather than management, selects the useful lives.
Answer: Independence is impaired.
Selecting useful lives is a management decision. The controller's oversight and approval of the resulting entry cannot cure Lane's assumption of that responsibility.
Change 2Lane, not the controller, makes the final decision to record the entry.
Answer: Independence is impaired.
Deciding whether to record the entry is a management responsibility. Lane need not also post the entry to impair independence.
Change 3Lane posts the entry instead of Harbor's staff, after the controller specifically approves it.
Answer: Independence is not impaired by this service.
Changing who posts does not impair independence here. Lane implements the controller's approved decision rather than making it.
Key points
- Remember: The key is who decides, not who calculates or posts the approved entry.
- The designated controller must oversee the work, evaluate its results, and accept responsibility.
- Documented understandings do not let Lane take over the controller's decisions.
How the exam traps you
- Treating competent oversight and documentation as permission for Lane to decide. These requirements support permissible assistance; they cannot cure Lane's selection of useful lives or recording decisions.
- Assuming independence is impaired only if Lane both selects and posts the entry. Deciding whether the entry should be recorded is enough, even if Harbor posts it.
- Assuming any posting by the audit firm impairs independence. Lane may post the entry after the controller specifically approves it and retains responsibility.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer A. Correct. Management makes the decisions, approves the entry, and provides the required oversight.
Why not B: Incorrect. Management, not Lane, selects the useful lives.
Why not C: Incorrect. Lane proposes the entry; the controller decides whether it is recorded.
Why not D: Incorrect. Calculations and management-approved posting can be permissible nonattest assistance.
Question 2
Answer B. Correct. Selecting useful lives is a management decision, even when the controller approves the entry.
Why not A: Incorrect. Management oversight cannot cure Lane's selection of useful lives.
Why not C: Incorrect. The controller still makes the recording decision.
Why not D: Incorrect. Calculation or approved posting alone does not impair independence; choosing useful lives does.
Question 3
Answer C. Correct. Deciding whether to record the entry is a management responsibility, even when Harbor's staff posts it.
Why not A: Incorrect. Lane has taken over the controller's recording decision.
Why not B: Incorrect. Management still selects the useful lives.
Why not D: Incorrect. The prohibited act is deciding what to record, not merely calculating or posting.
Question 4
Answer A. Correct. Management selects the methods and useful lives and approves the entry; Lane only calculates and posts under the stated oversight.
Why not B: Incorrect. Management, not Lane, selects the useful lives.
Why not C: Incorrect. The controller specifically approves the entry before Lane posts it.
Why not D: Incorrect. Posting a specifically approved entry can be permitted under AICPA rules.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on the line between assisting management and actually performing a management function.
Answer B. Under AICPA independence rules for nonissuer clients, auditors may perform certain nonattest services if management retains responsibility for the results and oversight. However, independence is impaired if the auditor assumes management responsibilities. Approving credit memos and authorizing receivable write-offs are decisions that belong to management, so performing those tasks would impair independence even with a designated CFO overseeing services.
Why not A: This is tempting because preparing financial statements sounds like a core management task; however, drafting is generally permissible for a nonissuer if management provides the trial balance, reviews and approves the final statements, and accepts responsibility, so independence is not automatically impaired here.
Why not C: Reconciling accounts and proposing corrections can seem like doing the client's accounting, but when management retains the decision to record entries and accepts responsibility for the results, the auditor is assisting rather than acting as management, so independence is preserved.
Why not D: Candidates may worry that depreciation involves judgment, but the auditor is only performing mechanics and proposing entries; because management selected the significant assumptions and approves the entries, the auditor is not assuming management responsibility and independence is not impaired.
Question 3
Hint
Separate routine processing from decisions that belong to management.
Answer D. Under the AICPA Code, a firm may perform certain nonattest services for a nonissuer if management accepts responsibility for the service and the firm does not assume management responsibilities. Lane went beyond routine processing by determining which employees should be reclassified under the new overtime rule, a decision that belongs to management. Because Lane assumed that management responsibility, independence is impaired despite client approval of payroll outputs and a documented understanding.
Why not A: Tempting because client acceptance and documentation are required safeguards for permitted nonattest services. However, those safeguards do not cure a situation in which the CPA actually makes a management decision; approving the final payroll register does not negate that Lane decided classifications.
Why not B: Payroll processing can be permissible when management retains responsibility. The facts here go beyond mechanical processing, Lane determined which employees must be reclassified under the new rule, which crosses into management responsibility and impairs independence.
Why not C: This overgeneralizes. For a nonissuer under the AICPA Code, payroll services are not automatically prohibited if management retains responsibility and the firm does not assume management functions. The impairment here arises from Lane's specific managerial decision, not from payroll services per se.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on which activities cross the line from assisting or advising management to actually making management's decisions or taking responsibility for them.
Answer D. Under AICPA independence guidance for nonattest services, a firm may perform preparatory or advisory tasks when management provides oversight and accepts responsibility. However, deciding which entries to record and authorizing their posting are management functions; performing those actions means the firm is assuming management responsibilities and would impair independence.
Why not A: Tempts because preparing financial statements sounds like creating the client's financials, but it's a permissible nonattest service if management (here, the controller) reviews, evaluates, and accepts responsibility and the required engagement documentation is in place; under those facts independence is not impaired.
Why not B: Tempts because computing depreciation is a substantive accounting calculation; however, when the firm is applying methods and useful lives that management selected and management accepts responsibility and oversight, the firm is implementing management's decisions rather than making them, so independence is not impaired.
Why not C: Tempts because recommending adjustments is close to affecting recorded amounts, but it is an advisory activity; if management reviews the recommendations and makes the final decision to record or reject them (as the stem indicates), the firm is not performing management and independence is preserved.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on whether the auditor is helping management carry out its decisions or is actually making management's accounting decisions.
Answer D. Selecting assumptions and the methodology and determining the amount to record for a significant accounting estimate places the auditor in a management role. Under the AICPA Code for a nonissuer, nonattest services are permissible only if management retains responsibility; actually making those estimate decisions impairs independence.
Why not A: This appears like bookkeeping, but the stem specifies that management (via the CFO) will establish policies (thresholds and useful lives), oversee the work, and accept responsibility. Applying management-established policies mechanically does not by itself constitute assuming management responsibility.
Why not B: Preparing drafts can create a self-review threat, but for a nonissuer it is permitted if management retains responsibility, reviews and approves the drafts, and does not delegate its decision-making to the auditor, facts the stem provides.
Why not C: Proposing adjusting entries is often tempting to treat as impairment, but because the CFO will evaluate and approve the entries before posting, the auditor is assisting rather than substituting for management's judgment; that assistance alone does not necessarily impair independence for a nonissuer under the stated facts.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on who selects and approves key accounting judgments and who actually records or directs recording of entries.
Answer B. Independence is impaired when the practitioner effectively assumes management responsibilities. Selecting which adjusting entries to record and directing client personnel to record them without management review or approval means the firm is making and executing management decisions rather than assisting; this negates the stem's safeguard of management oversight and therefore impairs independence under the AICPA Code for a nonissuer.
Why not A: This option tempts because drafting financial statements seems close to 'doing management's work.' However, for a nonissuer the service is permissible when management provides the underlying information, reviews and approves the statements, and accepts responsibility; the option explicitly states those safeguards, so independence is not impaired.
Why not C: Preparing reconciliations and proposed entries can seem close to executing accounting tasks, which makes this tempting. But because the firm is only preparing proposals and management is the one to review, approve, and record them, the firm is assisting management rather than assuming management responsibility, so independence is not impaired.
Why not D: This distractor tempts by describing the firm recommending accounting choices. It fails, though, because management, not the firm, selects and approves the methods and directs posting; when management makes the key judgments and accepts responsibility, the practitioner's assistance does not amount to assuming management responsibilities.
Question 7
Hint
Focus less on whether the task is accounting-related and more on who is making the final accounting decision.
Answer D. Under the AICPA Code, independence is impaired when a CPA assumes management responsibilities for an attest client. Deciding which accrual to record and determining the final amount requires the firm to make management judgments and choices rather than providing mechanical or advisory assistance. The listed safeguards (management oversight, acceptance of responsibility, documentation) cannot cure a service in which the firm actually makes management decisions, so option C impairs independence.
Why not A: This is tempting because depreciation uses judgment, but if management selects the policies and assumptions and accepts responsibility for the results, preparing the schedule is calculation assistance rather than assuming management responsibility and does not necessarily impair independence.
Why not B: Converting records into accrual-basis financial statements can be a permissible nonattest service for a nonissuer when management oversees the work, evaluates the results, and accepts responsibility, as the stem specifies; the conversion alone does not mean the CPA assumed management responsibility.
Why not C: Drafting proposed entries is advisory; as long as management reviews, approves or rejects, and makes the final decisions, the firm is not taking on management responsibility and independence is not necessarily impaired.
Question 8
Hint
Separate routine nonattest assistance from decisions management must make itself, and focus on whether the client can adequately oversee the service.
Answer D. Under the AICPA Code, nonaudit/nonattest services may be provided only if the client designates a person with suitable skill, knowledge, and experience to oversee the service, accepts responsibility for the results, and does not allow the auditor to assume management functions. Here, Atlas did not designate such a person, and the CEO specifically asked Rivera to decide which invoices to accrue, a management judgment. Those facts make independence impaired.
Why not A: This is tempting because students often equate later approval with sufficient oversight. However, mere sign-off after the auditor has effectively made key accounting decisions does not satisfy the oversight requirement and cannot cure the auditor's assumption of management responsibilities.
Why not B: While those services can be permissible for private-company clients, permissibility depends on the client meeting the oversight and responsibility requirements and the auditor not assuming management decisions. The stem's facts (no designated competent client overseer and the CEO asking Rivera to decide accruals) place this situation outside the permissible scope.
Why not C: This distractor hinges on posting as the decisive act, but independence can be impaired by the auditor performing management functions (such as deciding which liabilities to record) even before any posting occurs. The problem is the assumption of management judgment without adequate client oversight.
Question 9
Hint
Focus on which service would require the CPA to make or carry out management decisions rather than merely perform calculations or provide proposals.
Answer A. Choice A impairs independence because it requires the CPA to make and implement management decisions, selecting which credit memos to issue and executing reductions to accounts receivable. AICPA independence rules for nonissuers permit many nonattest services only when management retains responsibility and oversight; a CPA may not make or authorize management decisions or transactions.
Why not B: This choice tempts because preparing adjusting entries may appear to involve making accounting decisions. It is incorrect here because the CPA is only proposing entries, management will review, approve, and decide whether to record them, so the CPA is not making or authorizing management decisions.
Why not C: This option tempts because drafting the financial statements can create a self-review threat. It fails here because the stem states management provided the underlying trial balance and disclosures and will oversee and accept responsibility; under AICPA rules that circumstance permits the CPA to draft the statements as a nonattest service without assuming management's role.
Why not D: This option tempts because depreciation involves accounting computations and could involve judgment about useful lives. It fails because the task, as described, uses management-approved policies and records; the CPA is performing a mechanical calculation and preparing schedules while management retains responsibility, so independence is not impaired.
Common questions
Can an auditor calculate depreciation for an audit client?
Yes, under AICPA rules for a nonissuer, when management selects the methods and useful lives and the nonattest-service requirements are met. In Harbor's case, Lane calculates the amount while the controller oversees the service and approves the entry.
Can a CPA choose useful lives if the client's controller reviews the work?
No. Making the final selection of useful lives is a management decision, and the controller's review does not cure Lane's assumption of that responsibility.
Can an auditor post adjusting journal entries for a client?
Yes, under the stated AICPA nonissuer conditions, Lane may post the entry after Harbor's controller specifically approves it. Deciding whether the entry should be recorded is different and impairs independence.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Ethics and Independence and Professional Conduct, worked step by step.
Covered Members and Financial Interests | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Ethics and Independence and Professional Conduct
All Ethics and Independence and Professional Conduct practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.