PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Ethics and Professional Responsibilities and General Principles · 13 practice questions

AICPA Nonattest Services: Assistance vs. Management Decisions

Under AICPA rules, a CPA impairs independence by making management decisions for a nonissuer audit client. Below, the same depreciation entry shows how changing who decides or posts changes the independence analysis.

The ruleCalculating depreciation using management-selected methods and useful lives or posting management-approved entries can be permitted under AICPA rules. Selecting those lives or deciding whether to record the entry impairs independence, even with competent oversight and documentation.

Try one first

Reno, CPA, is the engagement partner on the audit of Harbor Co., a nonissuer. Harbor asks Reno's firm to (1) prepare a year-end depreciation schedule from Harbor's fixed-asset records, (2) draft Harbor's financial statements from Harbor's adjusted trial balance, and (3) decide which of the firm's proposed adjusting journal entries Harbor should record before the financial statements are issued. Harbor's owner will sign the financial statements, but no one at Harbor has been designated to evaluate the proposed entries before they are posted. Under the AICPA independence rules, which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Separate services that help management from services that require the CPA to make management's decision.

Same scenario, one fact changes

Base case

Lane audits Harbor, a nonissuer, under AICPA rules. Harbor's designated controller has suitable skill, knowledge, and experience and oversees, evaluates, and accepts responsibility for nonattest services. Required understandings are documented. Lane calculates depreciation using management-selected methods and useful lives and proposes an entry. The controller specifically approves the entry, which Harbor's staff posts.

Answer: Independence is not impaired by this service.

Lane performs the calculation and proposes the entry. Management selects the methods and useful lives, approves the entry, and retains responsibility under the stated oversight.

Before you open each one, predict the answer.

Change 1Lane, rather than management, selects the useful lives.

Answer: Independence is impaired.

Selecting useful lives is a management decision. The controller's oversight and approval of the resulting entry cannot cure Lane's assumption of that responsibility.

Change 2Lane, not the controller, makes the final decision to record the entry.

Answer: Independence is impaired.

Deciding whether to record the entry is a management responsibility. Lane need not also post the entry to impair independence.

Change 3Lane posts the entry instead of Harbor's staff, after the controller specifically approves it.

Answer: Independence is not impaired by this service.

Changing who posts does not impair independence here. Lane implements the controller's approved decision rather than making it.

Key points

  • Remember: The key is who decides, not who calculates or posts the approved entry.
  • The designated controller must oversee the work, evaluate its results, and accept responsibility.
  • Documented understandings do not let Lane take over the controller's decisions.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating competent oversight and documentation as permission for Lane to decide. These requirements support permissible assistance; they cannot cure Lane's selection of useful lives or recording decisions.
  • Assuming independence is impaired only if Lane both selects and posts the entry. Deciding whether the entry should be recorded is enough, even if Harbor posts it.
  • Assuming any posting by the audit firm impairs independence. Lane may post the entry after the controller specifically approves it and retains responsibility.

Now the same facts as questions

Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.

Question 1

Lane audits Harbor, a nonissuer, under AICPA rules. Harbor's designated controller has suitable skill, knowledge, and experience and oversees, evaluates, and accepts responsibility for nonattest services. Required understandings are documented. Lane calculates depreciation using management-selected methods and useful lives and proposes an entry. The controller specifically approves the entry, which Harbor's staff posts. Does this service impair Lane's independence?

Question 2

Same facts, except Lane selects the useful lives instead of management. Does this service impair Lane's independence?

Question 3

Same facts, except Lane makes the final decision to record the entry instead of the controller. Does this service impair Lane's independence?

Question 4

Same facts, except Lane posts the entry instead of Harbor's staff, after the controller specifically approves it. Does this service impair Lane's independence?

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Smith & Cole, CPAs, audits a privately held company and applies the AICPA independence rules. The client has designated a competent CFO to oversee any permitted nonattest services, evaluate the adequacy and results of those services, and accept responsibility for them. Which additional request would most likely impair Smith & Cole's independence?
Hint

Focus on the line between assisting management and actually performing a management function.

Question 3

Lane, CPA, audits a nonissuer and applies the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct. In Year 1, Lane also provides payroll-processing services to the audit client. The client's controller approves employee hires, pay rates, hours worked, and the final payroll register each pay period, and Lane documents the required understanding for the nonattest service. Midyear, a new overtime rule affects some positions. Instead of asking management to decide which positions are covered, Lane determines which employees must be reclassified and tells client personnel to change those classifications in the payroll system. Based on these facts alone, which conclusion is most appropriate?
Hint

Separate routine processing from decisions that belong to management.

Question 4

Rios, CPA, audits Pine Co., a nonissuer, under AICPA standards. During Year 2, Pine requests that Rios's firm perform certain nonattest services. Pine designates its controller, who has suitable skill, knowledge, and experience, to oversee the services, review the work, evaluate the adequacy and results, and accept responsibility. Assume all required engagement understandings and documentation are in place and no other independence issues exist. Which additional service by the firm would most likely impair independence with respect to Pine?
Hint

Focus on which activities cross the line from assisting or advising management to actually making management's decisions or taking responsibility for them.

Question 5

Holt & Co. will audit Raven Co., a privately held nonissuer, for Year 2. Raven is not subject to SEC or PCAOB independence rules. Raven's CFO has suitable skill, knowledge, and experience to oversee nonattest services, will accept responsibility for them, and will review and approve all significant judgments and entries before they are recorded. Under the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, which additional service would still impair Holt's independence?
Hint

Focus on whether the auditor is helping management carry out its decisions or is actually making management's accounting decisions.

Question 6

Harper & Co. audits Maple Co., a nonissuer, and also performs certain nonattest services for Maple. Assume, unless an option states otherwise, that Maple's management designates an appropriate employee to oversee the nonattest services, evaluates the adequacy and results of those services, and accepts responsibility for the services and the financial statements. Under the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, which additional service would impair Harper's independence?
Hint

Focus on who selects and approves key accounting judgments and who actually records or directs recording of entries.

Question 7

A CPA firm performs the annual audit of Apex Co., a private company that is not an SEC issuer. Apex asks the firm to assist with several year-end accounting tasks. Assume all otherwise required AICPA nonattest-service safeguards will be satisfied: Apex will designate an individual with suitable skill, knowledge, and experience to oversee the services, evaluate the adequacy and results, and accept responsibility for all decisions, and the firm will document its understanding with Apex. Which requested service would still impair the firm's independence because it exceeds the limiting condition on permissible nonattest services?
Hint

Focus less on whether the task is accounting-related and more on who is making the final accounting decision.

Question 8

Rivera, CPA, audits Atlas Co., a privately held company. Shortly before year-end, Atlas's controller resigns. Atlas asks Rivera's firm to help with the close by preparing bank reconciliations, drafting the financial statements, and proposing adjusting entries. Atlas has not designated anyone with suitable skill, knowledge, and experience to oversee this work, and the CEO tells Rivera to decide which unpaid vendor invoices should be accrued at year-end and include those accruals in the draft books for the CEO's sign-off. Assume only the AICPA independence rules apply. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Separate routine nonattest assistance from decisions management must make itself, and focus on whether the client can adequately oversee the service.

Question 9

Linton, CPA, audits Green Co., a privately held nonissuer under AICPA independence rules. Green's controller has suitable skill, knowledge, and experience and agrees to oversee, evaluate, and accept responsibility for any nonattest services. Assuming no other independence issues exist, which additional service by Linton would impair independence?
Hint

Focus on which service would require the CPA to make or carry out management decisions rather than merely perform calculations or provide proposals.

Drill all 90 Ethics and Independence and Professional Conduct questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Can an auditor calculate depreciation for an audit client?

Yes, under AICPA rules for a nonissuer, when management selects the methods and useful lives and the nonattest-service requirements are met. In Harbor's case, Lane calculates the amount while the controller oversees the service and approves the entry.

Can a CPA choose useful lives if the client's controller reviews the work?

No. Making the final selection of useful lives is a management decision, and the controller's review does not cure Lane's assumption of that responsibility.

Can an auditor post adjusting journal entries for a client?

Yes, under the stated AICPA nonissuer conditions, Lane may post the entry after Harbor's controller specifically approves it. Deciding whether the entry should be recorded is different and impairs independence.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Ethics and Independence and Professional Conduct, worked step by step.

Covered Members and Financial Interests | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Ethics and Independence and Professional Conduct

All Ethics and Independence and Professional Conduct practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.