PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 9 practice questions

Significant Revenue Risk: When Tests of Details Are Required

A substantive-only response to a significant risk must include tests of details specifically responsive to that risk. Below, follow Orion’s year-end fictitious-revenue risk from assessment to the required audit response.

The ruleUnder AU-C 330, significant risks require specifically responsive substantive procedures. When the response is substantive only, those procedures must include tests of details; substantive analytical procedures alone are insufficient.

Try one first

During planning for the Year 2 audit of Helix Electronics, the auditor identifies a significant risk of material misstatement related to revenue recognition. The prior year included several late-year shipping adjustments, management bonuses are tied to meeting revenue targets, and there is no independent review of sales cutoff procedures. Which of the following is the most appropriate auditor response?
Hint

For significant (including fraud-related) risks, think about what auditors change, nature, timing, and extent of procedures, rather than relying on representations or single corrective actions.

Step by step

  1. Pin down Orion’s risk

    Orion’s controller can post manual sales journal entries at year-end, creating a significant risk of fictitious revenue. The auditor does not plan to rely on controls over those entries.

  2. Apply the substantive-only requirement

    The response must include tests of details specifically directed at the fictitious-revenue risk. Substantive analytical procedures alone cannot satisfy this requirement.

  3. Target the year-end entries

    Select year-end sales journal entries for direct testing because that is where Orion’s identified risk lies. Interim analytics do not directly test those period-end postings.

  4. Inspect support for recorded sales

    Compare selected entries with supporting contracts and shipping documents. Determine whether the evidence supports genuine sales recorded in the proper period.

  5. Reject substitutes for direct evidence

    Management’s statement that entries receive review after posting does not replace responsive substantive testing. Plan the tests now rather than waiting until final review to address the risk.

Key points

  • Remember: A substantive-only response to significant risk needs direct testing, not just a convincing revenue trend.
  • Match the procedure to the suspected misstatement: fictitious revenue calls for evidence supporting recorded sales.
  • Focus Orion’s testing on year-end because that is when the suspected entries occur.

How the exam traps you

  • Use only interim analytics because revenue is recurring. Test selected year-end sales entries and supporting documents directly; interim trends may miss fictitious period-end entries.
  • Wait until final review to address the fraud risk. Plan responsive tests of details now rather than treating final review as the primary response.
  • Reduce testing because management says entries are reviewed after posting. Orion’s plan assumes no control reliance. Management’s assertion does not replace substantive tests of details responsive to the fictitious-revenue risk.

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

An auditor plans to use substantive analytical procedures as the primary substantive procedure to test the year‑end valuation assertion for a material inventory balance. Which of the following exceptions or limiting conditions would most strongly indicate that substantive analytical procedures alone are inadequate and that tests of details are required?
Hint

Ask whether objective, reliable data and predictable relationships exist for valuation, if valuation depends on subjective estimates or missing documentation, analytics alone will likely be insufficient.

Question 3

An auditor is planning the Year 2 audit of a manufacturing client. Inventory is 57% of total assets and is material. The client implemented a new ERP inventory‑costing module at the start of Year 2 and did not complete parallel testing before cutover. During Year 2, inventory turnover declined and management uses a standard‑costing system requiring significant estimates for scrap rates and obsolescence. Management compensation includes a substantial bonus tied to Year 2 gross margin. Based on these facts, which planned audit response is most appropriate?
Hint

Identify whether the facts indicate a significant risk (material inventory, new system cutover without parallel testing, complex estimates, and management incentives). For a significant risk, are substantive tests of details or primarily analytics/controls usually appropriate?

Question 4

During the 20X6 audit of Apex Co., the auditor assesses the valuation assertion for the year-end sales return reserve as a significant risk because late-year promotional terms created unusual return rights and limited comparable history. The auditor does not plan to rely on the operating effectiveness of controls in this area and believes a well-designed expectation using monthly return data could be highly precise. Assume the auditor has already completed required risk assessment procedures and that substantive procedures alone could, if properly designed, provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence. Which planned response best reflects the limiting condition AU-C 330 places on a substantive-only response to this significant risk?
Hint

Focus on what changes when an assessed assertion-level risk is classified as significant, assuming the auditor is not relying on controls.

Question 5

While planning the audit of Nilo Co., the auditor assesses a higher risk of material misstatement for the valuation assertion of inventory. The risk is concentrated in a new product line that has experienced recent markdowns, and the client's controls over identifying obsolete inventory are informal. The auditor does not plan to rely on those controls. Which planned audit response is most appropriate?
Hint

Match the planned response to the specific assertion and the specific area where the risk is concentrated.

Question 6

The auditor is planning the Year 2 financial statement audit of Bright Retailers. Accounts receivable are material (28% of total assets), and the allowance for doubtful accounts is a significant estimate produced by a management model that applies historical loss rates by customer type. During Year 2, economic conditions deteriorated in regions representing 60% of sales, and management updated the model to weight recent months more heavily. The company implemented automated controls that apply the model's loss rates three months before year-end; the controls have not operated for a full year. Management has incentives to smooth earnings. Based on these facts, which is the most appropriate audit response to the assessed risk of material misstatement for the allowance for doubtful accounts?
Hint

Decide whether the facts indicate a significant estimation risk and whether the automated controls have operated long enough; then choose the appropriate nature, timing, and extent of additional procedures.

Question 7

During planning of the Year 2 audit, the auditor assesses the risk of material misstatement for the warranty liability as high. The company launched a new product late in Year 2, and management's estimate depends heavily on assumptions with limited historical data. Assume the warranty liability is material. What is the correct treatment in planning the auditor's response to this risk?
Hint

Focus on how an auditor should respond when a material accounting estimate has higher assessed risk and significant judgment.

Question 8

You are the lead auditor for Northwind Manufacturing's audit for the year ended December 31, Year 1. Revenue is material and historically recognized at point of shipment. On November 15, Year 1, Northwind implemented a new order management system intended to automate price approvals and tie sales orders to approved price lists; however, the pricing module was not fully enabled and the automated pricing controls were not operating until January 10, Year 2. Preliminary analytical procedures show an unexpected increase in average selling prices and gross margin in November-December Year 1. Walkthroughs revealed that, during Nov-Dec Year 1, price approvals were performed manually by a sales manager who also had authority to enter and ship orders. The auditor has assessed the risk of material misstatement for revenue recognition as heightened given these facts. Which is the most appropriate response by the auditor?
Hint

Decide whether the auditor can rely on the pricing control for the period under audit and whether the facts point to a 'significant risk' that requires tests of details rather than increased control testing or analytics alone.

Question 9

During planning for the audit of Orion Co.'s Year 2 financial statements, the auditor identifies a significant risk of material misstatement due to possible fictitious revenue near year-end. Orion's controller can post manual sales journal entries at period-end, and the auditor does not plan to rely on controls over those entries. Which planned audit response is most appropriate?
Hint

Focus on how the auditor should respond when a significant risk is identified and controls are not being relied upon.

Drill all 93 Assessing and Responding to Risks of Material Misstatement questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Can substantive analytical procedures alone address a significant revenue risk?

Not when the response is substantive only. Orion must include tests of details specifically responsive to the possible fictitious year-end revenue.

What tests of details address fictitious year-end revenue?

Test selected year-end sales journal entries against supporting contracts and shipping documents. Evaluate whether the evidence supports a genuine sale recognized in the proper period.

Does a significant revenue risk require testing every sales transaction?

No. The requirement is responsive tests of details, not examination of every transaction. Orion’s selection should target the identified risk of fictitious year-end entries.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Assessing and Responding to Risks of Material Misstatement, worked step by step.

AUD Simulation: Cutoff, Valuation and Completeness under AU-C 315 on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Assessing and Responding to Risks of Material Misstatement

All Assessing and Responding to Risks of Material Misstatement practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.