AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 9 practice questions
Significant Revenue Risk: When Tests of Details Are Required
A substantive-only response to a significant risk must include tests of details specifically responsive to that risk. Below, follow Orion’s year-end fictitious-revenue risk from assessment to the required audit response.
Try one first
Hint
For significant (including fraud-related) risks, think about what auditors change, nature, timing, and extent of procedures, rather than relying on representations or single corrective actions.
Answer B. A risk assessed as significant (especially with fraud risk indicators) requires more persuasive evidence. The auditor should change the nature, timing, and and extent of procedures, emphasizing tests of details at or near period-end, larger samples, and unpredictable procedures. Tests of controls are only useful if the auditor plans to rely on them and has tested their operating effectiveness.
Why not A: Written representations are required but do not provide substantive evidence to address a significant (or fraud-related) risk; relying on representations without strengthening audit procedures is insufficient.
Why not C: Larger samples reduce sampling risk but do not address issues of timing or the need for more persuasive evidence; significant risks often require changes to nature and timing as well as unpredictable procedures.
Why not D: Management-prepared reconciliations and untested compensating controls cannot be relied on for significant risks; the auditor must evaluate and test the operating effectiveness of new controls before reducing substantive procedures.
Step by step
- Pin down Orion’s risk
Orion’s controller can post manual sales journal entries at year-end, creating a significant risk of fictitious revenue. The auditor does not plan to rely on controls over those entries.
- Apply the substantive-only requirement
The response must include tests of details specifically directed at the fictitious-revenue risk. Substantive analytical procedures alone cannot satisfy this requirement.
- Target the year-end entries
Select year-end sales journal entries for direct testing because that is where Orion’s identified risk lies. Interim analytics do not directly test those period-end postings.
- Inspect support for recorded sales
Compare selected entries with supporting contracts and shipping documents. Determine whether the evidence supports genuine sales recorded in the proper period.
- Reject substitutes for direct evidence
Management’s statement that entries receive review after posting does not replace responsive substantive testing. Plan the tests now rather than waiting until final review to address the risk.
Key points
- Remember: A substantive-only response to significant risk needs direct testing, not just a convincing revenue trend.
- Match the procedure to the suspected misstatement: fictitious revenue calls for evidence supporting recorded sales.
- Focus Orion’s testing on year-end because that is when the suspected entries occur.
How the exam traps you
- Use only interim analytics because revenue is recurring. Test selected year-end sales entries and supporting documents directly; interim trends may miss fictitious period-end entries.
- Wait until final review to address the fraud risk. Plan responsive tests of details now rather than treating final review as the primary response.
- Reduce testing because management says entries are reviewed after posting. Orion’s plan assumes no control reliance. Management’s assertion does not replace substantive tests of details responsive to the fictitious-revenue risk.
Question 2
Hint
Ask whether objective, reliable data and predictable relationships exist for valuation, if valuation depends on subjective estimates or missing documentation, analytics alone will likely be insufficient.
Answer D. Substantive analytical procedures require predictable relationships and reliable, objective data to develop a sufficiently precise expectation. When valuation depends on highly subjective management estimates (such as obsolescence allowances) and corroborating documentation or market evidence is missing for many items, analytics alone cannot provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence. In that circumstance, tests of details (item‑by‑item examination, vendor documentation, and other direct evidence) are required.
Why not A: Although this option sounds concerning, it actually describes strong controls and objective corroboration (stable costing variances and available invoices/price data) that support forming precise analytical expectations, so analytics may be appropriate.
Why not B: Observable market prices and supporting third‑party documentation increase the reliability of analytical evidence rather than limiting it, making substantive analytics more likely to be sufficient.
Why not C: This describes a low‑risk, predictable inventory population with reliable records, conditions under which substantive analytical procedures can be effective, so it does not indicate analytics alone are inadequate.
Question 3
Hint
Identify whether the facts indicate a significant risk (material inventory, new system cutover without parallel testing, complex estimates, and management incentives). For a significant risk, are substantive tests of details or primarily analytics/controls usually appropriate?
Answer D. The materiality of inventory plus the new ERP cutover without completed parallel testing, declining turnover, complex standard‑cost estimates, and management incentives indicate a significant risk of misstatement for valuation and costing. Significant risks require responsive substantive procedures, expanded tests of details at year‑end, detailed testing and independent recalculation of costing and estimates, and specialist involvement, rather than relying primarily on analytics or unproven controls.
Why not A: Tempting because inquiries and subsequent‑sales reviews are quick and may provide some evidence; however, those procedures alone do not provide sufficient appropriate evidence about complex costing methods, estimates, or potential management bias. Specialist input and expanded substantive testing are needed to evaluate valuation and costing.
Why not B: Tempting because analytics are efficient and targeted detail checks can seem sufficient; however, when indicators point to a significant risk (system cutover without parallel testing, complex estimates, and strong management incentives), analytical procedures supplemented by minimal testing do not provide sufficient appropriate evidence, detailed substantive testing is required.
Why not C: Tempting because effective controls can reduce substantive work; however, the ERP was implemented during the year without completed parallel testing and management incentives increase the risk that controls may not operate effectively. For significant risks, particularly involving a new system, auditors generally design substantive tests of details rather than relying primarily on unproven controls.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on what changes when an assessed assertion-level risk is classified as significant, assuming the auditor is not relying on controls.
Answer D. AU-C 330 requires substantive procedures responsive to assessed risks at the assertion level, and when the assessed risk is a significant risk, a substantive-only response must include tests of details. Analytical procedures can still be used as a complement, but they cannot be the sole substantive response for that significant risk.
Why not A: This is tempting because precise analytical procedures can provide strong evidence, but AU-C 330 prevents relying solely on analytical procedures when an assertion-level risk is assessed as significant; tests of details are required as part of a substantive-only response.
Why not B: This confuses risk assessment with further procedures. Identifying a significant risk during planning does not relieve the auditor of designing and performing substantive procedures responsive to that risk; inquiries and walkthroughs alone are insufficient.
Why not C: This distractor plays on overgeneralization. Tests of controls are required only if the auditor intends to rely on controls (or if substantive procedures cannot provide sufficient evidence), not simply because a risk is significant.
Question 5
Hint
Match the planned response to the specific assertion and the specific area where the risk is concentrated.
Answer D. The correct answer is performing more detailed year-end testing of inventory aging and subsequent sales for the new product line using a larger sample size, because when an increased risk of misstatement for valuation is concentrated in a specific product line and the auditor will not rely on controls, the appropriate response is targeted substantive procedures. Detailed testing of aging and subsequent sales for the new product line, with a larger sample, directly addresses possible obsolescence and markdowns and provides persuasive valuation evidence. Broad or control-based approaches would not be as effective for this concentrated risk. Reducing substantive testing because companywide controls appear strong is incorrect. It is wrong because it reduces substantive evidence despite an assessed higher risk in a specific area; strong companywide controls do not eliminate the need for substantive procedures where the risk is concentrated. Inquiries alone are not sufficiently persuasive to address valuation or obsolescence risk. Testing the design of the inventory obsolescence controls and relying on them is incorrect, because the stem states the auditor does not plan to rely on controls. Even if control design appears adequate, mere design assessment without evidence of operating effectiveness does not substitute for substantive procedures when valuation risk is high. Applying broad gross-margin analytical procedures to inventory as a whole is incorrect because broad gross-margin analytics over the entire inventory may miss problems concentrated in a particular product line; analytics at the account level are too general to detect obsolescence and markdowns specific to the new product line. The audit response should be tailored to the high-risk area.
Question 6
Hint
Decide whether the facts indicate a significant estimation risk and whether the automated controls have operated long enough; then choose the appropriate nature, timing, and extent of additional procedures.
Answer B. The allowance's materiality, management's update of the model during deteriorating economic conditions, and incentives to smooth earnings indicate a significant estimation risk. Standards call for increased persuasive evidence for significant risks, expanded substantive procedures at or near year‑end are appropriate: test model inputs and calculations, test subsequent cash receipts, develop an independent estimate, and involve a specialist when assumptions are complex. Newly implemented automated controls that have not operated for a full year do not by themselves justify reducing substantive testing.
Why not A: Tempting because automation can imply reliable controls, but these controls began operating only three months before year‑end and lack demonstrated operating effectiveness; for a significant estimation risk the auditor should not reduce substantive testing solely because controls are automated or new.
Why not C: Tempting because interim analytics are efficient and can detect anomalies, but interim procedures alone are insufficient when recent economic deterioration and management judgment create a significant risk; substantive evidence at or near year‑end (including tests of details and independent estimation) is typically required.
Why not D: Tempting because a specialist provides technical expertise, but a specialist's concurrence does not replace the auditor's responsibility to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence through expanded substantive procedures; relying primarily on the specialist and limiting tests is inappropriate for a significant estimation risk.
Question 7
Hint
Focus on how an auditor should respond when a material accounting estimate has higher assessed risk and significant judgment.
Answer D. When a material accounting estimate has a high assessed risk of material misstatement, the auditor should obtain more persuasive evidence by changing the nature, timing, and extent of procedures. That often includes using more experienced personnel and performing substantive procedures that focus on management's key assumptions and on subsequent claim activity that can corroborate the estimate. These steps are appropriate when limited historical data increases estimation uncertainty for a material warranty liability.
Why not A: Subsequent claims can provide useful corroborating evidence, but the auditor must obtain sufficient appropriate evidence to support the current-period estimate and cannot simply defer evaluation until a later period.
Why not B: Testing controls is useful and can influence the auditor's response, but strong controls generally do not justify eliminating substantive procedures for a material estimate with high assessed risk, especially when the estimate depends heavily on judgment and limited history.
Why not C: Broad analytical procedures alone are typically insufficient for a high-risk, material estimate; the auditor needs more persuasive, detailed substantive evidence when management's assumptions are significant and history is limited.
Question 8
Hint
Decide whether the auditor can rely on the pricing control for the period under audit and whether the facts point to a 'significant risk' that requires tests of details rather than increased control testing or analytics alone.
Answer B. The automated pricing control was not operating during the period under audit and manual approvals were performed by a person with incompatible duties, so the auditor cannot rely on that control. The facts indicate a heightened/ significant risk of material misstatement for revenue recognition, which requires special audit consideration and persuasive tests of details. Responsive procedures should focus on substantive testing (price verification, cutoff, shipping documents, confirmations) for the Nov-Dec period rather than relying on control testing or analytics alone.
Why not A: This is tempting because dual-purpose testing is efficient when controls are in place and operating, but here the automated pricing control was not operating during the period and manual approvals were performed by someone with incompatible duties. You cannot rely on or test the operating effectiveness of a control that wasn't operating for the period, so control testing would not permit reducing substantive procedures.
Why not C: While analytical procedures and future improvements to controls are relevant, they do not address the heightened risk for the period under audit. When risk is significant or heightened, analytical procedures alone are insufficient, more persuasive tests of details are required for the period in question.
Why not D: A control deficiency by itself does not automatically require a modified opinion. A modified opinion is appropriate only if there is a material misstatement that is uncorrected or a scope limitation; the auditor must first perform substantive procedures to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence before considering a modification.
Question 9
Hint
Focus on how the auditor should respond when a significant risk is identified and controls are not being relied upon.
Answer C. When a significant risk is identified, the auditor must plan responses tailored to that risk. Here, the risk is possible fictitious revenue introduced through manual year-end entries, and the auditor is not relying on controls over those entries, so targeted substantive testing of the entries and their supporting documentation is required.
Why not A: Management's explanation or an informal review does not substitute for evidence, and the auditor is not relying on controls. Reducing substantive work based on inquiry alone would be inappropriate for a significant risk.
Why not B: This is tempting because analytics are often used for revenue, but interim procedures and broad analytics may miss manipulations at year-end. A significant risk tied to period-end manual entries needs direct, substantive procedures performed at or near year-end.
Why not D: Although some procedures occur near the end of the audit, responses to identified significant risks must be planned and performed appropriately throughout the audit. Deferring action until final review would be an inadequate planned response.
Common questions
Can substantive analytical procedures alone address a significant revenue risk?
Not when the response is substantive only. Orion must include tests of details specifically responsive to the possible fictitious year-end revenue.
What tests of details address fictitious year-end revenue?
Test selected year-end sales journal entries against supporting contracts and shipping documents. Evaluate whether the evidence supports a genuine sale recognized in the proper period.
Does a significant revenue risk require testing every sales transaction?
No. The requirement is responsive tests of details, not examination of every transaction. Orion’s selection should target the identified risk of fictitious year-end entries.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Assessing and Responding to Risks of Material Misstatement, worked step by step.
AUD Simulation: Cutoff, Valuation and Completeness under AU-C 315 on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Assessing and Responding to Risks of Material Misstatement
- What Determines the Nature, Timing, and Extent of Audit Tests?
- Year-End Revenue Cutoff Audit Procedures
- Inventory Existence: Audit Response to High Risk
All Assessing and Responding to Risks of Material Misstatement practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.