AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 6 practice questions
Year-End Revenue Cutoff Audit Procedures
Higher year-end revenue cutoff risk calls for expanded tests of details around year-end when the auditor does not rely on controls. Below: follow one sale from invoicing through shipment to see why the invoice date does not settle cutoff.
Try one first
Hint
Match the planned procedure to the exact assertion at risk, not just to the account balance involved.
Answer B. Because the assessed risk specifically concerns the cutoff assertion at year-end, the most appropriate response is a substantive procedure that tests transactions around year-end. Inspecting shipping documents and related invoices for transactions recorded just before and just after year-end directly addresses whether revenue was recorded in the correct accounting period.
Why not A: High-level analytical procedures can identify unusual patterns but are not sufficiently focused to test individual transactions around year-end when there is a specific incentive to misstate cutoff; substantive, transaction-level cutoff testing is required.
Why not C: Interim control testing may provide evidence about control operating effectiveness but does not substitute for substantive testing of transactions at or near year-end; controls may not address all cutoff risks or operate identically at year-end.
Why not D: Receivable confirmations provide evidence about existence and valuation but do not directly test whether revenue was recognized in the proper period; they are a weaker primary response to a cutoff risk than inspecting shipping and billing records.
The timeline
- PlanningIdentify Orion's year-end revenue cutoff risk.
Managers earn revenue-based bonuses. The auditor assesses higher cutoff risk and plans no reliance on revenue controls. For the sale below, control transfers when the goods ship.
- Last week of Year 1Plan expanded cutoff testing and assign experienced staff.
Target sales recorded just before and after December 31. Moving most testing to interim would miss the risky boundary; staffing alone would not provide cutoff evidence.
- December 30, Year 1Orion prepares the sales invoice.
The invoice date does not establish that control transferred. The auditor must compare it with shipping evidence and the revenue posting.
- December 31, Year 1Orion records the sale through a manual revenue entry.
Select the entry for detailed testing. Vouch it to the invoice and shipping support rather than accepting its posting date.
- January 2, Year 2The goods ship, and control transfers to the customer.
The sale belongs in Year 2 under the stated terms. Recording it on December 31 overstated Year 1 revenue.
- Year-end fieldworkCompare documents on both sides of December 31.
The December invoice and posting conflict with the January shipping evidence. This is the cutoff error that expanded transaction-level testing is designed to detect.
- Evaluation of resultsEvaluate the cutoff misstatement using the direct evidence.
Receivable confirmations may complement the work, but they do not replace the shipping test or establish that the December revenue entry was timely.
Key points
- Remember: an invoice dated before year-end does not establish that revenue belongs before year-end.
- Concentrated risk calls for more testing at the boundary, not less testing because the risky period is short.
- Experienced staff support the response but do not replace direct cutoff evidence.
How the exam traps you
- Move most testing to interim because year-end is risky. Expand detailed testing around year-end, where the identified risk is concentrated.
- Use receivable confirmations as the primary cutoff test. Inspect shipping evidence and related postings directly; confirmations do not replace cutoff testing.
- Accept the invoice date as the revenue recognition date. Determine when control transferred under the sale's terms and compare that date with the recorded period.
Question 2
Hint
Match the audit response to the level and timing of the risk. Higher risk in a year-end area usually calls for stronger evidence, not less.
Answer B. When the assessed risk of material misstatement is higher and the auditor is not relying on controls, the auditor should increase the nature, timing, and extent of substantive procedures. That includes performing more substantive testing closer to year-end for revenue affected by a new system and manual adjustments, and using more experienced personnel in that higher-risk area.
Why not A: This is tempting because interim testing can improve efficiency, but higher risk around year-end calls for procedures performed closer to period end. Pushing most testing to interim would weaken evidence for fourth-quarter revenue.
Why not C: Inquiry alone does not provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence in a higher-risk area. The auditor needs stronger substantive evidence (e.g., detailed transaction testing, confirmations, and reconciliation review), not just explanations from staff.
Why not D: Prior-year control evidence may lose relevance when the client's billing system changed late in the year, and the question states the auditor will not rely on controls. Therefore reducing procedures based on prior-year control testing would be inappropriate.
Question 3
Hint
For a significant revenue risk involving occurrence and cutoff, think about which procedures give direct evidence about shipments and the timing of revenue recognition rather than relying only on high-level analytics or later cash receipts.
Answer A. Because the auditor assessed a significant risk for revenue occurrence and cutoff, substantive tests of details that directly examine shipping documents, customer orders, and receivable confirmations provide stronger, direct evidence about whether sales actually occurred and were recorded in the correct period. Analytical procedures alone or reliance on controls without evidence of effectiveness are insufficient for significant risks.
Why not B: Analytical procedures are useful for identifying anomalies but provide indirect evidence. When a significant risk (such as possible cutoff or fictitious sales) exists, auditors need direct evidence from tests of details rather than relying solely on analytics.
Why not C: Documented controls alone do not justify reducing assessed control risk without testing their operating effectiveness, particularly when there is evidence of prior control overrides by senior personnel. Relying on controls without evidence would be inappropriate.
Why not D: Subsequent cash receipts can help support existence and collectability but do not directly test whether revenue was recorded in the correct period (cutoff) or whether sales actually occurred at year-end. They can also be misleading if payments were arranged or manipulated.
Question 4
Hint
Match the planned response to the exact risk identified, especially the account and the period where the risk is highest.
Answer B. When there is a heightened risk of revenue cutoff and controls will not be relied upon, the auditor should increase the nature, timing, and extent of substantive procedures focused on the risky period. Examining shipping documents immediately before and after December 31 directly tests whether revenue was recorded in the proper period. This targeted testing provides stronger evidence about individual transactions than broad analytical procedures.
Why not A: Analytical procedures can identify unusual trends but do not provide persuasive evidence about the timing of individual shipments. A specific cutoff risk tied to manual year-end entries requires tests of details (e.g., shipping documents) rather than only annual analytics.
Why not C: Delaying testing does not address the identified elevated risk in the year-end period. The auditor should perform stronger substantive procedures targeted at the high-risk period rather than deferring them.
Why not D: This response misdirects effort to a different account area. The assessed risk is revenue cutoff, so additional testing should focus on revenue transactions and related shipping documentation, not accounts payable.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on how planned audit procedures change when assessed risk is higher and the auditor is not relying on controls.
Answer D. When the auditor assesses a higher risk of material misstatement, the planned response should provide more persuasive audit evidence. For a year-end revenue cutoff risk, that usually means increasing targeted substantive testing of shipments, invoices, and related documents around the balance-sheet date. Because the auditor is not relying on controls, substantive procedures (rather than control testing) are the appropriate response.
Why not A: Significant risks require appropriate responses, which can include tests of controls only if the auditor intends to rely on those controls. Here the auditor is not relying on controls, so substantive procedures are necessary to address the risk.
Why not B: Although the risky transactions are concentrated near year-end, a high assessed risk warrants more, not less, testing. Narrow timing does not justify reducing substantive procedures when risk is high.
Why not C: Analytical procedures can provide useful information but are generally insufficient by themselves for a specific cutoff risk involving recorded sales near year-end. Detailed substantive transaction testing is typically required to verify correct period recognition.
Question 6
Hint
Match the response to the specific assertion at risk, not just to the account area.
Answer A. The risk concerns recognition in the wrong period (cutoff). Because the auditor will not rely on controls, the most appropriate response is a substantive cutoff test: trace sales recorded just before and after year-end to shipping documents to verify whether revenue was recorded in the proper period.
Why not B: While assigning experienced staff and increasing supervision are reasonable responses to elevated overall risk, they do not provide direct evidence about whether sales were recorded in the correct period. The auditor still needs substantive procedures that focus on cutoff.
Why not C: Confirmations address existence and rights/obligations of receivables but are less effective at detecting timing errors concentrated around year-end. They may miss misstatements caused by recording revenue in the wrong period, so cutoff testing is more directly responsive.
Why not D: Inquiry of management can provide context but is insufficient when there is a heightened risk and incentive to misstate. The auditor needs objective substantive evidence (e.g., tracing to shipping documents), not just management explanations.
Common questions
What audit procedures test revenue cutoff at year-end?
Inspect sales recorded just before and after year-end. Compare shipping documents, invoices, and general ledger postings to determine whether each sale belongs in the recorded period.
Why test revenue after year-end if the risk is early recognition?
Post-year-end shipping evidence can reveal sales recorded too early. Orion's January 2 shipment exposes the incorrect December 31 revenue entry.
Do accounts receivable confirmations replace revenue cutoff testing?
No. A confirmed receivable balance does not by itself establish the correct revenue period; Orion's sale still requires evidence of when control transferred.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Assessing and Responding to Risks of Material Misstatement, worked step by step.
AUD Simulation: Cutoff, Valuation and Completeness under AU-C 315 on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Assessing and Responding to Risks of Material Misstatement
- What Determines the Nature, Timing, and Extent of Audit Tests?
- Significant Revenue Risk: When Tests of Details Are Required
- Inventory Existence: Audit Response to High Risk
All Assessing and Responding to Risks of Material Misstatement practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.