PracticeTCPFree practice exam

TCP · Entity Tax Compliance · 13 practice questions

Simple vs. Complex Trust: What Changes the Classification?

An unused power to distribute principal does not prevent simple-trust status, but an actual principal distribution does. Below: one trust scenario, with one fact changed at a time to test the classification.

The ruleA simple trust must require current distribution of all fiduciary accounting income, have no charitable payment or set-aside provision, and distribute no principal that year. An unused power to distribute principal does not disqualify it.

Try one first

For Year 1, which trust is most likely treated as a simple trust for federal income tax purposes, assuming "income" refers to fiduciary accounting income under the governing instrument and applicable state law?
Hint

Test each choice against all of the year-by-year requirements for a simple trust, not just whether income is distributed currently.

Same scenario, one fact changes

Base case

Oak is a domestic nongrantor trust. Its instrument requires all fiduciary accounting income distributed currently, permits discretionary principal distributions, and has no charitable provision. In Year 1, Oak distributes its $30,000 accounting income, retains a $10,000 capital gain allocated to principal under the instrument and state law, and makes no principal distributions or charitable payments or set-asides.

Answer: Oak is a simple trust for Year 1.

All fiduciary accounting income must be distributed currently, there is no charitable provision, and no principal was distributed. Neither the unused principal-distribution power nor the retained capital gain prevents simple-trust status.

Before you open each one, predict the answer.

Change 1Oak also distributes $10,000 of principal to the beneficiary during Year 1.

Answer: Oak is a complex trust for Year 1.

An actual principal distribution prevents simple-trust treatment, even though Oak distributed all required fiduciary accounting income.

Change 2The instrument instead authorizes charitable payments under Section 642(c) from retained capital gains; none are made.

Answer: Oak is a complex trust for Year 1.

The charitable payment provision prevents simple-trust treatment even when unused. It differs from an unused power to distribute principal to the beneficiary.

Change 3The instrument instead allows the trustee to accumulate fiduciary accounting income.

Answer: Oak is a complex trust for Year 1.

Actual payment of the $30,000 does not cure the missing requirement. All fiduciary accounting income must be required to be distributed currently.

Key points

  • Remember: Permission to distribute principal is not the same as actually distributing it.
  • Test classification separately for each tax year.
  • Retained capital gains allocated to principal are not retained fiduciary accounting income.
  • For income, check what the instrument requires; for principal, check what the trustee actually distributed.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating an unused principal-distribution power as an automatic disqualifier. Look for an actual principal distribution during the year.
  • Calling the trust simple because all income was actually paid. The instrument must require current distribution of all fiduciary accounting income.
  • Treating retained capital gains as accumulated fiduciary accounting income. Follow the stated allocation: gains allocated to principal do not alone make the trust complex.

Now the same facts as questions

Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.

Question 1

Oak, a domestic nongrantor trust, must distribute all fiduciary accounting income currently. Its instrument permits discretionary principal distributions and has no charitable provision. In Year 1, Oak distributes $30,000 of accounting income, retains a $10,000 capital gain allocated to principal under the instrument and state law, and makes no principal distributions or charitable payments or set-asides. How is Oak classified?

Question 2

Same facts, except Oak also distributes $10,000 of principal to the beneficiary during Year 1. How is Oak classified?

Question 3

Same facts, except the instrument authorizes charitable payments under Section 642(c) from retained capital gains; none are made. How is Oak classified?

Question 4

Same facts, except the instrument allows the trustee to accumulate fiduciary accounting income. Oak still distributes the full $30,000. How is Oak classified?

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

In Year 1, Birch Trust is a domestic nongrantor trust. Under the governing instrument and applicable local law, all fiduciary accounting income must be distributed currently. During Year 1, Birch had $50,000 of taxable interest, $10,000 of tax-exempt municipal bond interest, and a $20,000 net long-term capital gain allocated to corpus. Birch distributed all fiduciary accounting income to the income beneficiary and also made a separate discretionary $8,000 cash distribution charged to corpus. The capital gain was not paid, credited, or required to be distributed and was not used in determining the amount of any distribution. Assume no charitable amounts and no deductions allocable to tax-exempt interest. Which consequence is most appropriate for Year 1?
Hint

Decide classification (simple vs. complex) first, then apply the DNI carryout conditions to determine whether corpus-allocated capital gains were actually carried out into DNI.

Question 3

For Year 1, Trust Alpha and Trust Beta are domestic nongrantor trusts. Each governing instrument requires all fiduciary accounting income to be distributed currently to an individual beneficiary, contains no provision for charitable payments or set-asides, and had no capital gains allocated to income. Alpha's instrument permits discretionary principal distributions, but none were made in Year 1. Beta's instrument also permits discretionary principal distributions, and the trustee distributed $5,000 of principal to the beneficiary in Year 1. Assume no other distributions or unusual provisions apply. Which statement is most appropriate for Year 1 federal income tax purposes?
Hint

Classify each trust year by year. A power to distribute principal is not the same as actually distributing principal.

Question 4

Assume no grantor trust rules apply. A trust instrument requires all fiduciary accounting income to be distributed currently, and no charitable amounts are involved. Which additional fact would prevent the trust from being treated as a simple trust for Year 1?
Hint

Focus on the year-by-year requirements for simple trust status, especially what the trust may not distribute.

Question 5

Maple Trust is a domestic calendar-year irrevocable trust. Under its governing instrument, all fiduciary accounting income must be distributed currently to Leo. The trustee may also make discretionary principal distributions for Leo's health, education, maintenance, or support. The instrument contains no charitable provision. In Year 1, Maple Trust had $25,000 of fiduciary accounting income and $40,000 of distributable net income (DNI) (all taxable; no capital gains included). The trust distributed the required $25,000 of current income to Leo and also made a discretionary $15,000 distribution from principal to Leo. Assume the $15,000 payment is not a specific bequest under §663(a) and no separate-share rules apply. What are the federal income tax consequences for Year 1?
Hint

Separate (1) whether the trust actually distributed principal during the year (that determines simple vs. complex) and (2) the ordering rule for carrying out DNI, required current income first, then other distributions up to remaining DNI.

Question 6

Oak Trust is an irrevocable nongrantor trust. For Year 1, the trust instrument requires all fiduciary accounting income to be distributed currently to the sole income beneficiary, does not authorize charitable contributions, and does not permit any distributions of corpus. No corpus was distributed during Year 1. For federal income tax purposes, how should Oak Trust be classified for Year 1?
Hint

Use the year-by-year rules for a simple trust and pay attention to any classification the stem expressly rules out.

Question 7

Assume both trusts are domestic nongrantor trusts. Under each trust instrument, all fiduciary accounting income must be distributed currently each year to the sole income beneficiary. Neither instrument authorizes any charitable payment or set-aside. In Year 1, Trust A's trustee had discretion to invade principal for the beneficiary's health, education, maintenance, and support, but no principal was distributed. Trust B actually distributed $8,000 of principal to the beneficiary in Year 1. Under local law, trustee commissions for both trusts were charged to corpus. Which trust, if any, is a simple trust for federal income tax purposes in Year 1?
Hint

Apply the simple trust rules year by year and distinguish between a mere power to distribute principal and an actual principal distribution.

Question 8

Redwood Trust's governing instrument states that all accounting income must be distributed currently to its sole income beneficiary. The instrument permits, but does not require, the trustee to invade principal for that beneficiary's support. Under the governing instrument and applicable local law, capital gains are allocated to corpus. In Year 1, Redwood distributed all accounting income, made no principal distributions, realized capital gains on securities sales, and retained those gains in corpus. Assume Redwood is not a grantor trust, made no charitable distributions or set‑asides, and the trustee did not allocate or treat the capital gains as income or as distributed. For purposes of this question, treat a trust as a simple trust for a year only if (1) it is required to distribute all accounting income currently and (2) no principal was distributed during that year. Which statement is most accurate for Year 1?
Hint

Keep two questions separate: (1) Under the stem's Year‑1 test, was the trust a simple trust? (2) Are capital gains allocated to corpus but retained included in DNI absent an allocation or distribution?

Question 9

In Year 1, the Rose Trust instrument required all fiduciary accounting income to be distributed currently to the sole income beneficiary. The trustee distributed all Year 1 accounting income as required. In addition, the trustee made a separate $8,000 distribution from corpus to pay the beneficiary's medical expenses, as permitted by the governing instrument. The trust made no charitable contributions, and assume no grantor-trust rules apply. For federal income tax purposes, what is the best conclusion about Rose Trust for Year 1?
Hint

A simple trust must satisfy all of its yearly conditions, not just the income-distribution condition.

Drill all 136 Trusts questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Can a simple trust have discretion to distribute principal?

Yes. Oak's unused power does not prevent simple-trust status, but exercising that power makes Oak complex for that year.

Do retained capital gains make a trust complex?

Not by themselves. Oak's gains are allocated to principal under the instrument and state law, so retaining them does not violate the current-income requirement.

Can a trust be simple if it authorizes charitable payments but makes none?

No, if the instrument provides for charitable amounts described in IRC Section 642(c). Unlike an unused principal-distribution power, that charitable provision prevents simple-trust treatment.

Watch it solved

A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on Trusts, worked step by step.

Trust DNI & Distribution Deduction | CPA TCP Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice TCP like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Trusts

All Trusts practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.