TCP · Tax Compliance and Planning for Individuals and Personal Financial Planning · 6 practice questions
Tax Extension: What Must You File and Pay by April 15?
Form 4868 extends the time to file, not the time to pay tax. Below: follow one taxpayer from the April 15 deadline through filing, and see why a timely return can still leave payment charges.
Try one first
Hint
Separate the due date for filing the return from the due date for paying the tax.
Answer D. A timely-filed Form 4868 extends only the time to file, not the time to pay. Paying a reasonable estimate of the tax by the original due date reduces exposure to failure-to-pay penalties and interest; any remaining balance can be settled when the return is filed.
Why not A: Making a payment is good practice but does not extend the filing deadline. Without a timely extension, the taxpayer still faces potential late-filing penalties.
Why not B: Tempting because an extension to file is obtained, but incorrect: the extension does not postpone the payment due date. Waiting increases interest and failure-to-pay penalties.
Why not C: This appeals to those who think only payment matters, but a late return without a timely extension can trigger a failure-to-file penalty in addition to interest on unpaid tax.
The timeline
- April 10, Year 2Jordan cannot finish the Year 1 return.
Assume regular April 15 and October 15 deadlines and no special relief. Jordan reasonably estimates $18,000 of total tax. Withholding and estimated payments total $10,000, leaving $8,000 unpaid.
- April 15, Year 2Jordan timely files a valid Form 4868.
The filing deadline moves to October 15. The payment deadline does not move.
- April 15, Year 2Jordan makes no additional payment.
The appropriate payment was $8,000: $18,000 total tax minus $10,000 already paid. Requesting an extension does not defer that balance.
- After April 15, Year 2The $8,000 remains unpaid after its due date.
Interest accrues on the unpaid tax. A failure-to-pay penalty may also apply. Assume no penalty relief.
- September 20, Year 2Jordan files the completed return and pays $8,000.
The return confirms $18,000 of total tax. Filing before October 15 avoids the late-filing penalty, but does not erase interest or late-payment penalties.
Key points
- Remember: Form 4868 moves the filing deadline, but the payment deadline stays April 15.
- Subtract withholding and estimated payments from total tax to find the unpaid balance.
- An unpaid balance does not invalidate an otherwise valid filing extension.
- Filing before October 15 avoids late filing, not charges for paying after April 15.
How the exam traps you
- Wait until the extended filing date to pay. Pay the reasonably estimated unpaid balance by April 15.
- Treat the extension as invalid because Jordan paid nothing with it. Separate extension validity from payment consequences. A valid extension can leave unpaid tax.
- Assume filing in September eliminates all penalties and interest. Timely filing under an extension does not erase late-payment charges.
Question 2
Hint
Separate the deadline to file the return from the deadline to pay the tax.
Answer A. An automatic extension for an individual return generally extends only the time to file, not the time to pay. Taxpayers should pay any reasonably estimated unpaid tax by the original due date to avoid or reduce late-payment penalties and interest. Any remaining balance is reconciled when the return is filed.
Why not B: This is a common misconception: an extension to file does not extend the payment deadline. If tax remains unpaid past the original due date, interest and penalties can apply.
Why not C: Tempting because the final liability is calculated on the filed return, but taxpayers are expected to make a reasonable estimate and pay that amount by the original due date to limit penalties and interest.
Why not D: This confuses administrative steps with the payment deadline. A valid automatic extension does not delay when tax is due, so taxpayers should not wait for written "approval" before paying an estimated balance.
Question 3
Hint
Separate the filing deadline from the payment deadline.
Answer C. A valid extension for individuals generally extends only the time to file the return, not the time to pay tax. Dana should pay a reasonable estimate of her Year 1 tax by the original due date to minimize failure-to-pay penalties and interest. She can reconcile and adjust the final amount when she files the return.
Why not A: This choice is plausible if a candidate thinks the IRS requires a final calculation before granting an extension, but it is wrong: the extension request must be filed by the original due date and Dana can make a good‑faith estimated payment rather than waiting for perfect records.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates often assume an extension covers both filing and payment, but it is incorrect: the extension generally applies only to filing; unpaid tax is still due by the original due date.
Why not D: This distractor confuses the filing-extension effect with interest timing. In general, interest on unpaid tax accrues from the original due date even if the taxpayer obtains a filing extension.
Question 4
Hint
Separate the deadline to file the return from the deadline to pay the tax.
Answer D. An extension gives an individual more time to file, but not more time to pay. To reduce penalties and stay compliant, Lee should timely request the extension and pay the best estimate of the tax due by the original due date. The completed return must then be filed by the extended deadline.
Why not A: Incorrect: accuracy concerns do not excuse missing the filing deadline. If Lee cannot complete the return on time, Lee should still either file by the due date or request an extension and pay the estimated tax to avoid penalties.
Why not B: Tempting because candidates often remember that an extension delays filing and overgeneralize that it delays payment. It's wrong: an extension to file does not extend the time to pay; tax is still due by the original deadline and failure-to-pay penalties or interest can apply.
Why not C: Seems practical since filing by the due date feels safer, but filing a knowingly incomplete return when an extension exists is not the best compliance approach; the extension allows accurate reporting while avoiding late-filing issues if payment is timely.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on what Form 4868 extends and what it does not extend.
Answer D. Form 4868 grants an extension of time to file an individual return (typically to October 15) but does not extend the time to pay taxes. For a calendar-year individual, the unpaid tax for Year 1 is generally due by the original return due date, here April 15 of Year 2. Paying after that date can result in interest and late-payment penalties even if the filing extension was timely.
Why not A: October 15 is the usual extended filing deadline when Form 4868 is timely filed, so this is a common trap. The extension applies to filing the return, not to paying the tax owed, so payment by October 15 would generally be late.
Why not B: June 15 is one of the quarterly estimated tax deadlines for some taxpayers, which makes this tempting, but the unpaid balance from the prior year is due by the original return due date and is not postponed to an estimated-tax installment date.
Why not C: September 15 is another estimated tax installment date and may lure candidates who confuse estimated payments with the prior-year balance; however, filing an extension does not move the payment due date for the prior year.
Question 6
Hint
Separate the deadline to file the return from the deadline to pay the tax.
Answer B. A filing extension gives additional time to file the return, but it does not extend the time to pay the tax expected to be owed. To stay compliant, the taxpayer should timely request the extension and pay the estimated unpaid tax by the original due date. Any remaining amount can be settled when the return is filed within the extension period.
Why not A: This is tempting because many candidates remember that an extension moves the filing deadline and assume the payment deadline moves too. That is wrong. For individuals, the extension generally applies to filing the return, not to paying tax due, so late payment can still trigger interest and potentially penalties.
Why not C: This choice is tempting because timely payment does reduce one problem, but it does not solve the filing deadline issue. If the return is filed after the original due date without a timely extension, the taxpayer may still face late-filing consequences even if the tax was paid on time.
Why not D: This distractor plays on the practical difficulty of computing the exact amount owed. However, the rules generally require the taxpayer to make a good-faith estimate and pay by the original due date if tax is expected to be due. Simply waiting until the return is finished is not the required response.
Common questions
Does Form 4868 give me until October 15 to pay taxes?
No. It extends the filing deadline, not the payment deadline. Jordan's unpaid $8,000 was still due April 15.
Can I get a tax extension without paying the full balance?
Yes. An otherwise valid extension remains effective even with unpaid tax. Interest and a late-payment penalty may still apply to that balance.
Will I owe penalties if I file before the extended deadline?
Filing by the extended deadline generally avoids the late-filing penalty. Jordan's September filing does not eliminate interest or a late-payment penalty on the $8,000 paid late.
Watch it solved
A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on Individual compliance and tax planning considerations, worked step by step.
Form 1040 Build-Up: AGI & Itemized Deductions | CPA TCP TBS on YouTube
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Individual compliance and tax planning considerations
- Year-End Withholding vs. Estimated Payments: Form 2210
- Does Form 4868 Extend Time to Pay Tax?
- What Does Form 8332 Transfer? HOH, EITC, and Child Tax Credit
- Section 199A QBI Deduction: W-2, UBIA and Overall Limits
All Individual compliance and tax planning considerations practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.