TCP · Entity Tax Compliance · 10 practice questions
Dividends-Received Deduction: Income Cap and NOL Exception
The DRD taxable-income cap does not apply if the full deduction creates or increases an NOL. Below: the same qualifying dividend, with only pre-DRD taxable income changed to show when the cap applies.
Try one first
Hint
First determine which DRD percentage applies based on Pine's ownership level, then check whether the taxable income limitation actually changes that amount.
Answer C. Because Pine owned at least 20% but less than 80% of Maple, the applicable dividends received deduction percentage is 65%. The tentative DRD is $120,000 × 65% = $78,000. The taxable-income limitation is 65% of $150,000 = $97,500, which does not reduce the tentative DRD, so the deductible amount is $78,000.
Why not A: This reflects applying a 50% DRD (50% of $120,000 = $60,000). That rate applies when the recipient owns less than 20% of the payer, but Pine owns 30%, so the 65% rate applies instead.
Why not B: This is the taxable-income limitation amount (65% of $150,000), but the limitation is a ceiling. Since the tentative DRD ($78,000) is below that ceiling, the deduction is the tentative DRD, not the ceiling.
Why not D: This assumes the dividend is fully deductible (100% DRD). A 100% DRD generally applies only when ownership meets the 80% control threshold, which is not met here (Pine owns 30%), so a 100% deduction is not supportable.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Pine Corp, a calendar-year C corporation, receives a $120,000 dividend from domestic Maple Inc. The dividend fully qualifies for a 65% DRD. Pine's taxable income, including the dividend but before the DRD, is $110,000. No other adjustments affect the taxable-income limitation or NOL test. What DRD may Pine deduct?
Answer: $71,500.
The full DRD is $120,000 × 65% = $78,000. That leaves $32,000 of income, so no NOL exception applies. The deduction is capped at $110,000 × 65% = $71,500.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1Pre-DRD taxable income increases to $150,000.
Answer: $78,000.
The $97,500 income cap exceeds the $78,000 full DRD. The cap is only a ceiling, so Pine deducts $78,000.
Change 2Pre-DRD taxable income decreases to $60,000.
Answer: $78,000.
The full $78,000 deduction creates an $18,000 NOL. The $39,000 income cap does not apply.
Change 3Pre-DRD taxable income decreases to $78,000.
Answer: $50,700.
The full $78,000 deduction leaves zero, not an NOL. The exception does not apply, so the cap is $78,000 × 65% = $50,700.
Key points
- Remember: Test the full DRD for an NOL before applying the taxable-income cap.
- Pine's full DRD stays $78,000 because its $120,000 dividend and 65% rate never change.
- The taxable-income limit is a ceiling, not an additional deduction.
- Reducing taxable income to exactly zero does not create an NOL.
How the exam traps you
- Always deducting the full $78,000. Apply the income cap when the full deduction does not create or increase an NOL.
- Applying the cap even when the full deduction creates an NOL. Test the full deduction first. A resulting NOL removes the taxable-income cap.
- Treating zero taxable income as an NOL. Zero is not a loss. The cap still applies when the full deduction leaves exactly zero.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer B. Correct. The full DRD leaves $32,000 of income, so the $71,500 cap applies.
Why not A: Incorrect. This uses 50%, not Pine's given 65% rate.
Why not C: Incorrect. This is the full DRD, but no NOL exception removes the lower income cap.
Why not D: Incorrect. Pine qualifies for a 65% deduction, not a deduction of the entire dividend.
Question 2
Answer C. Correct. The $78,000 full DRD is below the $97,500 income cap.
Why not A: Incorrect. This uses the base scenario's $110,000 income instead of $150,000.
Why not B: Incorrect. This is the income ceiling, not the allowable deduction.
Why not D: Incorrect. The full qualifying DRD is $78,000, not the entire dividend.
Question 3
Answer C. Correct. The full deduction creates an $18,000 NOL, so the income cap does not apply.
Why not A: Incorrect. The NOL exception removes this otherwise applicable income cap.
Why not B: Incorrect. The deduction may exceed pre-DRD income when the NOL exception applies.
Why not D: Incorrect. The exception removes the income cap, not the 65% deduction rate.
Question 4
Answer B. Correct. No NOL results from the full DRD, so $78,000 × 65% limits the deduction.
Why not A: Incorrect. The full deduction leaves zero, which does not trigger the NOL exception.
Why not C: Incorrect. This uses $60,000 of income, not the stated $78,000.
Why not D: Incorrect. Neither the given rate nor the income cap permits deducting the entire dividend.
Question 2
Hint
Separate the rule that determines the DRD percentage from the rule that determines whether taxable income can cap the deduction.
Answer C. The ownership percentage determines the DRD percentage, but it does not by itself decide whether the deduction is capped by taxable income. The taxable-income limitation on the DRD is waived if taking the full DRD would create or increase a net operating loss. Because the stem asks which factor governs whether the DRD is limited by taxable income, the NOL effect is the controlling consideration.
Why not A: This is tempting because ownership percentage sets the applicable DRD rate (e.g., whether the recipient gets 50%, 65%, or 100%). However, the question asks what governs whether the taxable-income cap applies once the dividend qualifies for the DRD; that determination turns on whether the full DRD would create or increase an NOL, not the ownership percentage alone.
Why not B: Earnings and profits determine whether a distribution is a dividend, so this looks plausible. The stem, however, already states the dividend otherwise qualifies for the DRD, so characterization is not the issue being tested. Once the payment is a qualifying dividend, the taxable-income limitation question hinges on the NOL effect.
Why not D: Stock basis matters when determining gain or return of capital on distributions, but it does not govern whether the taxable-income limitation applies to the DRD for a qualifying dividend. The key question is whether taking the full DRD would create or increase an NOL.
Question 3
Hint
First determine the correct DRD percentage from Atlas's ownership level, then test whether the taxable income limitation actually restricts the deduction in these facts.
Answer B. Because Atlas owns at least 20% but less than 80% of Beacon, the applicable dividends-received deduction percentage is 65%. The full DRD is therefore $65,000 ($100,000 × 65%). The taxable-income limitation (which would yield $39,000) does not apply when allowing the full DRD would create or increase a net operating loss; here, the full $65,000 DRD would produce a $5,000 loss, so Atlas may deduct the full $65,000.
Why not A: This applies the 65% rate to the pre-DRD taxable income (60,000 × 65% = 39,000). It ignores the statutory exception that waives the taxable-income limitation when taking the full DRD would create or increase an NOL.
Why not C: This caps the deduction at the pre-DRD taxable income. That rule applies generally, but the taxable-income cap is waived if granting the full DRD would create or increase an NOL; thus Atlas may take the full $65,000 even though it exceeds the $60,000 pre-DRD taxable income.
Why not D: This equals 50% of the dividend and reflects using the wrong DRD tier (the 50% rate applies for ownership under 20%). Atlas owns 24%, so the correct DRD rate is 65%, making $65,000 the correct full deduction.
Question 4
Hint
First determine which DRD percentage applies based on ownership, then ask whether the taxable income limitation actually restricts the deduction in these facts.
Answer A. Amber owns between 20% and 80% of the distributing domestic corporation, so the applicable DRD rate is 65%. The tentative DRD is $65,000 (65% × $100,000). Although the taxable income limitation would normally cap the DRD at $32,500 (65% × $50,000), that limitation is waived when allowing the full DRD would create or increase an NOL; here $50,000 − $65,000 = a loss, so Amber may deduct the full $65,000.
Why not B: This choice reflects the incorrect idea that the deduction cannot exceed current taxable income or confuses the DRD rate. Amber's 22% ownership gives a 65% DRD and the NOL exception allows the full $65,000 despite taxable income of $50,000.
Why not C: This applies the 65% DRD rate to taxable income (65% × $50,000) as if the taxable-income limitation blocked the full deduction. It is tempting but incorrect because the taxable-income limitation is waived where taking the full DRD would create or increase an NOL, which occurs here.
Why not D: This distractor results from mistakenly using a 50% DRD rate and applying it to taxable income (50% × $50,000). Amber's ownership is 22%, so the correct DRD rate is 65%, not 50%.
Question 5
Hint
First determine the correct DRD percentage from the ownership level. Then ask whether the taxable income limitation actually applies in this fact pattern.
Answer C. Lark qualifies for the 50% DRD because it owns less than 20% of Swift; tentative DRD = $300,000 × 50% = $150,000. Although the DRD is generally limited to 50% of taxable income (140,000 × 50% = $70,000), that taxable-income limitation is waived when allowing the full DRD would create or increase a net operating loss. Because 140,000 − 150,000 would produce a loss, Lark may deduct the full $150,000.
Why not A: This applies the 50% DRD to taxable income (140,000 × 50%), using the ordinary taxable-income limitation. It is tempting but incorrect here because the limitation is waived if the full DRD would create or increase an NOL.
Why not B: This reflects applying a 65% DRD rate to taxable income (140,000 × 65%) and misreads the ownership threshold. Lark owns only 18%, so the applicable rate is 50%, and the NOL exception permits the full $150,000 DRD.
Why not D: This is 65% of the dividend (300,000 × 65%), which would be correct only if Lark owned at least 20% of Swift. With only 18% ownership the DRD rate is 50%, so $195,000 is incorrect.
Question 6
Hint
Determine the correct dividends received deduction percentage from the ownership level first, then consider whether the taxable income limitation still applies.
Answer B. Northlake's 30% ownership puts it in the 65% DRD bracket, so the tentative deduction is 65% of $100,000 = $65,000. Although the taxable-income cap would ordinarily limit the deduction (65% of $40,000 = $26,000), that limitation is waived when claiming the full DRD would create or increase a net operating loss. Because taking the full $65,000 would reduce taxable income below zero, the full $65,000 deduction is permitted.
Why not A: This correctly applies the 65% bracket and computes 65% of $40,000 as $26,000, but it ignores the statutory exception that the taxable-income limitation does not apply if allowing the full DRD would create (or increase) an NOL.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to the general 50% rule for small shareholders, but Northlake owns 30% of Delta, which places it in the higher (65%) bracket; therefore the 50% rate is incorrect here.
Why not D: This reflects the mistaken idea that a deduction can never exceed current taxable income. For the DRD, the limitation is governed by the taxable-income formula and the NOL exception; here the NOL exception permits the full DRD even though it exceeds current taxable income.
Common questions
How do you calculate the DRD taxable-income limitation?
For Pine's qualifying 65% DRD, multiply adjusted pre-DRD taxable income by 65%. At $110,000 of income, the cap is $71,500, below the $78,000 full DRD.
When does the NOL exception remove the DRD income limit?
The limit does not apply when the full DRD creates or increases an NOL. With $60,000 of pre-DRD income, Pine's full $78,000 deduction creates an $18,000 NOL.
Does the DRD NOL exception apply if taxable income becomes zero?
No. With $78,000 of pre-DRD income, the full $78,000 deduction leaves zero, not an NOL. Pine must apply the $50,700 income cap.
Watch it solved
A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on C corporations, worked step by step.
C Corporation E&P & Distributions | CPA TCP Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on C corporations
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.