REG · Federal Taxation of Property Transactions · 9 practice questions
Related-Party Loss on a Partial Sale With Improvements
On a later sale to an unrelated buyer, the buyer's gain is reduced by the allocated disallowed related-party loss, but not below zero. Below: a worked partial land sale with capital improvements and a selling commission.
Try one first
Hint
First compute D's amount realized and realized gain using D's own basis. Then ask whether any rule from the prior related-party loss changes how much of that gain is recognized.
Answer A. D's amount realized is $70,000 ($71,000 sales price less $1,000 commission). Her realized gain is $26,000 ($70,000 amount realized less D's $44,000 basis). Because M's $20,000 loss on the related-party sale to D was disallowed, that disallowed loss reduces D's recognized gain when D later sells to an unrelated party, but not below zero; therefore D recognizes $6,000 of gain ($26,000 realized gain less $20,000 disallowed loss).
Why not B: This is tempting if the candidate correctly computes D's realized gain but forgets the special related-party loss rule. M's disallowed $20,000 loss reduces D's recognized gain when D later sells to an unrelated party, so D does not recognize the full $26,000.
Why not C: This arises from incorrectly using M's $64,000 basis to compute D's realized gain. D's realized gain is computed using D's own basis (her purchase price of $44,000); the prior disallowed loss affects recognized gain, not the initial realized-gain calculation.
Why not D: This reflects over-applying the disallowed-loss limitation. The disallowed $20,000 loss can reduce D's recognized gain only up to $20,000; since D's realized gain is $26,000, she must still recognize the remaining $6,000.
Worked example
A daughter buys a 10-acre investment parcel from her mother for its $100,000 fair market value. Her mother's basis is $160,000. The daughter adds $20,000 of capital improvements, then sells five acres to an unrelated buyer for $110,000, paying a $5,000 commission. All acres have equal value and basis. Improvements benefit all acres equally. No other adjustments apply.
| 1 | Mother's disallowed loss$160,000 − $100,000 | $60,000 |
| 2 | Daughter's total adjusted basis$100,000 + $20,000 | $120,000 |
| 3 | Basis of the five acres sold$120,000 × 5/10 | $60,000 |
| 4 | Amount realized$110,000 − $5,000 commission | $105,000 |
| 5 | Realized gain$105,000 − $60,000 | $45,000 |
| 6 | Disallowed loss allocated to this sale$60,000 × 5/10 | $30,000 |
| 7 | Recognized gainmax($0, $45,000 − $30,000) | $15,000 |
The mother deducts no loss, and the daughter recognizes $15,000 of gain on the five-acre sale.
Check: Per acre sold: $21,000 net proceeds − $12,000 adjusted basis − $6,000 disallowed loss = $3,000 recognized gain; five acres = $15,000.
Key points
- The original sale at fair market value does not make the mother's loss deductible.
- The disallowed loss reduces recognized gain. It does not increase the daughter's basis.
- Keep the unsold acres' share of the disallowed loss separate from this sale.
How the exam traps you
- Reporting $20,000 by ignoring the commission. Subtract the $5,000 commission from the daughter's sale price before computing realized gain.
- Reporting $25,000 by ignoring capital improvements. Add improvements to cost before allocating basis to the acres sold.
- Reporting zero gain by applying the entire $60,000 disallowed loss. Only $30,000 belongs to the five acres sold; the other half belongs to the unsold acres.
Question 2
Hint
First ask whether any special disallowance rule applies before focusing on holding period or the type of property.
Answer A. Losses on sales or exchanges between related parties are generally disallowed under the federal tax rules (commonly applied under IRC §267). A sister qualifies as a related party, so the related-party disallowance, not holding period or FMV, controls whether Liam may deduct the loss. The sale being at fair market value does not override that disallowance.
Why not B: Holding period determines whether a gain or loss is long-term or short-term (its character), but it does not determine whether a realized loss is deductible at all. A related-party disallowance can prevent deduction regardless of holding period.
Why not C: While an arm's-length sale at FMV is often relevant to tax recognition, the related‑party loss disallowance applies even when the sale price equals fair market value and therefore does not by itself permit deduction.
Why not D: Losses on personal-use property are nondeductible, and losses on investment property are generally deductible, but the separate related-party disallowance supersedes that: even if the land is investment property, a loss on sale to a related party is typically disallowed.
Question 3
Hint
Analyze the first sale and the second sale separately. Then ask what a disallowed related-party loss does when the buyer later sells to someone unrelated.
Answer B. Under the related‑party loss rules, Nia's $20,000 loss on the Year 1 sale to her son is disallowed and she cannot deduct it in Year 1. Cole's basis is his $70,000 purchase price, so his realized gain on the Year 2 sale for $96,000 is $26,000 (96,000 − 70,000). The previously disallowed $20,000 loss reduces Cole's recognized gain on the sale to an unrelated party, leaving $6,000 of recognized gain (26,000 − 20,000).
Why not A: This is plausible if the student remembers the disallowance for Nia but forgets the follow‑on rule that the disallowed related‑party loss reduces the buyer's recognized gain when the buyer later sells to an unrelated party.
Why not C: This reflects correctly applying the later offset to Cole's gain but incorrectly treating Nia's loss as deductible. Because the sale was between related parties, Nia's $20,000 loss is disallowed in Year 1.
Why not D: This treats both transactions as if the related‑party rule does not apply; it fails to disallow Nia's loss and also ignores that the disallowed loss would reduce Cole's recognized gain on a later sale to an unrelated party.
Question 4
Hint
First determine the tax effect of the related-party sale under §267 on the seller's loss; then determine Blair's basis and how any previously disallowed loss applies when Blair later sells to an unrelated party.
Answer A. Ava realized a $22,000 loss on the Year 1 related-party sale (48,000 − 70,000), which is disallowed under IRC §267. Blair's basis is her cost, $48,000, so her later sale produced a $17,000 realized long-term gain ($65,000 − $48,000). Under §267 the transferor's disallowed loss may be used to offset the transferee's recognized gain on a subsequent sale to an unrelated party; the $17,000 gain is fully absorbed and Blair recognizes no gain or loss. The remaining $5,000 of Ava's disallowed loss remains disallowed and is not deductible by Blair.
Why not B: Tempting because Blair bought for $48,000 and sold after 14 months for $65,000, so superficially a $17,000 long-term gain. It fails because it ignores IRC §267: Ava's related-party loss is disallowed but may offset Blair's later recognized gain on sale to an unrelated party, eliminating Blair's recognition in this case.
Why not C: Tempting for candidates who confuse bases (comparing the $65,000 sale price to Ava's $70,000 basis) or who think any remaining disallowed loss becomes the buyer's deductible loss. It fails because Blair's basis is her purchase price ($48,000), not Ava's basis, and any disallowed loss offsets the transferee's later gain rather than creating a deductible loss for the buyer.
Why not D: Tempting because it reflects Ava's actual economic loss and a mistake that the buyer 'inherits' the seller's disallowed loss. It fails because §267 does not transfer a deductible loss to the related transferee; the disallowed loss can only offset the transferee's later recognized gain to the extent of that gain, and cannot produce a deductible loss for Blair.
Question 5
Hint
Work in sequence: calculate Ben's tentative gain under ordinary basis rules first, then consider whether the prior related-party loss changes the amount he must recognize.
Answer B. Ben's amount realized is $260,000 ($265,000 sale price less $5,000 selling expenses), and his adjusted basis is $200,000 ($180,000 purchase price plus $20,000 capital improvement), producing a $60,000 tentative gain. Under the related-party loss rules, Ava's $50,000 loss disallowed on the Year 1 related-party sale can be used to offset gain recognized by Ben when he later sells to an unrelated party. Therefore Ben recognizes $60,000 − $50,000 = a $10,000 capital gain.
Why not A: Tempting if a candidate forgets to subtract Ben's $5,000 selling expenses and uses $265,000 as the amount realized. That gives a $65,000 tentative gain, and after subtracting the $50,000 disallowed loss the result would be $15,000 (incorrect).
Why not C: Plausible if a candidate uses the wrong basis, for example, mistakenly using Ava's pre-sale basis of $230,000 or omitting Ben's $20,000 improvement. Using a $230,000 basis with the correct $260,000 amount realized yields a $30,000 gain (incorrect).
Why not D: This is the tentative gain before applying the special related-party rule. A candidate choosing this answer likely computed Ben's amount realized and basis correctly but failed to reduce recognized gain by Ava's previously disallowed $50,000 loss.
Question 6
Hint
First determine what happened to Nolan's Year 1 loss, then ask whether the later unrelated sale lets Reed use any of that disallowed amount, and if so, how far.
Answer C. A loss on a sale between related parties is disallowed to the seller under IRC Section 267. If the related-party buyer later sells the property at a gain to an unrelated person, that gain is reduced, but not below zero, by the seller's previously disallowed loss. Reed's realized gain is $14,000 ($102,000 sale price minus $88,000 cost), and Nolan's disallowed loss was $22,000, so Reed recognizes zero gain and zero loss in Year 2.
Why not A: This is tempting because Reed generally does start with a cost basis of $88,000, and many candidates stop there. However, IRC Section 267(d) specifically allows the previously disallowed related-party loss to offset Reed's later gain on a sale to an unrelated party. That rule prevents the full $14,000 gain from being recognized here.
Why not B: This distractor is attractive to candidates who confuse the related-party loss rule with carryover-basis concepts from gift transactions or other nonrecognition settings. Reed does not receive Nolan's $110,000 basis for purposes of creating a loss. The prior disallowed loss can reduce a later gain, but it cannot create or increase a loss for Reed.
Why not D: This choice reflects the common mistake of treating Nolan's disallowed loss like a full carryover item that passes to Reed. The statute is narrower: the disallowed loss may offset Reed's later gain, but only to the extent of that gain. Any excess disallowed loss does not become a separately recognized loss or carryover for Reed.
Question 7
Hint
Do this in two steps: first decide whether the seller may deduct a loss on a sale to a related party; then determine how any disallowed loss affects the buyer when the buyer later sells to an unrelated party.
Answer B. Losses on sales between related parties are disallowed, so Avery cannot deduct the $12,000 loss in Year 1. The brother's basis is his purchase price of $46,000, so his realized gain on the Year 2 sale is $15,000; the related-party transferee rule reduces recognized gain by the previously disallowed $12,000, leaving $3,000 recognized.
Why not A: Tempting because it applies ordinary realized loss and gain rules to each sale. Wrong because losses on sales to related parties are disallowed, Avery cannot deduct the $12,000 loss, and that disallowed amount affects the brother's later recognized gain.
Why not C: Tempting because it correctly disallows Avery's loss but then treats the brother's recognized gain as equal to his realized gain. Wrong because the transferee's recognized gain is reduced by the previously disallowed loss, so the brother recognizes only $3,000.
Why not D: Tempting because it pairs the correct $3,000 recognized gain for the brother with an assumed deductible loss for Avery. Wrong because Avery's $12,000 loss is disallowed on the related-party sale and cannot be deducted in Year 1.
Question 8
Hint
First compute Lane's realized gain using her own purchase price. Then ask how a previously disallowed loss on a related-party sale affects a later sale to an unrelated person.
Answer D. Harper realized an $8,000 loss on the Year 1 sale (22,000 − 30,000), but losses on sales between related parties are disallowed. Lane's realized gain on the Year 2 sale is $31,000 − $22,000 = $9,000; the previously disallowed $8,000 loss is allowed to offset Lane's gain on a later sale to an unrelated party, reducing recognized gain to $1,000.
Why not A: Tempting because Lane's own realized gain is $9,000 using her purchase price as basis, but it ignores that Harper's $8,000 related-party loss reduces the amount of Lane's recognized gain when Lane later sells to an unrelated party.
Why not B: This reflects the error of treating Harper's disallowed loss as if it became an immediate deductible loss for Lane. The rule does not convert the disallowed loss into a deductible loss for the transferee; it only permits the prior disallowed loss to reduce a later recognized gain.
Why not C: Attractive if one assumes the entire disallowed loss eliminates Lane's later gain, but only up to the amount of gain is available; since Lane's realized gain is $9,000 and the disallowed loss is $8,000, $1,000 of gain remains.
Question 9
Hint
First compute Mateo's realized gain using his own amount realized and cost basis. Then consider whether a previously disallowed loss from a related-party sale affects later gain recognition by the buyer.
Answer D. Mateo's amount realized is $96,000 ($100,000 less $4,000 selling expenses) and his basis is his cost of $72,000, so his realized gain is $24,000. Rosa's $18,000 loss on the related-party sale was disallowed, but that disallowed loss may offset the transferee's later recognized gain when the transferee sells to an unrelated party. Therefore, Mateo recognizes $24,000 − $18,000 = $6,000 of long-term capital gain (held >1 year).
Why not A: This correctly computes Mateo's realized gain but ignores the related-party rule: Rosa's $18,000 disallowed loss can reduce Mateo's later recognized gain when he sells to an unrelated buyer, so Mateo's recognized gain is less than $24,000.
Why not B: This reflects a common mistake. Mateo's basis is his purchase price of $72,000; the disallowed loss does not increase the transferee's basis. Instead, the previously disallowed loss reduces the amount of gain recognized on a subsequent sale to an unrelated party.
Why not C: This overstates the relief. The disallowed loss does not erase the transferee's realized gain entirely; it can offset the transferee's later recognized gain only to the extent of that gain. Mateo realized $24,000, so an $18,000 offset still leaves $6,000 of recognized gain.
Common questions
Does a disallowed related-party loss increase the buyer's basis?
No. The daughter's basis is her $100,000 cost plus $20,000 of capital improvements, or $120,000. The mother's $60,000 disallowed loss is a separate potential gain reduction.
How do commissions and improvements affect the buyer's later sale?
Commissions reduce amount realized, while capital improvements increase basis. Here, those adjustments produce $45,000 of realized gain before the related-party reduction.
How do you allocate a related-party disallowed loss on a partial sale?
Allocate it to the portion sold. Five of ten equal acres receive $30,000 of the $60,000 disallowed loss, which reduces the daughter's $45,000 realized gain to $15,000.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Nontaxable and deferred exchanges, worked step by step.
Section 1031 Boot & Liability Netting | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Nontaxable and deferred exchanges
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.