REG · Tax Procedures and Accounting Issues · 6 practice questions
IRS Six-Year Assessment Rule: More Than 25% Omitted
An undisclosed gross-income omission exceeding 25% of the gross income stated on the return gives the IRS six years to assess. Compare Mason’s omission with reported gross income, then test the exact 25% boundary.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on the rule that can extend the normal assessment period, and be careful about what amount the percentage is measured against.
Answer D. The extension-to-six-years rule applies when a taxpayer omits from gross income an amount properly includible in gross income that exceeds 25% of the gross income stated on the return. Here, $45,000 is greater than 25% of the $160,000 reported gross income, so the 6-year limitation applies. Because the return was timely filed before the due date, it is treated as filed on the April 15 due date for limitation purposes, and the assessment period is still open on April 20, Year 5.
Why not A: This is a generic distractor appealing to materiality. The statute does not use a generic material-dollar test; it specifically looks to whether an amount of gross income exceeding 25% of the gross income stated on the return was omitted.
Why not B: This confuses taxable income with the statutory base. The 25% threshold is measured against the gross income stated on the return, not taxable income.
Why not C: While the filing date affects when the limitation period begins, an early timely filing is treated as filed on the due date; that fact alone does not determine whether a 6-year extension applies. The governing issue is whether the omission meets the 25%-of-gross threshold.
Step by step
- Identify stated and omitted income
Mason’s return reports $200,000 of gross income but leaves $60,000 of consulting receipts undisclosed. Assume no fraud or other assessment-period exceptions.
- Compute 25% of stated income
$200,000 × 25% = $50,000. Use the amount stated on the return, not Mason’s actual gross income of $260,000.
- Compare the omission with the threshold
$60,000 exceeds $50,000, so the six-year assessment period applies. Compare omitted gross income, not the additional tax owed.
- Test the exact 25% boundary
Same facts, except Mason omits $50,000: $50,000 ÷ $200,000 = exactly 25%. That does not exceed the threshold, so the normal three-year period applies.
Key points
- Remember: Compare omitted gross income with gross income stated on the return, not actual gross income.
- The test measures missing gross income, not unpaid tax.
- An undisclosed omission can trigger six years even without fraud.
How the exam traps you
- Dividing Mason’s $60,000 omission by his actual gross income of $260,000. Use the $200,000 stated on the return: $60,000 ÷ $200,000 = 30%.
- Treating an omission equal to 25% as triggering six years. The omission must exceed 25%; exactly 25% does not qualify.
- Comparing additional tax owed with reported gross income. Compare omitted gross income, not additional tax, with 25% of stated gross income.
Question 2
Hint
Determine first whether the omission changes the normal assessment period, then decide what filing date counts when a return is filed before its due date.
Answer C. Because Jordan omitted more than 25% of the gross income stated on the return, the normal 3-year assessment period is extended to 6 years. The omitted $60,000 is 30% of the $200,000 reported gross income (60,000/200,000), which exceeds 25%. A return filed before its due date is generally treated as filed on the due date for statute-of-limitations purposes, so the 6-year period runs from April 15, 20X2 through April 15, 20X8.
Why not A: This reflects the normal 3-year assessment period (three years after the return due date), but it ignores the substantial-omission rule: omitting more than 25% of gross income generally extends the assessment period to 6 years.
Why not B: This applies a 6-year period counted from the actual filing date. It is tempting, but when a return is filed before its due date it is generally treated as filed on the due date for statute-of-limitations purposes, so the correct cutoff is April 15, 20X8.
Why not D: This confuses the unlimited period that can apply in cases of fraud or failure to file with the substantial-omission rule. Here Jordan filed a return and there is no allegation of fraud, so the omission extends the assessment period to 6 years rather than eliminating it.
Question 3
Hint
First determine whether the omission changes the normal assessment period. Then decide which date starts that period when a return is filed after its due date.
Answer D. The $60,000 omission compared with the $200,000 reported on the return equals 30%, exceeding the 25% threshold that triggers the six-year assessment period. Because Palmer filed the return late (September 20, 20X2) and did not extend the assessment period, the six-year limit runs from the filing date and expires on September 20, 20X8.
Why not A: This reflects measuring the normal three-year period from the original due date. It is incorrect because the omission exceeds 25% (triggering the six-year rule) and because a late-filed return is measured from the actual filing date, not the original due date.
Why not B: This correctly measures from the actual filing date for a late return but applies the normal three-year statute. Because the omission exceeds 25% of the gross income stated on the return, the six-year statute applies instead.
Why not C: This applies the six-year period but anchors it to the original due date. Since Palmer filed after the due date and did not extend the assessment period, the limitations period begins on the filing date, not the original due date.
Question 4
Hint
Start with the normal assessment period and then ask whether any stated fact changes when that period begins or how long it lasts.
Answer A. The general rule is that the IRS must assess tax within 3 years after a return is filed. Under the exception for substantial omission, if a taxpayer omits from gross income an amount in excess of 25% of the gross income stated on the return and it is not adequately disclosed, the assessment period is extended to 6 years; because B omitted 28%, the 6‑year period (through April 15, 20X8) is still open on September 1, 20X6.
Why not B: This is tempting if a candidate thinks an amended return restarts the statute. It generally does not. An original return filed before the due date is treated as filed on the due date (April 15, 20X2), so the normal 3‑year assessment period expired April 15, 20X5.
Why not C: Although filing under a valid extension shifts the filing date later (and thus the 3‑year window), the limitation still runs 3 years from the actual filing date (Oct 15, 20X2) and was therefore closed on Oct 15, 20X5; the amended return does not restart the 3‑year period.
Why not D: A written consent can extend the assessment period, but here the consent only preserved the period through June 30, 20X6. An attempted assessment on September 1, 20X6 would therefore be untimely.
Question 5
Hint
Work separately for each taxpayer. First decide whether the omission is large enough to trigger the longer assessment period, then determine when that period began to run.
Answer A. Allen omitted $60,000 of $200,000, 30%, which exceeds the 25% threshold and thus triggers the 6-year assessment period; that period (measured from his filing) remains open on August 15, 20X6. Baker's omission was $30,000 (15%), so the normal 3-year assessment period applied and ran from his filing date of July 1, 20X3; it expired on July 1, 20X6.
Why not B: This distractor correctly recalls that a late-filed return's 3-year period runs from the filing date, but it ignores the separate 6-year rule for returns omitting more than 25% of gross income. Allen's 30% omission keeps his assessment window open.
Why not C: This choice confuses any understatement with the specific >25% omission rule that extends the period to 6 years. Baker's omission was only 15%, so his 3-year period had already closed by August 15, 20X6.
Why not D: This is tempting if a candidate applies only the default 3-year rule. However, Allen's omission exceeded 25% of stated gross income, extending the assessment period to 6 years and leaving his return open.
Question 6
Hint
Work the problem in two steps: first decide whether the omission triggers the extended statute, then determine which filing date counts for a return filed before its due date.
Answer B. The general assessment statute is three years from the date the return is filed, but a return filed before its due date is treated as filed on its due date for limitations purposes. The omitted $60,000 equals 25% of the $240,000 gross income reported, so the extended six-year period (which applies only when the omission exceeds 25% of gross income stated) does not apply. Because the April 1, Year 2 return is treated as filed on the April 15, Year 2 due date, the IRS has until April 15, Year 5.
Why not A: This mistakes the statute-measurement date as the actual early filing date. For limitations purposes an early-filed return is treated as filed on its due date (April 15, Year 2 here), so the three-year period runs to April 15, Year 5, not April 1, Year 5.
Why not C: This combines two errors: applying the six-year extension when the omitted amount is exactly 25% (the six-year rule applies only when the omission exceeds 25% of gross income stated) and measuring from the actual early filing date rather than the return's due date.
Why not D: This distractor correctly measures from the due date but wrongly assumes the six-year period applies. Because the omitted amount is exactly 25% of the gross income reported, the six-year extension (which requires the omission to exceed 25%) does not apply.
Common questions
When does omitted income trigger the IRS six-year assessment rule?
An undisclosed gross-income omission must exceed 25% of the gross income stated on the return. Mason’s $60,000 omission is 30% of his reported $200,000, so six years applies.
Is the 25% omission test based on reported or actual gross income?
Use gross income stated on the return. For Mason, the denominator is $200,000, not the $260,000 he should have reported.
Does an omission of exactly 25% trigger six years?
No. If Mason omits $50,000 while reporting $200,000, the omission equals exactly 25%; the normal three-year period applies because no other exception is assumed.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on IRS Procedures
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.