REG · Federal Taxation of Individuals · 9 practice questions
Cancellation of Debt Income: Insolvency Exclusion Limit
Canceled debt is generally taxable, and the insolvency exclusion is limited to insolvency immediately before discharge. Below: a worked calculation using all assets at fair market value, including an exempt retirement account.
Try one first
Hint
Start from the general rule that canceled debt is income, then determine whether a statutory exclusion (notably insolvency) applies and the point in time used to measure it.
Answer D. Cancellation of debt is generally includible in gross income unless a statutory exclusion applies. For a nonbankruptcy discharge the relevant exclusion is insolvency, which is measured immediately before the discharge and cannot exceed the amount of insolvency at that time. Here Maya was insolvent by $11,000 immediately before the cancellation, so up to $11,000 of the $18,000 may be excluded and the remaining $7,000 ($18,000 − $11,000) is includible in Year 1 gross income.
Why not A: This distractor tempts because Form 1099-C notifies the taxpayer and IRS of canceled debt and may suggest taxability. It fails because an information return does not determine substantive tax treatment, the tax result depends on whether an exclusion like insolvency applies.
Why not B: This distractor tempts because the use of funds sometimes affects which tax rules apply, so test takers may look for a use-based exclusion. It fails here because the insolvency exclusion turns on the taxpayer's financial condition immediately before the discharge, not the purpose for which the debt was incurred.
Why not C: This is tempting as candidates may think the taxpayer's post-discharge financial position is what matters. It is incorrect because the insolvency exclusion is explicitly measured immediately before the discharge; measuring after would incorporate the effect of the discharge itself and use the wrong timing.
Worked example
A bank cancels $75,000 of Alex's recourse personal debt outside bankruptcy. Immediately before discharge, Alex has $220,000 of total liabilities, including that debt. Asset FMV is $155,000 outside retirement accounts plus $25,000 in a retirement account exempt from creditors under state law. No other exclusion applies. How much canceled debt is taxable?
| 1 | Total asset FMV$155,000 + $25,000 | $180,000 |
| 2 | Insolvency immediately before discharge$220,000 liabilities - $180,000 asset FMV | $40,000 |
| 3 | Canceled debt excludedLesser of $75,000 canceled or $40,000 insolvency | $40,000 |
| 4 | Taxable canceled debt$75,000 - $40,000 | $35,000 |
Alex includes $35,000 of canceled debt in gross income and excludes $40,000 under the insolvency exclusion.
Check: After discharge, assets exceed remaining liabilities by $180,000 - ($220,000 - $75,000) = $35,000, matching taxable canceled debt.
Key points
- Use total liabilities, including the debt about to be canceled.
- Personal debt can qualify for the insolvency exclusion; it does not need to be business debt.
- State-law protection from creditors does not remove the retirement account from the insolvency calculation.
How the exam traps you
- Excluding all $75,000 just because Alex is insolvent. The exclusion stops at $40,000, leaving $35,000 taxable.
- Using liabilities after discharge and taxing all $75,000. Use the $220,000 of liabilities immediately before discharge, not the $145,000 remaining afterward.
- Omitting the protected retirement account and reporting only $10,000 taxable. Include its $25,000 FMV; exempt assets still count.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on whether the item is a true exclusion from income or just looks unusual but is still compensation.
Answer D. A cash award from an employer is taxable compensation and must be included in gross income. Employee achievement award exclusions are limited and do not apply to cash awards, so the cash safety award is includible.
Why not A: This seems tempting because interest is generally taxable, but interest on state and local (municipal) bonds is typically excluded from federal gross income. Bonds issued by a city point to tax-exempt municipal bond interest.
Why not B: Compensatory damages received on account of personal physical injuries are generally excluded from gross income under the tax code. The stem removes punitive damages and interest, which could be taxable, so this recovery is usually nontaxable.
Why not C: Cash gifts received out of detached generosity are generally excluded from the recipient's gross income. The stem specifies no services were performed for the aunt, making this a likely nontaxable gift rather than compensation.
Question 3
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| A bank discharged $15,000 of Lee's recourse personal loan in an out-of-court workout. Immediately before the discharge, Lee's liabilities exceeded the fair market value of Lee's assets by | $9,000 |
| Lee received a settlement from an auto accident claim. Under an arm's-length settlement agreement, $31,000 was for personal physical injuries, $6,000 was for punitive damages, and $3,000 was for prejudgment interest | $40,000 |
| As a degree candidate, Lee received a scholarship and used $9,000 for tuition and required fees and books and $3,000 for room and board | $12,000 |
Hint
Analyze each item separately and apply the applicable exclusion rules: insolvency can limit COD inclusion; settlement proceeds may include both taxable and nontaxable components; scholarships exclude amounts used for qualified tuition/related items but not amounts used for room and board.
Answer C. COD income: $15,000 discharged less the $9,000 insolvency exclusion (measured immediately before the discharge) leaves $6,000 includible. Settlement: amounts allocated to personal physical injuries ($31,000) are excludable, while the $6,000 punitive damages and $3,000 prejudgment interest are taxable, taxable settlement = $9,000. Scholarship: $9,000 used for qualified tuition and required fees and books is excludable; $3,000 used for room and board is includible. Total includible income = $6,000 + $9,000 + $3,000 = $18,000.
Why not A: This total ($15,000) corresponds to $6,000 COD + $6,000 punitive damages + $3,000 taxable scholarship while omitting the $3,000 prejudgment interest. It is incorrect because prejudgment interest is taxable and should be included, raising the total to $18,000.
Why not B: This treats the full $15,000 COD as taxable and assumes the scholarship is completely excluded, yielding $15,000 + $9,000 = $24,000. That is incorrect because Lee was insolvent by $9,000 immediately before the discharge, so $9,000 of the COD is excluded and only $6,000 of the COD is includible.
Why not D: This equals taxing the full $15,000 COD plus the $9,000 taxable settlement portion and the $3,000 taxable scholarship (15,000 + 9,000 + 3,000 = 27,000). The mistake is failing to apply the insolvency exclusion on the COD, only $6,000 of the COD is includible, so the correct total is $18,000.
Question 4
Hint
Classify each receipt based on why Nina received it, not just on the fact that she received cash.
Answer D. Nina must include the $2,000 from her employer in gross income because a cash payment from an employer for outstanding performance is compensation even if labeled a "gift." The $2,000 from her aunt is a true gift from an individual and is generally excluded from gross income. The $500 manufacturer rebate on a personal refrigerator is treated as a purchase-price reduction (not gross income) in this personal-use context.
Why not A: Tempting if the candidate focuses on the word "gift" and the rebate exclusion; however, the employer payment is compensation for services and is includible, so total gross income is not $0.
Why not B: Tempting if the candidate assumes all cash receipts are taxable. The aunt's birthday cash is a true gift (excluded) and the manufacturer rebate is not income for a personal purchase, so only the employer payment is includible.
Why not C: Tempting if the candidate includes the employer payment but treats the $500 manufacturer rebate as taxable income. In a personal-purchase scenario the rebate is generally a purchase-price adjustment, not gross income.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on who ultimately bore the economic cost of the premiums and whether Leah's salary reductions were after‑tax or excluded.
Answer C. Taxability of group long‑term disability benefits depends on who bore the economic cost of the premiums and whether any employee contributions were made with after‑tax dollars. Premiums paid by the employer or employee contributions paid with pre‑tax/excluded salary reductions result in taxable benefits; only amounts attributable to employee contributions paid with after‑tax dollars are excluded. Here, Leah's 30% was paid via pre‑tax salary reductions and 70% by the employer, so the benefits are includible in gross income to the extent attributable to those non‑after‑tax payments (effectively the entire benefit).
Why not A: Tempting because who writes the check seems relevant to control of the payment, but tax treatment does not turn on whether the insurer or employer issues the checks, it turns on who bore the economic cost of the premiums and whether employee contributions were after‑tax.
Why not B: Tempting because disability payments commonly replace lost earnings and that feels like income, but the purpose of the payment (wage replacement) does not by itself determine inclusion; funding of the coverage controls taxability.
Why not D: Plausible because workers' compensation for job‑related injuries is tax‑exempt, but the stem excludes workers' compensation; aside from that exception, job‑relatedness does not determine the taxability of benefits under the employer's disability plan.
Question 6
Hint
For each payment, ask whether the landlord had an unrestricted right to keep it when received, regardless of the label used in the lease.
Answer C. A cash-basis taxpayer includes advance rent in gross income when received, even if part of the payment covers a later period. The $2,400 received for December Year 1 and January Year 2 is therefore included in Year 1. The $1,200 that is nonrefundable and designated for the final month's rent is also advance rent when received, while the truly refundable $1,200 security deposit is not income until (and unless) it is forfeited.
Why not A: Tempting if the student relies on labels alone, but incorrect because the nonrefundable deposit that will be applied to the final month's rent is advance rent and is included when received; only a truly refundable deposit is deferred.
Why not B: Overbroad: while cash-basis taxpayers generally include receipts when received, a refundable security deposit is not income at receipt because the landlord may have to return it.
Why not D: Reflects accrual-basis matching thinking; for a cash-basis taxpayer advance rent (including the $2,400 and the nonrefundable last-month amount) is included when received, not deferred to the period it covers.
Question 7
Hint
Start from the usual exclusion for death benefits, then consider whether the transfer-for-value rule limits that exclusion and which payments form the transferee's tax-free recovery.
Answer C. Under the transfer-for-value rule, the exclusion for life insurance proceeds is limited to the transferee's consideration paid for the policy plus premiums paid by the transferee after acquisition. Lena's excludable recovery = $18,000 (purchase price) + $4,000 (post-acquisition premiums) = $22,000. Therefore, $100,000 − $22,000 = $78,000 of the death benefit is includible in gross income.
Why not A: Tempting because death benefits are normally tax-free, but incorrect here because the transfer-for-value rule applies to a purchased policy; Lena may only exclude the transferee's basis and post-acquisition premiums, not the whole amount.
Why not B: Tempting if one subtracts only the purchase price, but wrong because it ignores the $4,000 of premiums Lena paid after acquiring the policy, which also reduce the taxable portion.
Why not D: Tempting if one subtracts only the post-acquisition premiums, but incorrect because the purchaser's initial consideration ($18,000) is also part of the excludable recovery under the transfer-for-value limitation.
Question 8
Hint
Analyze each debt reduction separately. One is ordinary canceled debt; the other may be recharacterized because it involves the original seller and the purchase price of property still owned.
Answer C. The $6,000 canceled credit card balance is generally includible in gross income as discharge of indebtedness because Mara is solvent and no exclusion applies. The $15,000 reduction of the original seller-financed purchase-money debt, while Mara still owns the property, is treated as a purchase price adjustment rather than current COD income and thus reduces the land's basis.
Why not A: This is wrong because the canceled personal credit card debt is generally taxable COD income when the taxpayer is solvent and no exclusion applies. The seller's reduction is not a nontaxable exclusion per se but is recharacterized as a purchase price adjustment that reduces basis, so basis would change.
Why not B: This flips the correct treatment: personal debt cancellation is typically includible in gross income unless an exclusion applies, whereas a qualifying reduction of a purchase-money obligation by the original seller is treated as a purchase price adjustment, not immediate COD income.
Why not D: Both transactions involve debt reduction, but the tax code treats a qualifying seller reduction of purchase-money debt differently from ordinary COD. Because Mara still owns the land and the debt was owed to the original seller, the $15,000 reduces basis rather than producing current gross income.
Question 9
Hint
Classify each receipt first: gift, taxable interest, tax-exempt interest, and prize do not all receive the same treatment.
Answer C. Patel includes the $1,400 corporate bond interest and the $2,200 sweepstakes prize in gross income (total $3,600). The $6,000 cash gift from a grandmother is excluded from gross income, and interest on general obligation municipal bonds is generally excluded from federal gross income; the fact pattern gives no special exceptions.
Why not A: This choice reflects including only the corporate bond interest while treating the $2,200 sweepstakes prize as nontaxable. Prizes are generally includible in gross income unless an exclusion applies, and the question states no other exclusions apply.
Why not B: This answer adds the corporate bond interest and the municipal bond interest (1,400 + 900) but omits the taxable sweepstakes prize. Municipal bond interest is generally tax-exempt for federal income tax, so the $900 should not be included.
Why not D: This choice includes the corporate bond interest and the sweepstakes prize but also incorrectly includes the $900 municipal bond interest. General obligation municipal bond interest is generally excluded from federal gross income, so including that $900 overstates taxable income.
Common questions
How do I calculate taxable canceled debt when I am insolvent?
Subtract total asset FMV from total liabilities immediately before discharge to find the exclusion limit. Alex's $40,000 insolvency excludes $40,000 of the $75,000 cancellation, leaving $35,000 taxable.
When is insolvency measured for canceled debt?
Immediately before the discharge, not afterward. Alex's $220,000 liability total includes the $75,000 debt that is about to be canceled.
Do retirement accounts count as assets for the insolvency exclusion?
Yes. Alex must count the $25,000 retirement account at FMV even though it is exempt from creditors under state law.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Gross Income, worked step by step.
Gross Income & Tax Benefit Rule | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Gross Income
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.