REG · Federal Taxation of Property Transactions · 8 practice questions
Gifted Property Basis Decision Tree
Gifted property uses the donor's basis for gain, but gift-date FMV limits loss basis when it is lower. Follow the decision tree to compare net proceeds with the correct basis.
Try one first
Hint
For gifted property with built-in loss, determine which basis applies first, then separately decide whether the donor's holding period carries over.
Answer D. Because the stock's fair market value at the date of the gift ($24,000) was less than the donor's basis ($30,000), the dual-basis rule applies and Dana's loss basis is the FMV at the gift date. The recognized loss is $24,000 - $20,000 = $4,000. When the FMV at the gift date is used as the loss basis, the donor's holding period does not carry over; Dana held the stock 8 months, so the $4,000 loss is short-term.
Why not A: Tempting because it applies the donor's $30,000 carryover basis and tacks the donor's long-term holding period, yielding a $10,000 loss. It's wrong here because the stock had a built-in loss at the gift date, so the donee uses the FMV at the gift date as the loss basis instead of the donor's carryover basis.
Why not B: That rule applies when the sale price falls between the donor's basis and the FMV at the gift date. Dana sold for $20,000, which is below the $24,000 FMV at the gift date, so a loss is recognized.
Why not C: This has the correct numeric loss but incorrectly treats it as long-term. When the donee uses the FMV at the gift date as the loss basis, the donor's holding period does not tack, so Dana's 8-month holding period produces a short-term loss.
Decide it in order
T1Dana receives investment stock as a gift. Assume no gift tax or later basis adjustments. Net proceeds equal sale price minus selling expenses. Is gift-date FMV below the donor's adjusted basis?
YesGo to T2NoUse the donor's adjusted basis for both gain and loss. Net proceeds above basis produce gain; below basis produce loss; equal to basis produce neither.T2Dana's donor basis is $30,000 and gift-date FMV is $24,000. Are net proceeds above $30,000?
YesUse the $30,000 donor basis. Recognized gain equals net proceeds minus $30,000; at $33,000 net proceeds, the capital gain is $3,000.NoGo to T3T3Are net proceeds below the $24,000 gift-date FMV?
YesUse the $24,000 FMV loss basis. Recognized loss equals $24,000 minus net proceeds; at $20,000 net proceeds, the capital loss is $4,000.NoNet proceeds are from $24,000 through $30,000. Recognize no gain or loss, including at either endpoint.
Key points
- Remember: A built-in-loss gift has two bases, and net proceeds between them produce no gain or loss.
- Net proceeds equal selling price minus selling expenses.
- At either basis boundary, recognized gain or loss is zero.
How the exam traps you
- Using the $30,000 donor basis to report a loss. When gift-date FMV is $24,000, use that lower amount to measure loss.
- Using the $24,000 FMV to report a gain. Gain starts only when net proceeds exceed the $30,000 donor basis.
- Comparing gross sale price with the bases. Subtract selling expenses first, then compare net proceeds with both bases.
Question 2
Hint
First compute Baker's amount realized after selling expenses. Then determine whether the gifted property has one basis or separate gain and loss bases after the capital improvement.
Answer C. Baker's amount realized is $87,000 ($90,000 selling price less $3,000 selling expenses). Because the land's FMV at the gift date ($80,000) was less than the donor's basis ($100,000), Baker has a dual basis: for gain $105,000 (carryover basis $100,000 plus the $5,000 improvement) and for loss $85,000 (FMV-based $80,000 plus the $5,000 improvement). Since $87,000 falls between those two adjusted bases, Baker recognizes no gain or loss.
Why not A: This reflects using the donor's carryover basis for loss (100,000 + 5,000 = 105,000). That is incorrect when FMV at the gift date was lower; the FMV-based figure is used for loss. The amount realized ($87,000) is above the $85,000 loss basis, so a loss is not recognized.
Why not B: This arises if a candidate uses the FMV-based loss basis as the operative basis for gain. When FMV < donor basis at the gift date, the FMV-based figure is used only to compute loss; because $87,000 is above the $85,000 loss basis but below the $105,000 gain basis, no gain is recognized.
Why not D: This results from forgetting to subtract selling expenses (using $90,000 as amount realized) and then applying the FMV-based basis. The correct amount realized is $87,000, and with the dual-basis rule $87,000 falls between the adjusted loss basis ($85,000) and the adjusted gain basis ($105,000), so no gain is recognized.
Question 3
Hint
For gifted property with a built-in loss at the gift date, compute amount realized after selling expenses and compare it to both the donor's basis and the gift-date fair market value.
Answer B. When gift-date FMV is less than the donor's basis, the donee uses the donor's basis for computing gain and the gift-date FMV for computing loss. Ava's amount realized is $50,000 ($52,000 sales price less $2,000 commission), which lies between the $48,000 gift-date FMV and the $60,000 donor basis, so she recognizes no gain or loss. Ben's amount realized is $42,000 ($44,000 less $2,000), which is below the $48,000 loss basis, so he recognizes a $6,000 capital loss.
Why not A: This is tempting because Ava's sale price before expenses ($52,000) exceeds the gift-date FMV ($48,000). However, amount realized is net of selling expenses ($50,000), and because that net amount is still below the donor's $60,000 basis but above the $48,000 FMV, the dual-basis rule produces no recognized gain or loss.
Why not C: This distractor incorrectly uses the donor's $60,000 basis to compute Ben's loss. For loss determination when gift-date FMV is lower, the loss basis is the gift-date FMV ($48,000), so Ben's loss is $42,000 − $48,000 = $6,000, not $18,000.
Why not D: This choice wrongly applies the donor's basis to compute Ava's loss (which would be $50,000 − $60,000 = −$10,000). Because the gift-date FMV ($48,000) is lower than the donor's basis, the donee uses the FMV for loss; Ava's net proceeds fall between the FMV and donor basis, so she recognizes no gain or loss.
Question 4
Hint
Start with amount realized, not just the sales price. Then decide which gifted-property basis applies for a loss sale when the donor's basis exceeded fair market value on the date of the gift.
Answer A. Because the donor's basis ($92,000) exceeded the gift-date FMV ($70,000), the donee has a dual basis: donor's carryover basis for computing gain and the gift-date FMV (adjusted for later capital improvements) for computing loss. For a loss sale Nora's basis = $70,000 + $8,000 = $78,000. Amount realized = $76,000 − $2,000 selling expenses = $74,000, so Nora recognizes a $78,000 − $74,000 = $4,000 capital loss.
Why not B: Tempting because if the sales price falls between the gain basis and the loss basis no recognition occurs; here the amount realized ($74,000) is below the loss basis ($78,000), so a loss is recognized.
Why not C: This results from using the loss basis correctly but failing to net selling expenses (using the $76,000 gross sale price). Netting the $2,000 selling expense yields $74,000 realized, producing a $4,000 loss.
Why not D: This mistake uses the donor's carryover basis ($92,000) plus improvements ($8,000) to compute the loss basis. When donor basis exceeds gift-date FMV, the donee's basis for loss is the gift-date FMV (plus adjustments), not the donor's carryover basis.
Question 5
Hint
First compute Priya's amount realized after selling expenses. Then ask whether gifted property with FMV below donor basis uses the same basis for gain and loss.
Answer C. Priya's amount realized is $72,000 ($76,000 sale price less $4,000 selling expenses). Because the property's FMV at the date of gift ($70,000) was less than the donor's basis ($90,000), Priya uses the donor's basis to determine gain and the FMV at the gift date to determine loss. Since $72,000 falls between $70,000 and $90,000, Priya recognizes neither gain nor loss.
Why not A: Tempting if a student simply compares the amount realized ($72,000) to the donor's $90,000 basis and computes a loss. But when FMV at gift is below donor basis, the donor basis cannot be used to compute a loss, the donee uses the FMV at gift for loss determination.
Why not B: This reflects using the FMV-at-gift ($70,000) as the basis for gain, producing a $2,000 gain ($72,000 − $70,000). That is incorrect because the FMV-at-gift basis is used only to determine losses; gains are measured using the donor's $90,000 basis.
Why not D: This distractor reflects using the donor's $90,000 basis but failing to reduce the sale price by selling expenses (76,000 − 90,000 = −14,000). Even after correcting for selling expenses, the dual-basis rule prevents using the donor's basis to compute a loss here.
Question 6
Hint
For gifted property with a built-in loss, first decide whether the sale price is above the donor's basis, below the fair market value at the gift date, or between those two amounts.
Answer C. When gifted property has a fair market value below the donor's basis on the gift date, the donee uses a dual-basis rule. The donor's basis is used to determine gain, and the fair market value at the date of gift is used to determine loss. Because Maya sold the securities for $35,000, which is between $30,000 and $40,000, she recognizes no gain or loss.
Why not A: This is tempting if the candidate incorrectly uses the fair market value at the date of gift ($30,000) as the basis for all later sales. FMV on the gift date is used only to determine loss when the gifted property had a built-in loss; it is not the general carryover basis for gain in this situation.
Why not B: This reflects incorrectly applying the donor's carryover basis ($40,000) to determine loss. For gifted property with a built-in loss, the donee uses the donor's basis only to determine gain, not loss; since the sale price is above the date-of-gift FMV, no loss is recognized.
Why not D: This choice assumes the pre-gift $10,000 decline (from $40,000 to $30,000) becomes the donee's deductible loss. A built-in loss at the time of the gift cannot be converted into a deductible loss for the donee when the sale price is between the donor's basis and the date-of-gift FMV.
Question 7
Hint
For the gifted land, first compute amount realized after selling expenses, then compare that amount to both the donor's basis and the FMV on the gift date.
Answer C. Avery's amount realized on the gifted land is $80,000 ($82,000 sale price less $2,000 selling expenses). Because the donor's basis ($90,000) exceeded the FMV at the date of gift ($70,000), the dual-basis rule applies: donor basis for gain and FMV at gift for loss. Since $80,000 falls between $90,000 and $70,000, no gain or loss is recognized on the land. The inherited stock has a $40,000 basis and was sold for $37,000, producing a $3,000 recognized capital loss.
Why not A: This distractor confuses the dual-basis rule by treating FMV or donor basis incorrectly for gain. When donor basis exceeds FMV at the gift date, donor basis governs gain and FMV governs loss; the $80,000 amount realized is between those amounts, so there is neither gain nor loss on the land.
Why not B: This is tempting if a candidate assumes the donor's basis always carries over for loss; when the donor's basis exceeds FMV at the gift date, FMV is used for loss. Because Avery's $80,000 amount realized lies between FMV ($70,000) and donor basis ($90,000), no loss is recognized on the land.
Why not D: This choice may attract candidates who overgeneralize the inheritance basis rule. The inherited stock's basis is given as $40,000, and selling it for $37,000 results in a $3,000 recognized loss.
Question 8
Hint
First compute amount realized after selling expenses. Then apply the gifted-property dual-basis rule separately for gain and for loss.
Answer B. Amount realized = $101,000 − $4,000 = $97,000. For gifts where the donor's basis exceeds the FMV on the gift date, the donee uses the donor's basis to measure gain and the gift-date FMV to measure loss. Because $97,000 is less than the donor's $120,000 basis (no gain) and greater than the $95,000 loss basis (no loss), Lana recognizes neither gain nor loss; the disposition would be capital.
Why not A: This is tempting if the candidate uses the gift-date FMV ($95,000) as the basis for gain (97,000 − 95,000 = 2,000). However, for gain the donee uses the donor's $120,000 basis, not the FMV.
Why not C: This comes from 120,000 − 97,000 = 23,000 and reflects using the donor's basis for loss. When the donor's basis is higher than gift-date FMV, the donee must use the gift-date FMV ($95,000) to measure loss, so no loss is recognized here.
Why not D: This result arises if one forgets to subtract the $4,000 commission (using $101,000 as the amount realized) and then applies the donor's basis (120,000 − 101,000 = 19,000). Selling expenses reduce amount realized, and even with correct selling-expense adjustment the loss rule uses the gift-date FMV ($95,000), so no loss is recognized.
Common questions
What basis do I use when selling gifted property at a gain?
Use the donor's adjusted basis. This tree assumes no gift tax and no later basis adjustments.
What if gifted property sells between donor basis and gift-date FMV?
If gift-date FMV was lower than donor basis, recognize no gain or loss. For Dana, net proceeds from $24,000 through $30,000 produce zero recognized gain or loss.
Do selling expenses reduce gain on gifted property?
Selling expenses reduce net proceeds. Compare those net proceeds, not the gross sale price, with the relevant bases to determine gain, loss, or neither.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Basis of assets, worked step by step.
Asset Basis and Section 1245 Recapture | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Basis of assets
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.