REG · Federal Taxation of Individuals · 6 practice questions
Minimum Tax Credit: Annual Limit and Remaining Balance
Ignoring other credits, the allowable minimum tax credit is the lesser of the available carryforward or the excess of regular tax over tentative minimum tax, but not less than zero. Below: calculate the annual limit, credit used, and remaining balance.
Try one first
Hint
Start with the later-year ceiling: regular tax liability reduced by tentative minimum tax.
Answer C. The minimum tax credit usable in a later year is limited to the excess of regular tax over tentative minimum tax. Here, that ceiling is $42,000 minus $31,000, or $11,000. Since Taylor has a $25,000 carryforward, Taylor claims $11,000 now and carries the remaining $14,000 forward.
Why not A: This assumes the full carryforward is usable because regular tax is high enough. The credit is also capped by regular tax minus tentative minimum tax, which is only $11,000.
Why not B: This reverses the amount usable now and the amount remaining later. The current-year limit is $11,000, so that is the claim amount; the unused balance of the $25,000 carryforward is $14,000.
Why not D: This assumes no minimum tax credit can be used in the current year. A later-year credit is allowed to the extent regular tax exceeds tentative minimum tax, and that excess here is $11,000.
Step by step
- Start with the available carryforward
Taylor enters Year 3 with a $25,000 minimum tax credit carryforward. Ignore all other credits.
- Identify the two tax amounts
Taylor's Year 3 regular tax liability is $42,000. Tentative minimum tax is $31,000.
- Calculate the annual limit
Subtract tentative minimum tax from regular tax: $42,000 minus $31,000 equals $11,000. If the difference is zero or negative, no credit is usable.
- Use the smaller amount
Compare the $25,000 available carryforward with the $11,000 annual limit. Taylor may claim $11,000 in Year 3.
- Calculate the remaining balance
Subtract the credit used from the available carryforward: $25,000 minus $11,000 equals $14,000. That balance carries to Year 4.
- Check the tax floor
After the credit, Taylor's regular tax is $42,000 minus $11,000, or $31,000. It equals tentative minimum tax, confirming that the credit stops at the floor.
Key points
- Remember: tentative minimum tax is the floor, not the amount of credit you can claim.
- The available carryforward and the annual limit are separate ceilings. Use the smaller amount.
- Subtract the credit actually used, not the annual limit, when calculating the remaining balance.
How the exam traps you
- Claim the full $25,000 because regular tax exceeds the carryforward. Compare the carryforward with the $11,000 gap between regular tax and tentative minimum tax.
- Claim $14,000 and carry forward $11,000. The $11,000 gap is usable now. The $14,000 remainder carries to Year 4.
- Claim nothing because Taylor has tentative minimum tax. A credit is allowed because regular tax exceeds tentative minimum tax.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on whether the AMT item is only a timing difference that can reverse in a later year.
Answer A. A minimum tax credit arises only from AMT caused by items that shift income or deductions between years. The bargain element from exercising incentive stock options is such a timing difference because regular tax may catch up when the stock is later sold. The other items are not credit-generating for this purpose.
Why not B: This answer treats percentage depletion as a timing difference. The excess over basis is an AMT preference that does not create a later regular tax catch-up, so it does not generate a minimum tax credit.
Why not C: This answer comes from assuming every AMT preference can create a later credit. Private activity bond interest is included for AMT but excluded for regular tax, and that difference does not later reverse through regular tax.
Why not D: This answer assumes a disallowed deduction will automatically create a future credit. State income taxes allowed for regular tax but disallowed for AMT are not a credit-generating timing item for the AMT credit carryforward.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on whether the minimum tax credit may ever reduce tax in an earlier year.
Answer B. The minimum tax credit for individuals cannot be carried back to an earlier year. If it is not usable in the current year, it remains available as a carryforward to future years until it can be used.
Why not A: This comes from assuming the credit has a limited carryback like some other tax attributes. That fails because the minimum tax credit has no carryback period at all.
Why not C: This treats the credit like a one-year nonrefundable credit that disappears if unused. Instead, an unused minimum tax credit continues forward indefinitely.
Why not D: This mistake confuses the minimum tax credit with the general business credit rules. The minimum tax credit is not carried back, and it is not subject to a 20-year carryforward limit.
Question 4
Hint
Identify which AMT amount came from an adjustment that can reverse through future tax calculations.
Answer A. AMT attributable to depreciation differences is from a deferral-type adjustment. That type of adjustment can reverse in later years and may generate a minimum tax credit carryforward. The disallowed state income tax deduction is not included in that credit source.
Why not B: This results from treating all AMT paid as eligible for the credit carryforward. Only the portion attributable to deferral-type adjustments is considered, not the portion from disallowed state taxes.
Why not C: This results from treating all prior-year AMT as ineligible for the minimum tax credit. AMT caused by deferral-type adjustments, such as depreciation differences, may be considered for the credit carryforward.
Why not D: This results from selecting the state tax adjustment as the credit source. State income tax disallowance is not a deferral-type adjustment that reverses through future AMT computations.
Question 5
Hint
Decide whether the ISO exercise adjustment is a timing difference that can reverse, then apply the later-year AMT credit limitation.
Answer B. AMT caused by an incentive stock option exercise and hold is generally a deferral item, not a permanent difference. Because the AMT basis in the shares differs from regular tax basis, the difference can reverse later. That prior year minimum tax can produce a minimum tax credit carryforward, usable only to the extent regular tax exceeds tentative minimum tax.
Why not A: This mistake treats the ISO adjustment like a permanent AMT item. It fails because the exercise and hold adjustment is generally a timing difference tied to different stock basis for AMT and regular tax, so it can create minimum tax credit.
Why not C: This mistake assumes the credit exists only with an immediate sale. It fails because the minimum tax credit arises from prior year AMT attributable to a deferral item and may be used in later years when regular tax exceeds tentative minimum tax.
Why not D: This mistake reverses how the credit works. The minimum tax credit reduces regular tax, but only down to tentative minimum tax; it does not offset tentative minimum tax itself.
Question 6
Hint
Track the AMT credit carryforward as a running balance, adding new credits and subtracting actual uses.
Answer C. The AMT credit carryforward is a running balance. Begin with $45,000, subtract actual credits used in Year 1 and Year 3, and add the $7,000 credit generated in Year 2. The carryforward entering Year 4 is $45,000 - $9,000 + $7,000 - $13,000 = $30,000.
Why not A: This omits the $13,000 credit used on the Year 3 return. Credit used in a year reduces the carryforward entering the next year.
Why not B: This ignores the $7,000 AMT credit generated in Year 2. New AMT credit amounts are added to the carryforward balance if not used in that year.
Why not D: This treats the Year 2 generated credit as reducing the carryforward. A generated AMT credit increases the available balance, while actual credit use reduces it.
Common questions
How do you calculate the annual minimum tax credit limit?
Ignoring other credits, subtract tentative minimum tax from regular tax, with a minimum limit of zero. Taylor's limit is $42,000 minus $31,000, or $11,000.
Can I use my entire minimum tax credit carryforward?
Only if it does not exceed the annual limit. Taylor has $25,000 available but can use only $11,000.
How do I calculate the minimum tax credit remaining?
Subtract the credit actually used from the available carryforward. Taylor's $25,000 carryforward minus the $11,000 used leaves $14,000 for Year 4.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Alternative minimum tax, worked step by step.
Alternative Minimum Tax | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Alternative minimum tax
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.