PracticeISCFree practice exam

ISC · Considerations for System and Organization Controls (SOC) Engagements · 9 practice questions

SOC 2 Type 2 Qualified Opinion: Which Conclusion Changes?

For a material, nonpervasive matter, qualify only the affected SOC 2 Type 2 conclusion when the others remain supported. Below, a decision tree separates a description omission from an operating failure.

The ruleA SOC 2 Type 2 report separately addresses description, design, and operating effectiveness. For a material, nonpervasive matter, qualify only the affected conclusion; leave other conclusions unmodified when sufficient appropriate evidence supports them.

Try one first

A CPA is completing a SOC 2 Type 2 examination over the security category for the period 20X5. The CPA concludes that management's description of the system is fairly presented and that the related controls are suitably designed. Testing disclosed that one access‑review control, which is necessary to achieve one applicable security criterion, failed to operate for several months during the period. The failure is material to the operating‑effectiveness conclusion for that criterion but not pervasive to the report as a whole; testing of other controls necessary to meet the criteria showed they operated effectively. Management plans to include a narrative explanation of the lapse and its remediation in the report. What is the most appropriate auditor response?
Hint

Treat the system description, suitability of design, and operating effectiveness as separate conclusions; decide which conclusion is affected and whether the effect is pervasive.

Decide it in order

  1. T1For an access-review control in a SOC 2 Type 2 examination, is the sole issue material but nonpervasive, with sufficient appropriate evidence obtained and unaffected conclusions supported?

    NoThis tree does not determine the reporting treatment. It covers only material, nonpervasive matters with sufficient appropriate evidence and supported, unaffected conclusions.
  2. T2Is the issue an omission from the system description, while the access-review control was suitably designed and operated effectively throughout the period?

    YesQualify the description conclusion only. Leave design and operating effectiveness unmodified.
  3. T3Did the suitably designed access-review control fail to operate for part of the period, while the system description remained fairly presented?

    YesQualify the operating-effectiveness conclusion only. Leave description and design unmodified.
    NoNeither example fits. Do not assume which conclusion changes; identify the affected conclusion from the examination findings.

Key points

  • Remember: A problem in one conclusion does not automatically change the other two.
  • An accurately described, suitably designed control can still fail in operation.
  • A description omission can require qualification even when the control was suitably designed and operated effectively.

How the exam traps you

  • Qualifying all three conclusions because one matter is material. Identify the affected conclusion. Keep supported, unaffected conclusions unmodified.
  • Qualifying design because a suitably designed control was not performed. Failure to perform the control affects operating effectiveness, not automatically design.
  • Leaving a material description omission unmodified because the control operated effectively. Qualify description only when design and operating effectiveness remain supported.

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

SecurePay provides payroll processing to public-company clients and is undergoing an SOC 1 examination. Management requests an unmodified Type 2 report for Year 2 covering January 1 through December 31 because user auditors want full-year coverage. A key reconciliation control relevant to user entities' ICFR was not implemented until October 1, Year 2, and no alternative control achieved the related control objective before that date. Management's description of the system fully discloses the late implementation, and the service auditor has sufficient evidence of the control's operation from October 1 through December 31. In deciding whether an unmodified SOC 1 Type 2 opinion can cover the entire period Jan 1-Dec 31, Year 2, which factor is most governing?
Hint

Remember that a Type 2 report assesses both design and operating effectiveness over the stated period; focus on when the control actually operated.

Question 3

In a SOC 2 Type 2 examination covering only the security category for 20X5, the service auditor determined that the service organization's privileged-access approval control was accurately described in management's system description and was suitably designed. However, throughout 20X5, administrators routinely granted privileged production access without obtaining the required approvals, and no compensating review or monitoring control existed. The service auditor concluded this operating failure was pervasive to the in-scope security criteria, and there was no scope limitation. Which is the most appropriate primary reporting conclusion?
Hint

Separate the three possible report conclusions in a Type 2 examination: description, design, and operating effectiveness.

Question 4

A service auditor is performing an SOC 1 Type 2 examination. Management's description accurately states that payroll master-file changes are entered by payroll personnel and that no independent approval control exists before processing. The service auditor concludes the description fairly presents the system. However, the absence of the approval control is material because it means a stated control objective is not achieved, and there is no scope limitation. What is the correct treatment in the report?
Hint

Separate the report into its opinion elements first, then ask which of those elements is actually affected by an accurately described but materially deficient control.

Question 5

In a SOC 2 Type 2 examination, management allows the service auditor to test controls for all relevant trust services criteria except one security-related control area. Management will not provide access to certain system logs needed to test operating effectiveness in that area. Assume the missing evidence is material to the report, but the scope limitation is not pervasive to the engagement as a whole. Which reporting outcome is most appropriate?
Hint

First decide whether the problem is a known failure or a lack of evidence. Then ask whether the limitation is pervasive.

Question 6

A CPA is performing a SOC 2 Type 2 examination on a service organization's controls relevant to the security category for the period January 1 through September 30, 20X5. Assume management's description is otherwise fairly presented, the criteria are suitable and available, and management has provided the required written assertion. Which additional fact would most directly create a reporting limitation that could prevent an unmodified opinion, rather than merely an exception in operating effectiveness?
Hint

Focus on the difference between a known control failure and an inability to obtain enough evidence to evaluate controls at all.

Question 7

A CPA is completing an SOC 2 Type 2 examination of a service organization's controls relevant to the security category for the period January 1, 20X5, through December 31, 20X5. During testing, the CPA found one required monthly user-access review was completed 12 days late. For that month, automated access restrictions and daily exception-log monitoring operated effectively, no unauthorized access was identified, and no other control exceptions were found during the engagement. The CPA concludes this isolated deviation did not prevent the controls, taken as a whole, from providing reasonable assurance that the service organization's security commitments and system requirements were achieved throughout the period. Which reporting conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Focus on whether the deviation undermines the auditor's overall conclusion about operating effectiveness for the period or instead requires disclosure only.

Question 8

A CPA is completing an SOC 2 Type 2 examination for the period January 1, 20X5, through December 31, 20X5, covering the security and processing integrity categories. The CPA concludes that management's description of the system is fairly presented and that the controls are suitably designed. However, after a midyear system update, a key automated input-validation control relevant to processing integrity did not operate for two months, and no other control addressed that risk during that time. The CPA concludes this matter is material to operating effectiveness for processing integrity, but not pervasive to the entire engagement. What is the best reporting action?
Hint

For a Type 2 report, separate the conclusions on description, design, and operating effectiveness, then decide whether the problem is limited or pervasive.

Question 9

A service auditor is completing an SOC 2 Type 2 examination covering the security category for the period January 1 through December 31, 20X5. The auditor concludes that management's description of the system is fairly presented and that the relevant controls were suitably designed. However, system-generated access-review logs for October through December were corrupted and cannot be recovered, and alternative procedures do not provide sufficient appropriate evidence about whether that access-review control operated effectively during those three months. No other testing issues were identified. Which factor should primarily govern whether the service auditor's opinion on operating effectiveness is qualified or disclaimed?
Hint

First decide whether this is an inability to obtain evidence (a scope limitation) or a detected control failure. Then recall how materiality and pervasiveness guide the auditor's choice between a qualified opinion and a disclaimer.

Drill all 209 Reporting on an SOC engagement questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Which SOC 2 Type 2 conclusion is qualified for a control failure?

For a material, nonpervasive operating failure, qualify operating effectiveness only if the description is fairly presented and design remains suitable. Leave those supported conclusions unmodified.

Does an operating failure require a qualified design conclusion?

Not automatically. If the control was suitably designed but was not performed, the failure affects operating effectiveness.

Does a description omission change all SOC 2 Type 2 conclusions?

No. A material, nonpervasive omission qualifies description only when sufficient appropriate evidence supports suitable design and effective operation.

Watch it solved

A full CPA ISC task-based simulation on Reporting on an SOC engagement, worked step by step.

ISC Simulation: SOC 1 Type 2 Sections and Qualified Opinion on YouTube

Practice ISC like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Reporting on an SOC engagement

All Reporting on an SOC engagement practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.