PracticeISCFree practice exam

ISC · Security and Confidentiality and Privacy · 9 practice questions

Do NIST CSF and ISO 27001 Satisfy HIPAA or PCI DSS?

Framework alignment, certification, and control mappings do not by themselves establish HIPAA or PCI DSS compliance. Below: judge management's proposed compliance conclusions against the requirements that actually bind the company.

The ruleIdentify applicable legal and contractual obligations first, then evaluate controls against those requirements. Framework alignment, certification, and crosswalks can support that evaluation but do not by themselves establish compliance.

Try one first

A U.S. company adopts the NIST Cybersecurity Framework to organize its cybersecurity program. Management asks whether adopting that framework means the company is now automatically compliant with all applicable privacy and cybersecurity laws. Assume no specific law provides a safe harbor solely for adopting the framework. Which conclusion is most appropriate?
Hint

Separate the role of a voluntary framework or standard from the role of an actual law or regulation.

What should you do?

The situation

Harbor Clinic is a HIPAA covered entity that maintains electronic protected health information and stores patient cardholder data. Its merchant agreement requires PCI DSS compliance. Harbor adopts NIST CSF, obtains ISO 27001 certification, and completes a controls crosswalk to HIPAA and PCI DSS. No applicable law or contract recognizes these steps as substitutes for compliance. Management has not evaluated whether Harbor actually meets each regime's requirements.

  1. Evaluate HIPAA and PCI DSS requirements directly, using the framework, certification, and crosswalk as support.

    Best HIPAA and the merchant agreement impose separate obligations. None of Harbor's organizing or certification steps establishes compliance by itself.

  2. Declare compliance with both regimes because Harbor aligned its program to NIST CSF.

    Wrong NIST CSF organizes cybersecurity risk management. Alignment does not establish that Harbor meets HIPAA or PCI DSS requirements.

  3. Use ISO 27001 certification instead of separate HIPAA and PCI DSS compliance evaluations.

    Wrong Certification supports the security program but does not replace either regime's specific requirements.

  4. Declare compliance because the completed crosswalk links Harbor's controls to both regimes.

    Wrong The crosswalk documents alignment. It does not demonstrate that Harbor actually satisfies the mapped requirements.

  5. Evaluate HIPAA only because PCI DSS is an industry standard rather than federal law.

    Wrong Harbor's merchant agreement requires PCI DSS compliance. Contractual obligations remain binding despite framework alignment or certification.

Key points

  • Remember: A framework organizes the program; HIPAA and the merchant agreement determine what the company must satisfy.
  • PCI DSS can be contractually mandatory even though it is not a federal regulation.
  • NIST CSF alignment and ISO 27001 certification remain useful without replacing direct HIPAA and PCI DSS evaluations.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating NIST CSF alignment or ISO 27001 certification as automatic compliance. Evaluate the applicable HIPAA and PCI DSS requirements directly.
  • Treating a completed crosswalk as proof that mapped obligations are satisfied. A crosswalk shows alignment, not whether the company actually meets each requirement.
  • Calling PCI DSS optional because it is an industry standard. The company's merchant agreement makes PCI DSS binding.

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

MediHost, a U.S.-based cloud provider, hosts billing and patient-portal systems for physician practices. Under written agreements it can create, receive, maintain, and transmit electronic protected health information (ePHI), assume MediHost is a HIPAA business associate. MediHost also stores cardholder data for recurring patient payments and is in scope as a PCI DSS service provider. It has no EU operations and does not target or monitor individuals in the EU. Which statement is best supported?
Hint

Think in three categories: legal/regulatory obligations (HIPAA), industry/contractual standards (PCI DSS), and voluntary frameworks or attestations (NIST CSF, ISO 27001, SOC 2); which apply directly to MediHost?

Question 3

In 20X6, Orion Data Services aligned its enterprise security program to NIST CSF 2.0 and maintains ISO/IEC 27001 certification. For a legacy administrative portal, management proposes using network segmentation, strong logging, and continuous monitoring instead of multifactor authentication (MFA) because its internal CSF profile rates the residual risk as acceptable. An applicable state cybersecurity regulation and a customer contract that incorporates, by reference, a mandatory industry standard both expressly require MFA for privileged remote access to that portal. The portal is in scope for both requirements, and neither external requirement permits a compensating-control alternative. Which of the following is the most appropriate treatment?
Hint

Identify which external authorities impose mandatory controls for the in‑scope portal and whether they allow compensating measures.

Question 4

A privately held personal‑finance app lets consumers link bank and card accounts, aggregates balances and spending, and initiates bill payments from linked accounts. The app charges subscription fees through an outsourced credit‑card processor and plans to adopt the NIST Cybersecurity Framework as its enterprise security model. Management tells its CPA, "If we adopt NIST, we should be covered for any external security requirements." Which response is most appropriate?
Hint

Distinguish voluntary control frameworks and third‑party services from obligations that are defined by statute, regulation, or contract; consider what duties can remain after outsourcing a payment function.

Question 5

North Peak Co. is subject to a state privacy law requiring reasonable security safeguards, documented vendor oversight, and timely responses to consumer deletion requests. Management aligns the company's cybersecurity controls to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework. Assume the law does not treat use of any framework as automatic compliance, and North Peak has not separately evaluated whether its deletion-request process meets the law's timing and documentation requirements. Which consequence is best supported?
Hint

Ask whether framework alignment 'supports' compliance or actually 'replaces' specific legal requirements, focus on the deletion-request obligation.

Question 6

In Year 2, an online retailer that already maintains PCI DSS compliance for its payment‑card environment begins collecting additional personal data from EU customers for targeted marketing and customer analytics. Management concludes that because PCI DSS is already in place, the company does not need a separate review of privacy obligations for the new activity. Assume the GDPR applies to this new personal‑data processing. Which consequence is most supportable?
Hint

Distinguish an industry security standard from a legal privacy regime, and consider which GDPR obligations (e.g., lawful basis, data‑subject rights, DPIA) are commonly implicated by profiling/targeted marketing.

Question 7

CloudCo is a privately held U.S. software company that hosts a billing platform for physician groups, stores electronic protected health information (ePHI) on their behalf, and directly accepts payment card transactions from patients. A large prospective customer asks whether CloudCo is "NIST compliant." Assume CloudCo has no federal contracts and no additional state-specific facts are relevant; the customer's informal inquiry does not, by itself, create a binding contractual obligation. Which action is most appropriate for management to take first when structuring CloudCo's security program?
Hint

Distinguish which obligations are legally or contractually binding from which frameworks, certifications, or attestations are options for implementing or demonstrating controls.

Question 8

A health-tech retailer accepts payment cards and hosts electronic protected health information (ePHI) for provider clients. To reduce duplicate compliance work, management created one internal control catalog and mapped each control to the applicable HIPAA Security Rule standards, PCI DSS requirements, and NIST Cybersecurity Framework categories. Assume the mapping is complete and current, the company has correctly identified which HIPAA and PCI DSS requirements apply, and some mapped requirements have different evidence types or testing frequencies. Which consequence is most accurate?
Hint

Ask whether the same test scope, evidence content, and frequency can automatically satisfy every mapped requirement.

Question 9

Blue Mesa Cloud hosts a scheduling and billing platform for physician practices. In that role it receives, maintains, and transmits electronic protected health information (ePHI) on behalf of the practices. Assume Blue Mesa is a HIPAA business associate. Management asks whether obtaining ISO 27001 certification alone satisfies its external security obligations, specifically whether ISO 27001 replaces HIPAA Security Rule requirements such as performing a security risk analysis and implementing required administrative, physical, and technical safeguards. Which response is most appropriate?
Hint

First decide whether Blue Mesa falls within HIPAA's scope as a business associate, then evaluate whether a voluntary framework can replace a legal/regulatory obligation or only help support it.

Drill all 157 Regulations and standards and frameworks questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Does adopting NIST CSF make a company HIPAA compliant?

No. NIST CSF can organize the security program, but the company must still evaluate whether its controls meet applicable HIPAA Security Rule requirements.

Does ISO 27001 certification replace PCI DSS compliance?

No. ISO 27001 certification does not by itself satisfy PCI DSS obligations imposed through the company's merchant agreement.

Does a NIST crosswalk prove HIPAA and PCI DSS compliance?

No. A crosswalk connects controls to requirements, but the company must still establish that it meets the applicable HIPAA and PCI DSS requirements.

Practice ISC like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Regulations and standards and frameworks

All Regulations and standards and frameworks practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.