PracticeISCFree practice exam

ISC · Considerations for System and Organization Controls (SOC) Engagements · 9 practice questions

SOC 2 Inclusive vs. Carve-Out: Which Controls Are Tested?

Management's inclusive or carve-out presentation determines whether the data center's controls enter the SOC 2 examination scope. Below, compare the same Apex Payroll system under each method to see what the auditor tests and what stays in the description.

The ruleManagement's inclusive or carve-out presentation determines whether the data center's relevant controls are included in the examination. Carve-out excludes provider controls from testing and the opinion, but relevant Apex controls, including monitoring, remain in scope.

Try one first

During planning of an SOC 2 Type 2 examination over the security category, a service organization's system description uses the inclusive method for a colocation provider that performs physical security, environmental safeguards, and backup media storage. No separate report on the provider is available, and the provider refuses to allow the service auditor to inspect controls, observe procedures, or perform tests at its site. The service organization can provide vendor oversight reviews and SLA monitoring reports, and management wants the provider's controls included because user entities consider them critical. Which action is most appropriate for the service auditor?
Hint

Focus on the auditor's need for sufficient appropriate evidence when controls of a subservice organization are included in the system, consider whether direct testing or acceptable independent third-party evidence is available rather than relying only on management monitoring or disclosure.

Side by side

Inclusive methodCarve-out method
Same system and controlsApex Payroll is undergoing a SOC 2 Type 2 security examination. Its outside data center operates physical security and environmental safeguards that, together with Apex's controls, are necessary to meet the applicable security criteria. Apex reviews vendor reports and follows up on exceptions.Apex Payroll is undergoing a SOC 2 Type 2 security examination. Its outside data center operates physical security and environmental safeguards that, together with Apex's controls, are necessary to meet the applicable security criteria. Apex reviews vendor reports and follows up on exceptions.
Only changed factManagement presents the data center using the inclusive method.Management presents the data center using the carve-out method.
Data center control testingInclude its relevant physical security and environmental controls in examination testing.Do not test its physical security or environmental controls in this examination.
Opinion coverageCovers Apex's relevant controls and the included data center controls.Covers Apex's relevant controls, not the data center's controls.
Apex's vendor monitoringTest relevant vendor-report reviews and exception follow-up for design and operating effectiveness.Test relevant vendor-report reviews and exception follow-up for design and operating effectiveness.
System descriptionInclude the data center's relevant services and controls within the described system.Describe its services and identify assumed complementary subservice organization controls, without including those controls in the examination scope.

Key points

  • Remember: Carve-out excludes the provider's controls, not Apex's controls over the provider.
  • Physical security can be necessary to meet the criteria without being included in the auditor's opinion.
  • Disclosing assumed provider controls does not mean the auditor tested them.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating tested vendor-report reviews as tested data center controls. Apex's vendor-report reviews are Apex controls. Testing them does not bring the data center's controls into a carve-out opinion.
  • Omitting the data center from the description because its controls are carved out. Describe its services and identify the complementary subservice organization controls Apex assumes are in place.
  • Requiring inclusive presentation because the data center's safeguards are necessary to meet the security criteria. Necessity does not force inclusion. Management's presentation method determines whether those controls enter the examination scope.

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Maple Payroll is planning a SOC 1 Type 2 examination for Year 2. Maple uses HostCo, a third-party data center, to run and store payroll processing data. In its system description, management identifies HostCo's controls as "complementary subservice organization controls" rather than describing HostCo's controls as part of Maple's control environment. During planning, Maple's service auditor also obtains a current SOC 1 Type 2 report for HostCo. In deciding whether HostCo's controls will be included in the service auditor's testing and opinion in Maple's SOC 1 report, which factor is most governing?
Hint

Focus on what establishes the reporting boundary for a subservice organization in the service auditor's report, not on factors that make the outsourced function important.

Question 3

NorthPeak Processing is planning a SOC 2 Type 2 examination on its transaction-processing system. NorthPeak uses SafeSite Data Centers to provide physical facility, environmental safeguards, and backup power. Management's description identifies SafeSite as a subservice organization and discloses the facility and environmental safeguards NorthPeak assumes SafeSite operates in designing NorthPeak's controls. The practitioner intends to test only controls performed by NorthPeak. Assuming the arrangement is otherwise properly described, how should this presentation be classified for the SOC 2 engagement?
Hint

Decide who performs the controls (subservice organization vs. user entity) and whether those controls are included in the service auditor's testing or only described as assumed in the service organization's control design.

Question 4

AlphaPay is planning an SOC 2 examination covering Security and Availability for the year ended December 31, 20X5. AlphaPay outsources data center hosting, physical access, and certain environmental safeguards to CloudHost. Management elects the carve-out method for CloudHost, so CloudHost's controls are not intended to be included in AlphaPay's system description. During planning, the practitioner determines that several relevant trust services criteria can be achieved only if certain controls at CloudHost operate as contemplated. Assuming management is willing to revise the description if needed, what is the practitioner's best action?
Hint

Separate two issues: whether the outsourced activities matter to the criteria, and how those activities are presented when management chooses carve-out rather than inclusive.

Question 5

During planning for an SOC 2 Type 2 examination on security and availability, Orion Services uses a third-party data center to provide physical security, environmental safeguards, and backup power for the servers that run Orion's application. Orion has decided to use the carve-out method for that data center. Orion's user entities are expected to approve their own end-user access requests and review daily exception reports generated by Orion. Assuming these controls are relevant to the applicable criteria, which classification is most appropriate for Orion's system description and the service auditor's planning?
Hint

First separate controls performed by Orion's third-party provider from controls expected to be performed by Orion's customers. Then consider what the carve-out method does, and does not do, to the provider's controls.

Question 6

During planning of a SOC 1 type 2 examination, Apex Payroll Services uses a third-party cloud host to store and transmit payroll files. Management elects the carve-out method for the cloud host. Apex also has controls at the service organization that review daily interface exceptions from the cloud host and investigate unresolved transmission failures. Assume those Apex controls are relevant to the control objectives included in the engagement. What is the correct treatment by the service auditor?
Hint

Separate the service organization's own controls from the subservice organization's controls, then ask what the carve-out method changes and what it does not.

Question 7

A CPA firm will perform a SOC 2 Type 2 examination of Arden Hosting's system for the security criterion for the period January 1 through September 30, 20X6. Arden's production environment is hosted at a third‑party colocation facility, and management wants to use the carve-out method for that subservice organization. In Arden's draft system description, management states only that a third‑party facility hosts the production servers and does not identify the services performed by the subservice organization or any complementary subservice organization controls. Management says no further detail is needed because the facility is carved out and Arden's monthly vendor‑monitoring meetings suffice. Assuming engagement preconditions are met, which conclusion is best?
Hint

Carve-out changes which controls the practitioner tests, not management's obligation to describe the subservice organization's services and complementary controls.

Question 8

BlueSky Payroll is planning an SOC 2 Type 2 examination over the security and availability categories for 20X6. BlueSky uses CloudCo to host production servers and perform managed firewall monitoring. Management elects the carve-out method for CloudCo because CloudCo will not provide the information and representations needed for an inclusive presentation. In BlueSky's draft system description, management states only that "CloudCo performs certain infrastructure services that are outside the scope of this report" and does not identify any complementary subservice organization controls or any relevant complementary user entity controls related to identity federation and review of access alerts. Management tells user entities they can read CloudCo's separate SOC report for more detail. Assume CloudCo's services are relevant to the trust services criteria in scope. Which conclusion is most appropriate for the practitioner during planning?
Hint

Distinguish what the carve-out method changes (the practitioner's opinion/testing) from what it does not change (management's responsibility to provide a suitably complete system description).

Question 9

HarborPay is planning an SOC 2 Type 2 engagement for Year 1 covering the security and availability trust services criteria. HarborPay uses a third-party colocation provider for physical access controls, power, and environmental safeguards over the servers used in HarborPay's production environment. Management intends to use the carve-out method for this subservice organization, and the provider's controls are relevant to meeting the applicable criteria. Which action is most appropriate for the service auditor during planning?
Hint

Focus on what the carve-out method changes: whether the subservice organization's controls become part of the controls tested, and how that organization's role should be described.

Drill all 207 Planning and performing an SOC engagement questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Does SOC 2 carve-out exclude vendor-monitoring controls?

No. Apex's relevant vendor-report reviews and exception follow-up remain in scope because Apex performs them. The data center's own controls are excluded.

Do critical data center controls require the inclusive method?

No. Even when physical security and environmental safeguards are necessary to meet the security criteria, management may use carve-out. Those provider controls then remain outside the auditor's testing and opinion.

What must a SOC 2 carve-out system description disclose?

It must describe the data center's services and identify the complementary subservice organization controls Apex assumes are in place. Carve-out excludes provider controls from testing, not the provider's role from disclosure.

Watch it solved

A full CPA ISC task-based simulation on Planning and performing an SOC engagement, worked step by step.

SOC Report Selection & Engagement Planning | CPA ISC TBS on YouTube

Practice ISC like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Planning and performing an SOC engagement

All Planning and performing an SOC engagement practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.