ISC · Considerations for System and Organization Controls (SOC) Engagements · 9 practice questions
SOC 2 Inclusive vs. Carve-Out: Which Controls Are Tested?
Management's inclusive or carve-out presentation determines whether the data center's controls enter the SOC 2 examination scope. Below, compare the same Apex Payroll system under each method to see what the auditor tests and what stays in the description.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on the auditor's need for sufficient appropriate evidence when controls of a subservice organization are included in the system, consider whether direct testing or acceptable independent third-party evidence is available rather than relying only on management monitoring or disclosure.
Answer B. An inclusive SOC 2 opinion covers controls at included subservice organizations, so the service auditor must obtain sufficient appropriate evidence about those controls, either by testing at the provider or by obtaining acceptable independent third-party evidence. When the provider refuses access and no adequate third-party report or equivalent evidence is available, the auditor cannot support an inclusive opinion. The auditor should therefore require a carve-out (excluding the provider's controls from the opinion) or reconsider acceptance or continuation of the engagement.
Why not A: Tempting because management is responsible for the system and may monitor vendors, but management assertions and internal monitoring reports generally do not provide the auditor with sufficient appropriate evidence to support inclusion of a subservice organization's controls in the auditor's opinion.
Why not C: Tempting because disclosure is important, but disclosure of a limitation or reliance in the report does not substitute for the auditor's requirement to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence before issuing an inclusive opinion.
Why not D: Tempting because Type 1 does not include operating-effectiveness testing, but converting to Type 1 does not remove the auditor's obligation to obtain evidence about the accuracy of the system description or the suitability of control design for included subservice organization controls; refusal of access may still prevent adequate evidence.
Side by side
| Inclusive method | Carve-out method | |
|---|---|---|
| Same system and controls | Apex Payroll is undergoing a SOC 2 Type 2 security examination. Its outside data center operates physical security and environmental safeguards that, together with Apex's controls, are necessary to meet the applicable security criteria. Apex reviews vendor reports and follows up on exceptions. | Apex Payroll is undergoing a SOC 2 Type 2 security examination. Its outside data center operates physical security and environmental safeguards that, together with Apex's controls, are necessary to meet the applicable security criteria. Apex reviews vendor reports and follows up on exceptions. |
| Only changed fact | Management presents the data center using the inclusive method. | Management presents the data center using the carve-out method. |
| Data center control testing | Include its relevant physical security and environmental controls in examination testing. | Do not test its physical security or environmental controls in this examination. |
| Opinion coverage | Covers Apex's relevant controls and the included data center controls. | Covers Apex's relevant controls, not the data center's controls. |
| Apex's vendor monitoring | Test relevant vendor-report reviews and exception follow-up for design and operating effectiveness. | Test relevant vendor-report reviews and exception follow-up for design and operating effectiveness. |
| System description | Include the data center's relevant services and controls within the described system. | Describe its services and identify assumed complementary subservice organization controls, without including those controls in the examination scope. |
Key points
- Remember: Carve-out excludes the provider's controls, not Apex's controls over the provider.
- Physical security can be necessary to meet the criteria without being included in the auditor's opinion.
- Disclosing assumed provider controls does not mean the auditor tested them.
How the exam traps you
- Treating tested vendor-report reviews as tested data center controls. Apex's vendor-report reviews are Apex controls. Testing them does not bring the data center's controls into a carve-out opinion.
- Omitting the data center from the description because its controls are carved out. Describe its services and identify the complementary subservice organization controls Apex assumes are in place.
- Requiring inclusive presentation because the data center's safeguards are necessary to meet the security criteria. Necessity does not force inclusion. Management's presentation method determines whether those controls enter the examination scope.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on what establishes the reporting boundary for a subservice organization in the service auditor's report, not on factors that make the outsourced function important.
Answer D. Management's presentation method in its system description determines the reporting boundary. Under the carve-out method (complementary controls), the subservice organization's controls are excluded from the service auditor's testing and opinion even if those services are significant or a separate SOC report exists. If management uses the inclusive method and other engagement requirements are met, the service auditor may include the subservice organization's controls in scope, but only after obtaining sufficient appropriate evidence (for example, a current SOC report or direct testing).
Why not A: This is tempting because the significance of outsourced services affects risk assessment and planning. However, significance alone does not establish whether those controls fall inside the auditor's opinion boundary, management's chosen presentation method does.
Why not B: A current SOC report is useful evidence and may be relied on if the subservice organization is presented as included, which makes this distractor tempting. But obtaining a SOC report does not change the reporting boundary set by management's system description and cannot convert a carve-out into an inclusive presentation.
Why not C: Expected user reliance makes the controls important to users and may influence how management describes outsourcing, which is why this option tempts. Nonetheless, expected reliance does not itself determine whether those controls are part of the service auditor's opinion, the presentation method set by management does.
Question 3
Hint
Decide who performs the controls (subservice organization vs. user entity) and whether those controls are included in the service auditor's testing or only described as assumed in the service organization's control design.
Answer B. This is a carve-out presentation. When management's description identifies a subservice organization and discloses the complementary controls the service organization assumes the subservice provides, the service auditor's testing typically excludes the subservice organization's controls; the service organization's description, not the auditor's testing, addresses those externally performed controls.
Why not A: Tempting because SafeSite's controls clearly affect the trust services criteria and an inclusive presentation would bring them into the auditor's testing. It is wrong here because the facts indicate SafeSite is identified as a separate subservice organization with complementary controls described by NorthPeak rather than being incorporated into NorthPeak's tested control population.
Why not C: Attractive because both involve controls performed by an external party, but complementary user entity controls refer to controls the service organization expects user entities (its customers) to implement. SafeSite is a subservice organization, not a user entity, so this classification does not apply.
Why not D: Some candidates view excluding outsourced controls as a scope limitation that mandates report modification. That is tempting, but SOC guidance permits a carve-out when the subservice organization's role and the complementary controls are properly described; a report modification is required only when the omission prevents the auditor from obtaining sufficient appropriate evidence or is not properly disclosed.
Question 4
Hint
Separate two issues: whether the outsourced activities matter to the criteria, and how those activities are presented when management chooses carve-out rather than inclusive.
Answer A. Under the carve-out method, controls at a subservice organization are excluded from the service organization's system description. Management's description must still identify the services performed by the subservice organization and any complementary subservice organization controls that are relied on. The practitioner may proceed with a carve-out presentation if the description is fair and the engagement is scoped to AlphaPay's controls; the opinion does not extend to CloudHost's controls merely because they affect the criteria.
Why not B: This distractor stems from overgeneralizing the importance of outsourced controls. While inclusive is one option, the existence of relied-upon subservice organization controls does not, by itself, force management to choose the inclusive method if the description transparently discloses the subservice organization's role under a carve-out.
Why not C: This option confuses categories. Complementary user entity controls are expected of user entities, not of a vendor engaged by the service organization. CloudHost is a subservice organization, so its controls are not reclassified as user-entity controls.
Why not D: Even if the practitioner could test CloudHost's controls, those controls are outside AlphaPay's described system under a carve-out. Including their operating effectiveness in AlphaPay's opinion would require management to include them in the system description (i.e., use the inclusive method) or otherwise change the scope.
Question 5
Hint
First separate controls performed by Orion's third-party provider from controls expected to be performed by Orion's customers. Then consider what the carve-out method does, and does not do, to the provider's controls.
Answer A. Under the carve-out method, controls at a subservice organization (the third-party data center) are not included as the service organization's own controls; instead, relevant controls at that provider are identified as complementary subservice organization controls. Separately, activities the service organization expects user entities to perform (approving their own access and reviewing exception reports) are complementary user entity controls. Thus the classifications in option A correctly distinguish provider-side controls from customer-side controls.
Why not B: This inverts who performs each control. The data center is a third-party provider to Orion (a subservice organization), so its controls are complementary subservice organization controls, not user entity controls, while the approval and review tasks are performed by Orion's customers and are user entity controls.
Why not C: Although management retains responsibility for outsourced services, for SOC reporting the locus of control matters: under the carve-out method, controls at the subservice organization are not reported as the service organization's own controls but are identified as complementary subservice organization controls.
Why not D: Carve-out does not make subservice organization controls disappear; it excludes them from being described as the service organization's own controls but still requires identification of relevant complementary subservice organization controls in planning and the system description.
Question 6
Hint
Separate the service organization's own controls from the subservice organization's controls, then ask what the carve-out method changes and what it does not.
Answer B. Under the carve-out method, the service auditor does not test controls at the subservice organization. Relevant controls at the service organization (for example, Apex's monitoring of interface exceptions) remain in scope and should be tested if they relate to the control objectives. Management's system description must still identify the services performed by the subservice organization and disclose any complementary subservice organization controls the service organization's control design assumes.
Why not A: Tempting because candidates sometimes overread 'carve-out' as excluding everything tied to the vendor. Carve-out excludes testing of the subservice organization's controls, but it does not exclude the service organization's own controls (such as vendor oversight, monitoring, and reconciliation) from the engagement.
Why not C: Appealing since the cloud host affects delivery, but incorrect because the carve-out method, if management elects it, means the service auditor does not test the subservice organization's controls. If management wanted inclusive testing, management would elect the inclusive method instead.
Why not D: Partially true that Apex's controls remain in scope, but wrong to say the subservice organization can be omitted from the description. Under carve-out, the description must still identify the subservice organization's services and any complementary subservice organization controls relevant to the design of the service organization's controls.
Question 7
Hint
Carve-out changes which controls the practitioner tests, not management's obligation to describe the subservice organization's services and complementary controls.
Answer B. Under the carve-out method, controls at a subservice organization are excluded from the practitioner's testing, but management still must disclose in the system description the services performed by the carved-out subservice organization and the complementary subservice organization controls relevant to the applicable criterion. Because Arden's draft omits those disclosures, management should revise the description; the practitioner would not test the subservice organization's controls.
Why not A: This is tempting because carved-out controls are not tested, giving the impression less disclosure is needed. However, carve-out affects testing scope, not disclosure obligations, management must still identify the subservice organization's services and the complementary controls relevant to the criterion.
Why not C: This distractor appeals because the colocation's physical/environmental controls relate to security. But the mere existence of relevant controls does not automatically mandate the inclusive method; management may use carve-out provided the system description properly discloses the subservice organization's role and complementary controls.
Why not D: Testing vendor‑monitoring controls might be appropriate and influence the practitioner's risk assessment, but it does not eliminate management's obligation to describe the carved-out subservice organization's services and the complementary subservice organization controls in the system description.
Question 8
Hint
Distinguish what the carve-out method changes (the practitioner's opinion/testing) from what it does not change (management's responsibility to provide a suitably complete system description).
Answer D. Under the carve-out method, the practitioner's opinion excludes the subservice organization's controls, but management remains responsible for a suitably complete system description. When outsourced services are relevant to the selected trust services criteria, management should describe the nature of those services and identify any complementary subservice organization controls and complementary user entity controls so users can understand the carved-out scope. A separate SOC report from the subservice organization may be helpful to users but does not relieve management of that disclosure obligation.
Why not A: This is tempting because exclusion from testing is disclosed, but it is incorrect: management must describe complementary subservice organization controls and complementary user entity controls when outsourced services are relevant to the in-scope criteria, regardless of whether BlueSky plans to rely on the subservice organization's controls.
Why not B: This is tempting because carve-out excludes the subservice organization's controls from the practitioner's opinion, but it is incorrect: management must still provide a suitably complete system description that identifies relevant outsourced services and the related complementary controls. Merely referring users to a separate SOC report does not meet that requirement.
Why not C: This distractor is plausible because inclusive presentation gives users direct reporting on the subservice organization, but relevance alone does not mandate inclusive presentation. Carve-out remains permissible provided management's system description adequately describes the outsourced services and identifies the related complementary controls.
Question 9
Hint
Focus on what the carve-out method changes: whether the subservice organization's controls become part of the controls tested, and how that organization's role should be described.
Answer C. Under the carve-out method, the subservice organization's controls are not included as if they were the service organization's controls. The auditor should confirm the description properly identifies the subservice organization's role and any complementary subservice organization controls and plan the engagement to test HarborPay's own controls as described, rather than treating the provider's controls as HarborPay's controls.
Why not A: This answer reflects the inclusive approach. Under carve-out, the auditor does not include the subservice organization's controls as HarborPay's controls even if those controls are relevant to the criteria.
Why not B: Relevance alone does not force use of the inclusive method. Management may use carve-out provided the system description and any complementary subservice organization controls are appropriately identified; the auditor does not automatically require inclusive treatment.
Why not D: Complementary user entity controls are controls expected to be performed by user entities (customers), not by a subservice organization. The colocation provider is a subservice organization, so its controls would be described as subservice organization controls or complementary subservice organization controls, not user entity controls.
Common questions
Does SOC 2 carve-out exclude vendor-monitoring controls?
No. Apex's relevant vendor-report reviews and exception follow-up remain in scope because Apex performs them. The data center's own controls are excluded.
Do critical data center controls require the inclusive method?
No. Even when physical security and environmental safeguards are necessary to meet the security criteria, management may use carve-out. Those provider controls then remain outside the auditor's testing and opinion.
What must a SOC 2 carve-out system description disclose?
It must describe the data center's services and identify the complementary subservice organization controls Apex assumes are in place. Carve-out excludes provider controls from testing, not the provider's role from disclosure.
Watch it solved
A full CPA ISC task-based simulation on Planning and performing an SOC engagement, worked step by step.
SOC Report Selection & Engagement Planning | CPA ISC TBS on YouTube
Practice ISC like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Planning and performing an SOC engagement
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.