PracticeISCFree practice exam

ISC · Information Systems and Data Management · 10 practice questions

ERP Revenue Recognition: Shipment vs. Invoice Date

Recognize a sale when control transfers, not when the invoice is prepared. Below: one sale with one fact changed at a time to show what belongs in the December 31 accounts.

The ruleRecognize revenue, accounts receivable, COGS, and inventory reduction when control transfers. For Orion's FOB shipping point sale, that occurs at shipment; preparing the invoice later does not delay recognition.

Try one first

An organization uses an ERP with Sales Order (SO), Warehouse Management (WMS), Billing/Accounts Receivable (AR), and General Ledger (GL) modules. For product sales the terms are FOB shipping point and the company's accounting policy recognizes revenue when control transfers at shipment. The WMS records a goods-issue/shipment confirmation at the time goods physically leave the warehouse; invoices are produced by AR in an overnight billing batch that frequently occurs several hours after shipment; the GL is updated via a nightly EOD posting that includes entries created during the day. To ensure timely and properly matched recognition of revenue, accounts receivable, inventory, and cost of goods sold in the GL, which system event should be configured to trigger the journal entries for those accounts?
Hint

Identify which system event most directly shows the company has completed its performance obligation and relinquished control of the goods.

Same scenario, one fact changes

Base case

Orion sells goods for $10,000 that cost $6,000. Its ERP uses perpetual inventory. The goods ship December 31, Year 1, under FOB shipping point terms, with control transferring at shipment. Delivery occurs January 3, Year 2. Orion prepares the invoice January 2, Year 2. What should Orion recognize as of December 31, Year 1?

Answer: Recognize the sale in Year 1: debit accounts receivable $10,000; credit revenue $10,000; debit COGS $6,000; credit inventory $6,000.

Control transfers at shipment on December 31. The January invoice does not delay recognition of either revenue or COGS.

Before you open each one, predict the answer.

Change 1Change only the shipping terms to FOB destination, with control transferring on delivery.

Answer: Recognize none of the sale entries in Year 1. Recognize revenue, accounts receivable, COGS, and inventory reduction on January 3, Year 2.

Control transfers on January 3 delivery, not December 31 shipment. The goods remain Orion's inventory at year-end.

Change 2Change only the shipment date to January 2, Year 2.

Answer: Recognize none of the sale entries in Year 1. Recognize revenue, accounts receivable, COGS, and inventory reduction on January 2, Year 2.

FOB shipping point still makes shipment the trigger, but shipment now occurs after year-end.

Change 3Change only the invoice preparation date to December 28, Year 1.

Answer: Recognition remains December 31: debit accounts receivable $10,000; credit revenue $10,000; debit COGS $6,000; credit inventory $6,000.

The earlier invoice is a tempting but irrelevant date. Preparing it does not transfer control before the December 31 shipment.

Key points

  • Remember: Find the control-transfer date first; the invoice date does not move it.
  • Record both sides together: revenue and receivables, plus COGS and inventory reduction.
  • For Orion's FOB destination version, delivery replaces shipment as the recognition trigger.

How the exam traps you

  • Waiting for the January invoice to recognize the December shipment. Recognize the FOB shipping point sale on December 31, when control transfers.
  • Recognizing revenue in December but waiting until January to record COGS. Recognize revenue and COGS together when control transfers.
  • Using shipment as the trigger even after the terms change to FOB destination. Use the January delivery date because control transfers on delivery in that version.

Now the same facts as questions

Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.

Question 1

Orion sells goods for $10,000 that cost $6,000 and uses perpetual inventory. The goods ship December 31, Year 1, FOB shipping point, with control transferring at shipment. Delivery occurs January 3, Year 2. Orion prepares the invoice January 2, Year 2. What should Orion recognize as of December 31, Year 1?

Question 2

Same facts, except the terms are FOB destination and control transfers on delivery. What should Orion recognize as of December 31, Year 1?

Question 3

Same facts, except shipment occurs January 2, Year 2. What should Orion recognize as of December 31, Year 1?

Question 4

Same facts, except Orion prepares the invoice December 28, Year 1. On what date should Orion recognize revenue, AR, COGS, and inventory reduction?

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Orion Co. uses an integrated ERP purchasing system. For inventory purchases, the system is configured to record accounts payable only after a three-way match is completed among an approved purchase order, a receiving report, and the vendor invoice. In Year 1, Orion approved the purchase order on June 2, recorded receipt of the goods on June 8, entered the vendor invoice on June 10, and approved payment on June 25. Assuming no exceptions, when should the ERP post the payable?
Hint

Focus on the exact system rule stated in the stem and identify the last document needed to satisfy it.

Question 3

A company is configuring its enterprise resource planning (ERP) system for sales order entry. When a sales clerk enters an order, the company wants the system to immediately check inventory availability and customer credit before the order is accepted. In deciding whether this process should use online real-time processing rather than batch processing, which factor should govern the decision?
Hint

Focus on what the business needs at the moment the sales order is entered, not on general reporting or control features.

Question 4

Lakeview Co. uses an integrated ERP system in which a confirmed shipment automatically updates billing, accounts receivable, inventory, and the general ledger from the same transaction record. A warehouse employee accidentally confirms shipment of 100 units when only 10 units were actually shipped. Assume no edit or review control catches the error before processing. What is the most likely consequence?
Hint

Focus on what an integrated ERP does when one transaction is used to update several modules automatically.

Question 5

TriCo uses an integrated ERP for purchasing, receiving, accounts payable, and the general ledger. When goods are received and accepted, the receiving module automatically debits inventory and credits a goods-received-not-invoiced (GRNI) liability clearing account. When the vendor invoice is later matched and posted, the AP module debits GRNI and credits accounts payable. At 12/31/20X5, an interface outage delayed posting of certain approved vendor invoices from the invoice-capture queue into the ERP until 1/3/20X6. All related goods had been received and accepted by 12/31/20X5, and those receipts had already posted to inventory and GRNI in the ERP. Assume there are no price disputes and no separate duplicate-prevention entry will be made. To avoid understating liabilities, the controller proposes a top-side year-end accrual for the delayed invoices and then allowing the ERP invoices to post normally when the backlog clears. What is the correct treatment?
Hint

Trace the transaction through the ERP modules in order: what entry was created at receipt, and what entry will the delayed invoice create when it finally posts?

Question 6

A company uses an integrated ERP system for purchases and inventory. The system is configured so that purchase orders do not create accounting entries, and title to inventory passes when goods are received at the company's dock. For a routine inventory purchase, which event should trigger the ERP system to initially record inventory and accounts payable?
Hint

Identify the event that changes the company's accounting position, not just the event that authorizes or settles the transaction.

Drill all 170 Enterprise and accounting information systems questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Does the shipment date or invoice date determine ERP revenue recognition?

Control transfer determines recognition. For Orion's FOB shipping point sale, the December 31 shipment triggers recognition even though the invoice is prepared January 2.

What year-end entries are needed for goods shipped FOB shipping point before invoicing?

Orion debits accounts receivable and credits revenue for $10,000. It also debits COGS and credits inventory for $6,000 in Year 1.

Does preparing an invoice before shipment accelerate revenue recognition?

No. In Orion's early-invoice version, the December 28 invoice does not transfer control. Recognition still occurs at shipment on December 31.

Watch it solved

A full CPA ISC task-based simulation on Enterprise and accounting information systems, worked step by step.

ISC Simulation: Mapping Controls Through Order-to-Cash on YouTube

Practice ISC like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Enterprise and accounting information systems

All Enterprise and accounting information systems practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.