FAR · Select transactions · 6 practice questions
ASC 842: Which Payments Enter the Lease Liability?
The initial lease liability includes unpaid fixed payments, CPI-linked payments using commencement CPI, and probable residual guarantee amounts. Sort the payment terms in Lark's equipment lease into included and excluded amounts.
Try one first
Hint
Separate variable payments based on an index or rate from variable payments based on performance. Then ask which version of the index is used at commencement.
Answer C. For a lessee under ASC 842, variable lease payments based on an index or rate are included in the initial lease liability using the index or rate at commencement. By contrast, payments based on sales are excluded from the initial measurement because they depend on future performance. Therefore, Lark initially measures the lease liability using $80,000 base rent plus the $5,000 CPI-based amount determined from the commencement-date CPI, without forecasting later CPI changes.
Why not A: This distractor overgeneralizes that 'variable payments are excluded.' Variable payments tied to an index or rate (such as CPI) are treated differently under ASC 842 and are included in the initial measurement using the commencement-date index.
Why not B: This is tempting because the stem provides expected sales, which can make candidates think those amounts should be included if reasonably estimable. However, sales-based variable lease payments are excluded from the initial lease liability and are recognized when the sales occur; only the CPI-based amount (using the commencement index) is included initially.
Why not D: This choice correctly excludes the sales-based amounts but is incorrect because initial measurement uses the index at commencement only; you do not forecast future CPI increases when determining the initial lease liability under ASC 842.
Sort it
Include unpaid lease-component amounts within the lease term that are fixed, based on commencement CPI, or probable under a residual guarantee.
Exclude sales/usage amounts, forecast CPI increases, residual exposure above the probable amount, separate services, and payments outside the lease term.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Lark's four-year equipment lease requires $50,000 fixed rent at each year-end. | Include in initial lease liabilityThese are unpaid fixed lease payments within the noncancelable lease term. |
| An additional 2% of annual sales, estimated at $4,000 per year. | Exclude from initial lease liabilityFuture sales drive the payment. A reliable estimate does not make it includable. |
| An additional annual CPI-linked payment equal to $3,000 using commencement CPI. | Include in initial lease liabilityIndex-based payments enter initial measurement using the index in effect at commencement. |
| A $3,000 annual maintenance fee accounted for separately; Lark does not elect to combine components. | Exclude from initial lease liabilityMaintenance is a separate nonlease component. Being fixed does not make it a lease payment. |
| A $6,000 probable payment at the end of Year 4 under a residual guarantee capped at $10,000. | Include in initial lease liabilityInclude the amount probable of being owed under the guarantee at commencement. |
| An additional $1,000 per year forecast from CPI increases after commencement. | Exclude from initial lease liabilityInitial measurement uses commencement CPI, not a forecast of later index changes. |
| A separate charge of $5 per machine hour, estimated at $2,000 annually. | Exclude from initial lease liabilityUsage drives this payment. Exclude it initially even though Lark can estimate machine hours. |
| The remaining $4,000 of exposure between the $10,000 residual guarantee cap and the $6,000 probable obligation. | Exclude from initial lease liabilityThe maximum exposure does not replace the probable payment amount. |
| Two optional renewal years at $50,000 annually; Lark is not reasonably certain to renew. | Exclude from initial lease liabilityThese optional years are outside the lease term because exercise is not reasonably certain. |
| Same facts, except Lark elects to combine components for this equipment class: the $3,000 annual maintenance fee. | Include in initial lease liabilityThe election treats maintenance and the lease as one lease component, so the fixed fee enters the liability. |
Key points
- Remember: A reliable estimate does not turn sales- or usage-based payments into an initial lease liability.
- The residual guarantee cap is not the measurement amount; use the amount probable of being owed.
- Include renewal payments only when exercise is reasonably certain.
- A fixed maintenance fee stays outside the liability unless Lark elects to combine lease and nonlease components.
How the exam traps you
- Excluding CPI-linked payments because they are variable. Include the amount based on commencement CPI, not forecast CPI.
- Adding estimated sales and machine-hour charges. Exclude both from initial measurement, even when Lark can estimate them.
- Using the full residual guarantee cap. Include only the amount probable of being owed.
Question 2
Hint
Separate the measurement issues: first identify what belongs in the lease liability, then determine what adjusts the right-of-use asset.
Answer D. Because Noll did not elect the practical expedient to combine lease and nonlease components, the fixed maintenance amount is a separate nonlease component and must be excluded from the lease liability. Usage-based charges that depend on future production and are not based on an index or rate are variable lease payments excluded from the initial lease liability, while the amount probable under a residual value guarantee is included. The lease liability is measured using Noll's incremental borrowing rate when the implicit rate is not readily determinable. The right-of-use asset equals the lease liability adjusted for initial direct costs (add the broker commission) and reduced by lease incentives received (subtract the cash incentive).
Why not A: This is tempting because the maintenance amount is fixed and included in the contractual payments. However, because Noll did not elect the practical expedient to combine lease and nonlease components, the maintenance services are a separate nonlease component and should be excluded from the lease liability.
Why not B: This overgeneralizes contingency rules. The residual value guarantee, when Noll concludes it is probable it will owe $25,000, is included in the lease liability. Service payments here are nonlease components and are excluded from the liability, not ignored as contingencies. The broker commission is an initial direct cost included in the ROU asset, and the lessor's cash incentive reduces the ROU asset rather than being immediately expensed.
Why not C: This distractor bundles two common errors: capitalizing variable usage-based payments and ignoring the residual value guarantee. Under ASC 842, usage-based payments not linked to an index or rate are excluded from initial lease measurement and accounted for as incurred, while amounts probable under a residual value guarantee are included. Also, initial direct costs such as a broker commission are added to the ROU asset rather than reducing it.
Question 3
Hint
At commencement, sort each item into three buckets: included in the lease liability, affects only the right-of-use asset, or excluded until later because it depends on future use or a not-reasonably-certain option.
Answer A. At commencement, include fixed lease payments and variable payments that depend on an index or rate using the commencement-date index; amounts probable of being owed under a residual value guarantee are also included in the lease liability. Usage- or performance-based variable payments (e.g., amounts tied to units produced) are excluded from the initial lease liability. Renewal payments are included only if the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise the option. The right-of-use asset is reduced by lease incentives received and increased by incremental initial direct costs such as the third-party commission.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates may want to estimate all expected outflows, but ASC 842 excludes usage- or performance-based variable payments from initial measurement while including variable payments that depend on an index using the commencement-date index. Also, a probable residual value guarantee is included at commencement, and lease incentives received reduce (not increase) the lessee's right-of-use asset.
Why not C: This distractor relies on the idea that any variability is excluded initially. However, index- or rate-based payments are included using the commencement-date index, and probable amounts under a residual value guarantee are included. Lease incentives paid by the lessor do affect the lessee's right-of-use asset.
Why not D: This answer overweights the mere existence of an option and expected future usage. Renewal payments are included only when exercise is reasonably certain, and production-based variable payments are excluded from initial measurement. By contrast, a probable residual value guarantee is included, and lease incentives reduce the lessee's right-of-use asset.
Question 4
Hint
Identify which variable payments are indexed to a rate (include at commencement) versus those that depend on future performance (exclude); treat maintenance as a nonlease component unless combined.
Answer C. ASC 842 requires including fixed payments and variable payments that depend on an index or rate, measured using the index at lease commencement. Alder therefore includes the $90,000 fixed rent plus the CPI-linked $4,000 (measured using the commencement CPI), for $94,000 per year before discounting. Sales-based payments depend on future performance and are excluded at initial measurement, and the $6,000 maintenance is a separate nonlease component (Alder did not combine components), so both are excluded.
Why not A: Tempts because it is just the fixed base rent. It fails because it omits the CPI-linked variable payment, which ASC 842 requires be included at commencement using the index in effect at that date.
Why not B: Tempts by including both the CPI-linked amount ($4,000) and the expected sales-based amount ($8,000) in addition to the $90,000 base rent (90 + 4 + 8 = 102). It fails because sales-based variable payments depend on future performance and are excluded from the initial lease liability under ASC 842, even though CPI-linked payments are included.
Why not D: Tempts by treating all contractual outflows as lease payments (90 + 4 + 8 + 6 = 108). It fails because the $6,000 maintenance is a nonlease component (and Alder did not combine components), so it is excluded, and sales-based payments are excluded as performance-based variables.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on which lease payments belong in the lessee's initial lease liability and which are recognized only as they occur.
Answer B. Under ASC 842 a lessee recognizes a lease liability and right-of-use asset at lease commencement for leases that are not short-term. The initial liability includes fixed lease payments (and certain other specified amounts) but excludes variable payments that depend on the lessee's sales because those are not based on an index or rate. Sales-based variable payments are expensed in the period the related sales occur.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates may think the liability should reflect all expected cash outflows. However, sales-based variable payments are excluded from initial measurement when they do not depend on an index or rate, so estimating and capitalizing them at commencement would be incorrect.
Why not C: This reflects an outdated off-balance-sheet view. ASC 842 requires recognition of a lease liability and right-of-use asset at commencement for leases that are not short-term; only the sales-based variable portion is excluded from initial measurement and recognized as incurred.
Why not D: The right-of-use asset is recognized at lease commencement when the lessee obtains the right to use the asset, not when the first payment is made. Both the liability and the ROU asset are recorded at commencement (for non-short-term leases).
Question 6
Hint
Separate the classification question from the measurement question. Then ask which cash flows are lease payments at commencement and which are variable or nonlease amounts.
Answer C. This meets the finance-lease criterion because the asset is so specialized that it is expected to have no alternative use to the lessor at the end of the term. Initial lease liability includes the present value of fixed lease payments (the $424,000). Variable payments based on sales are excluded from the initial liability and are recognized when incurred, and separately stated maintenance (a nonlease component) is excluded because Birch did not elect the practical expedient to combine components.
Why not A: This distractor is plausible because the 4-year term is less than the 10-year economic life, but ASC 842 allows a lease to be classified as a finance lease if any one of the criteria is met. The specialized-asset/no-alternative-use criterion is met here, so it is a finance lease even though the liability equals $424,000.
Why not B: Sales-based payments are variable payments tied to performance and are excluded from the initial measurement of the lease liability under ASC 842; they are recognized in profit or loss when incurred, so they do not increase the initial liability.
Why not D: Although the maintenance charges are fixed in amount, they are separately stated nonlease components. Birch did not elect the practical expedient to combine lease and nonlease components, so those maintenance payments are not included in the lease liability at commencement.
Common questions
Which CPI do you use to measure the initial lease liability?
Use CPI at lease commencement. Lark includes the $3,000 annual amount based on that index, not the additional $1,000 forecast from future CPI increases.
Do you include the full residual value guarantee in the lease liability?
No. Lark includes the $6,000 probable obligation, not the $10,000 maximum exposure.
Are fixed maintenance payments included in the lease liability?
Not when maintenance is accounted for separately as a nonlease component. If Lark elects to combine components for this equipment class, the fixed $3,000 annual maintenance fee enters the liability.
Watch it solved
A full CPA FAR task-based simulation on Leases, worked step by step.
Finance Lease Commencement & Year-End | CPA FAR Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice FAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Leases
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.