PracticeFARFree practice exam

FAR · Select balance sheet accounts · 7 practice questions

Patent Amortization: Successful Defense and Remaining Life

Successful patent-defense costs increase the carrying amount, which is amortized over the shorter of remaining legal life or useful life. Below: a worked calculation shows how a later defense changes the patent balance and annual amortization.

The ruleAdd successful defense costs to the patent's carrying amount. Under straight-line amortization, spread the updated amount over the shorter of remaining legal life or remaining useful life without revising prior amortization.

Try one first

On January 1, 20X5, Lark Co. purchased a patent for $180,000. On the same date, Lark paid $24,000 in legal fees to successfully defend the patent against an infringement claim. After the defense, the patent had 12 years of remaining legal life, but Lark expects to benefit from the patent for only 8 years. Lark uses straight-line amortization and assumes no residual value. What amount should Lark report for the patent on its December 31, 20X5 balance sheet?
Hint

First decide which costs belong in the patent account, then determine the correct amortization period.

Worked example

On January 1, Year 1, Pine Co. buys a patent for $420,000, ready for use immediately. Remaining legal life is 11 years; expected useful life is 7 years. On January 1, Year 3, Pine pays $50,000 to successfully defend it. Neither life estimate changes. Use straight-line amortization, no residual value, and no impairment. Find the December 31, Year 3 carrying amount.

1Choose the initial amortization periodShorter of 11 legal years and 7 useful years7 years
2Calculate original annual amortization$420,000 ÷ 7$60,000
3Calculate amortization through Year 2$60,000 × 2$120,000
4Find carrying amount before the defense$420,000 − $120,000$300,000
5Capitalize the successful defense$300,000 + $50,000$350,000
6Calculate Year 3 amortization$350,000 ÷ 5 remaining useful years, shorter than 9 remaining legal years$70,000
7Find the Year 3 ending carrying amount$350,000 − $70,000$280,000

Pine reports the patent at $280,000 on its December 31, Year 3 balance sheet.

Check: Shortcut: $420,000 × 4/7 + $50,000 × 4/5 = $280,000, because four useful years remain at year-end.

Key points

  • The successful defense protects the existing patent. It does not create a separate intangible asset.
  • Capitalizing defense costs does not restart the patent's original useful life.
  • Prior amortization stays unchanged. The updated carrying amount is allocated going forward.
  • Amortization begins when the patent is ready for use, so Years 1 and 2 each receive a full year.

How the exam traps you

  • Using the 11-year legal life because the patent remains legally protected. Use the shorter useful life: 7 years initially and 5 remaining years after the defense.
  • Expensing the $50,000 successful defense. Add it to the $300,000 carrying amount before calculating Year 3 amortization.
  • Capitalizing the defense but keeping the old $60,000 annual amortization. Recalculate: $350,000 divided by 5 remaining years gives $70,000 of Year 3 amortization.

6 more, each from a different angle

0 of 6 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Alpha Co. (calendar-year) has the following transactions related to intangible assets. All acquisitions occurred on January 1, Year 1 unless noted. For finite-lived intangibles, Alpha uses straight-line amortization and records amortization annually; no impairments are indicated. Determine the amount Alpha should report as intangible assets (noncurrent) on its balance sheet at December 31, Year 2.
Intangible AssetCostUseful Life
Patent (purchased Jan 1, Year 1)$300,00010 years
Customer list (purchased Jan 1, Year 1)$150,0005 years
Trademark (purchased Jan 1, Year 1)$200,000Indefinite
Additional Year 2 events: On Jan 1, Year 2, Alpha incurred $45,000 of legal fees to successfully defend the Patent and capitalized the fees, amortizing them over the Patent’s remaining useful life. During Year 2, Alpha incurred $60,000 of research and development costs for a new product, expensed as incurred. What amount should Alpha report as intangible assets (noncurrent) at December 31, Year 2?
Hint

First classify each item (finite‑lived vs indefinite‑lived vs R&D expense). Remember that successful legal defense costs are capitalized to the intangible and amortized over the remaining life; R&D is expensed as incurred.

Question 3

Arden Co. owns a patent that it acquired from another company. In Year 2, Arden incurs legal fees to successfully defend the patent against an infringement challenge. Assume the defense preserves the patent's remaining economic benefit and that no impairment indicators exist after the case. Under U.S. GAAP, what is the effect of these legal fees?
Hint

Ask whether the expenditure creates or preserves future economic benefits of an existing patent, and then consider whether that patent is finite-lived.

Question 4

Enterprise E has the following Year 1 transactions and estimates related to intangible assets. Using straight-line amortization and assuming no impairments, what amount of intangible-asset amortization expense should Enterprise report for Year 1? Facts: - Jan 1, Year 1: Enterprise purchased a patent for $600,000. The patent's remaining legal life is 12 years, but management estimates the patent's useful economic life is 8 years. Straight-line amortization over the useful life. - Jan 1, Year 1: Enterprise purchased a customer list for $120,000 with an estimated useful life of 10 years. Straight-line amortization. - During Year 1 Enterprise developed internal-use software. Total costs incurred = $450,000: $150,000 were preliminary project-stage costs (incurred Jan-Jun) and $300,000 were application-development-stage costs (incurred Jul-Sep). The software was completed and placed in service on Oct 1, Year 1, and has a 5-year estimated life amortized on a straight-line basis. - Jan 1, Year 1: Enterprise acquired a subsidiary and recognized goodwill of $800,000 (indefinite-lived). Calculate Year 1 intangible amortization expense.
Hint

Identify which items are capitalizable versus expensed and which intangibles have finite lives; prorate amortization for assets placed in service partway through the year.

Question 5

On July 1, Year 1, Pica Co. purchased a patent for $240,000. The patent was ready for use immediately. It has a remaining legal life of 12 years, but Pica expects to use it in operations for only 8 years. Assuming straight-line amortization and no residual value, when should Pica begin amortizing the patent, and over what period?
Hint

Focus on two separate issues: when amortization starts and which life controls for a finite-lived intangible.

Question 6

On January 2, Year 1, Lane Co. purchased a patent for $120,000. During Year 1, Lane also paid $8,000 of legal fees to successfully defend that patent in court, $12,000 of research costs related to a separate new product idea, and $6,000 of routine patent maintenance fees. Assume no amortization is recorded for this question. What amount should Lane report as the patent intangible asset at December 31, Year 1?
Hint

Separate the costs that acquire or successfully defend the patent from the costs of research and routine upkeep.

Question 7

Bram Co. purchased a patent for $240,000 at the beginning of Year 1. In Year 2, Bram incurred $30,000 of legal fees to successfully defend the patent in court. Assume the patent remains a finite-lived intangible asset and no impairment is indicated. What is the required accounting response for the Year 2 legal fees?
Hint

Focus on whether the legal cost protects an existing finite-lived intangible asset and whether the defense was successful.

Drill all 107 Intangible assets questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Do you capitalize successful patent-defense costs?

Yes. Add costs that successfully defend the patent to its carrying amount. Here, the $50,000 defense increases the balance from $300,000 to $350,000 before Year 3 amortization.

Is a patent amortized over its legal life or useful life?

Use the shorter period. Here, 7 useful years beats 11 legal years initially; after two years, 5 remaining useful years beats 9 remaining legal years.

Does a successful patent defense restart amortization?

No. Amortize the updated carrying amount over the remaining life, not the original life. Keep prior amortization unchanged.

Watch it solved

A full CPA FAR task-based simulation on Intangible assets, worked step by step.

Patent Cost, Amortization & Impairment | CPA FAR Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice FAR like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Intangible assets

All Intangible assets practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.