BAR · Business Analysis · 6 practice questions
Sensitivity Analysis vs Scenario Analysis: One Input or Many
One-way sensitivity analysis changes one input while holding others constant; scenario analysis combines assumptions for a consistent future state. Below, separate price and cost tests lead to a combined adverse scenario.
Try one first
Hint
Find the best expected value without the report, then compare it with the expected value when each demand state is known first.
Answer C. Without the report, the company chooses the higher expected value: limited launch at $96,000 versus full launch at $84,000. With certainty, it would choose full launch if demand is strong and limited launch if demand is weak, for an expected value of $120,000. The value of perfect information is the difference, or $24,000.
Why not A: This uses the expected value with certainty but forgets to subtract the best expected value already available without the report. Perfect information adds value only to the extent it improves the decision.
Why not B: This comes from comparing the perfect-information value of $120,000 to the full launch expected value of $84,000. That fails because the company would not choose full launch without the report; it would choose limited launch at $96,000.
Why not D: This treats the expected value of full launch as if it were the value of the report. The report's value is not an alternative's expected payoff; it is only the improvement over the best decision available without certainty.
Worked example
Vale Co. forecasts sales of 20,000 units at $80 each, variable cost of $50 per unit, and fixed costs of $300,000. Test a 10% price decrease and a 10% variable-cost increase separately. Then start from the price-only case and change only variable cost to build an adverse scenario.
| 1 | Original forecast20,000 × ($80 − $50) − $300,000 | $300,000 operating income |
| 2 | Price-only sensitivityPrice = $80 × 90% = $72. Income = 20,000 × ($72 − $50) − $300,000. | $140,000 operating income |
| 3 | Separate variable-cost sensitivityReset price to $80. Variable cost = $50 × 110% = $55. Income = 20,000 × ($80 − $55) − $300,000. | $200,000 operating income |
| 4 | Add one change to the price-only caseStart with 20,000 units, a $72 selling price, $50 variable cost per unit, and $300,000 fixed costs. Change only variable cost to $55. Income = 20,000 × ($72 − $55) − $300,000. This scenario includes both adverse changes relative to the original forecast. | $40,000 operating income |
The separate one-way tests produce operating income of $140,000 for the price decrease and $200,000 for the variable-cost increase. Combining both changes produces scenario operating income of $40,000.
Check: From the price-only case, subtract only the added variable cost: $140,000 − 20,000 × $5 = $40,000.
Key points
- Reset all inputs to the original forecast before starting each separate one-way test.
- Apply each percentage change to its own input, not to contribution margin or operating income.
- Adding one changed assumption to a price-only case creates a scenario with two changes relative to the original forecast.
How the exam traps you
- Keeping the reduced price when calculating the separate variable-cost sensitivity. Reset price to $80 for the cost-only test; operating income is $200,000.
- Leaving variable cost at $50 in the combined adverse scenario. Use $55 variable cost with the $72 price; scenario operating income is $40,000.
- Applying the price decrease directly to operating income. Reduce the $80 selling price by 10%, then recompute revenue and operating income.
Question 2
Hint
Convert the dollar shortfall into a required percentage miss for each row in the table.
Answer A. Use the table to convert the $180,000 shortfall into a required percentage miss for each assumption. Selling price requires a 1.5% miss ($180,000 ÷ $120,000), sales volume 2.4%, variable cost per unit 2.0%, and fixed costs 6.0%. The smallest percentage error is tied to selling price.
Why not B: This answer can result from reversing the logic and picking the smallest dollar impact per 1% change. A smaller per-1% impact actually means a larger percentage miss is needed to explain the same $180,000 shortfall. Fixed costs would require a 6.0% miss, the largest of the four.
Why not C: This answer can result from focusing only on cost assumptions because income was below forecast. But the table asks for the smallest percentage error, and variable cost per unit needs a 2.0% miss ($180,000 ÷ $90,000). That is greater than the 1.5% miss needed for selling price.
Why not D: This answer can result from noticing that sales volume affects income materially but not comparing all rows quantitatively. At $75,000 per 1% unfavorable change, sales volume would need a 2.4% miss to create a $180,000 shortfall. That is larger than the percentage miss required for selling price.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on whether outcomes are merely possible or can also be assigned supportable probabilities.
Answer C. Risk exists when possible outcomes can be identified and reasonable probabilities can be assigned to them. Comparable historical launch data provides a basis for those probability estimates. That makes the decision environment one of risk rather than uncertainty.
Why not A: This answer comes from assuming a measurable issue always involves risk. It fails because there is no comparable data to support probability estimates, so the situation remains uncertainty.
Why not B: This answer comes from treating any future business exposure as risk. It fails because management cannot even fully identify the outcomes, which is characteristic of uncertainty.
Why not D: This answer comes from thinking that listing possible outcomes is enough for risk. It fails because risk requires a reasonable basis for assigning probabilities, and this situation lacks that basis.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on the method that turns uncertain inputs into many repeated outcome trials.
Answer B. Monte Carlo simulation models uncertain inputs with probability distributions and recalculates the outcome many times. That produces a distribution of possible operating income results, including an estimated probability of a loss. This directly matches management's need for both range and likelihood.
Why not A: This reflects sensitivity analysis. It shows how income responds to isolated input changes, but it does not combine uncertainty across inputs or estimate the probability of a loss.
Why not C: This treats the task as estimating a relationship from historical data. Regression alone does not simulate thousands of possible income outcomes or quantify loss probability for the proposed product.
Why not D: This is scenario analysis. It compares a few discrete cases, but it does not generate a full distribution of outcomes from many random draws.
Question 5
Hint
Recalculate unit contribution margin after the variable cost change, then divide fixed costs by that new margin.
Answer D. A 10% increase raises variable cost from $30 to $33. The new contribution margin is $17 per unit, so break-even volume is $120,000 divided by $17, or 7,058.82 units. Because partial units cannot fully cover fixed costs, the company must sell 7,059 units.
Why not A: This treats break-even units as if they should rise by the same 10% as variable cost. Break-even units depend on the new contribution margin, not on applying the percentage directly to the old unit volume.
Why not B: This keeps the original contribution margin of $20 and ignores the variable cost increase. Sensitivity analysis requires recomputing break-even using the changed variable cost.
Why not C: This results from increasing variable cost by $5 instead of 10% of $30. The 10% applies to the original variable cost, so the increase is $3, not $5.
Question 6
Hint
Use a probability-weighted average, not a simple average or a single scenario outcome.
Answer A. Expected value is the probability-weighted average of all scenario outcomes. Compute $50,000 × 10% + $100,000 × 20% + $150,000 × 30% + $200,000 × 40% = $150,000. The result reflects both the size of each profit and its likelihood.
Why not B: This treats the most favorable or most prominent outcome as the answer. Expected value is not one scenario's profit; it is the weighted average across all scenarios.
Why not C: This can result from missing the 10% scenario and weighting only the other three outcomes. Expected value must include every scenario and its assigned probability.
Why not D: This comes from taking a simple average of the four profit amounts. That ignores the stated probabilities, so it does not measure expected value.
Common questions
What is the difference between sensitivity analysis and scenario analysis?
One-way sensitivity changes one assumption while keeping the others at forecast. The adverse scenario combines the lower selling price and higher variable cost.
Why reset assumptions before each one-way sensitivity test?
Resetting isolates the effect of the input being tested. Keeping the $72 price during the cost-only test would combine both changes instead.
How do you calculate scenario income from the price-only case?
Start with $140,000 of price-only operating income. The additional $5 variable cost across 20,000 units reduces income by $100,000, leaving $40,000.
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Data analytics, regression analysis, and quantitative methods
- Calculate Predicted Cost Using Simple Linear Regression
- Adjusted R-Squared When Adding Regression Predictors
- Correlation vs. Causation: Confounding and Selection Bias
- Time-Series Forecasting: Match the Method to the Pattern
All Data analytics, regression analysis, and quantitative methods practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.