BAR · State and Local Governments · 6 practice questions
GASB Modified Approach: Infrastructure Eligibility Tests
The modified approach permits no depreciation only when both asset-management and documented condition requirements are met. Follow a road network through the eligibility checks and see why a missing preservation estimate requires depreciation.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on the specific GASB criteria that permit not depreciating infrastructure, an asset-management system, condition assessments (every three years), estimates of preservation needs, and demonstration that condition is maintained.
Answer B. GASB permits reporting qualifying infrastructure under the modified approach (without depreciation) only if the government maintains an asset-management system with an up-to-date inventory, performs condition assessments at least every three years, estimates the annual amount needed to preserve the assets at a specified condition level, and demonstrates the assets are being preserved at or above that level. When those criteria are met, depreciation is not recorded and specific condition and expenditure disclosures are required.
Why not A: This is tempting because higher maintenance spending and an inventory suggest preservation efforts, but GASB requires a formal asset-management system, periodic condition assessments, and demonstration that a predetermined condition level is maintained, mere increased spending and a basic inventory are insufficient.
Why not C: Governmental funds do not capitalize infrastructure (they use the current financial resources focus); capitalization and depreciation are addressed in the government-wide statements, and acquisition date alone does not allow avoiding depreciation, modified approach criteria must be met.
Why not D: This distractor plays on the general rule that capital assets are depreciated, but it is incorrect: the modified approach specifically allows qualifying infrastructure assets to be reported without depreciation when the required asset-management, assessment, and preservation criteria are satisfied.
Step by step
- Identify the network and reporting year
Riverbend previously elected the modified approach for its road network in the government-wide statements. In Year 5, it has a current inventory, a complete Year 4 condition assessment, and documentation that the roads remain at or above its disclosed target.
- Check the asset-management gate
The system must include a current inventory and an estimate of the annual amount needed to preserve the established condition. Riverbend records actual maintenance spending but has not prepared the required annual estimate.
- Check the assessment interval
Complete, documented condition assessments must occur at least every three years. Riverbend's Year 4 assessment is timely for Year 5.
- Check the documented condition
The government must establish and disclose a condition level and document preservation at or above that level. Riverbend meets this condition test.
- Require both gates to pass
Riverbend passes the condition-assessment and preservation tests but fails the asset-management requirement because its annual preservation estimate is missing. Favorable condition results and actual maintenance spending do not replace that estimate.
- Apply the failed-eligibility result
Riverbend cannot use the modified approach for its roads in Year 5. Keep the network capitalized and begin depreciation prospectively in the Year 5 government-wide statements.
Key points
- Remember: Good road condition does not cure a missing annual preservation-cost estimate.
- Actual maintenance spending is not the required estimate of annual preservation needs.
- Losing eligibility changes depreciation prospectively; it does not remove the road network from capital assets.
How the exam traps you
- Continue the modified approach because the latest condition assessment passed. Check the asset-management requirements too. A missing annual preservation estimate defeats eligibility.
- Treat actual maintenance expenditures as the annual preservation estimate. Require an estimate of the annual amount needed to preserve the established condition.
- Rely on the city's prior election to avoid current-year depreciation. Recheck eligibility for the current year and begin depreciation when requirements fail.
Question 2
Hint
Do not stop at whether the county has an asset management system or whether the roads were once above the target condition. Ask what ongoing requirement must still be met to keep using the modified approach.
Answer C. Under GASB, the modified approach is available only if a government maintains a qualifying asset management system and performs complete condition assessments at least every three years. Because the county's last complete assessment was at the end of 20X1 and no complete reassessment was done through 20X5 (more than three years), it is no longer eligible to use the modified approach in 20X5. Preservation costs that merely maintain existing service levels are expensed, while capacity-increasing additions are capitalized and depreciated; therefore expense $4.8 million, capitalize $1.6 million, and record depreciation on the network.
Why not A: This choice is tempting because the last measured condition (77) exceeded the minimum acceptable level (75). However, the modified approach requires more than a favorable prior score, the government must perform complete condition assessments at least every three years. An outdated assessment breaks eligibility even if the prior score was above the benchmark.
Why not B: This distractor plays on the general rule that infrastructure spending is capitalized, but preservation expenditures that only maintain existing service levels are typically expensed. Moreover, if the modified approach is not used, depreciation rules apply to the infrastructure network generally, not just to new additions.
Why not D: This answer seems like a compromise, but it ignores the central eligibility issue. If the government fails to meet the required reassessment frequency, it cannot continue the no-depreciation modified approach for existing infrastructure; the modified approach is unavailable until the requirements are again satisfied.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on what the modified approach changes for eligible infrastructure assets: does it eliminate capitalization, depreciation, or both?
Answer A. Eligible infrastructure assets reported under the modified approach are capitalized in the government-wide statements but are not depreciated. Instead, the government must meet the required inventory, assessment, and preservation-condition criteria. Ongoing preservation costs are expensed, while additions and improvements that increase capacity or efficiency are capitalized.
Why not B: This is tempting because depreciation is the default treatment for most capital assets. It is wrong because the modified approach is a specific exception for eligible infrastructure assets, so depreciation is not recorded. It is also too broad in saying all later costs are expensed, since additions and improvements are capitalized.
Why not C: This distractor plays on the fact that preservation costs are expensed and that governmental funds focus heavily on current expenditures. However, under GASB, infrastructure assets are still capitalized in the government-wide statements even when the modified approach is used. The modified approach changes depreciation, not the need to recognize the capital asset.
Why not D: This may tempt a candidate who associates some governmental measurements with current value concepts. It is wrong because general capital assets are not remeasured to fair value each year for this purpose. The modified approach affects depreciation of qualifying infrastructure, not the basic historical-cost-based measurement model.
Question 4
Hint
Remember GASB’s two principal modified-approach criteria (asset-management system plus demonstration that assets are being preserved at an established condition level) and the difference between government-wide (capitalize + depreciate unless modified approach applies) and governmental fund (record capital outlays as expenditures) reporting.
Answer A. The modified approach requires both an appropriate asset-management system and evidence that the assets are being preserved at the government's established condition level. Westport failed to meet its condition target (71% vs. 80%), so it cannot use the modified approach for Year 3. Under government-wide (full-accrual) reporting the infrastructure is capitalized and, when the modified approach does not apply, is depreciated (including the new road); governmental funds report capital outlays as expenditures.
Why not B: Tempting because Westport has an asset-management system and performed maintenance (two administrative prerequisites), but the modified approach also requires demonstrating assets are being preserved at the established condition level, which Westport failed to do, so depreciation is required in the government-wide statements.
Why not C: Tempting because it suggests a partial application, but the stem says the streets are treated as a single network (the modified approach must be elected for an eligible network or defined subsystem up front), so you cannot cherry-pick lane miles within a designated network. Also, governmental funds do not capitalize capital assets; they record capital outlays as expenditures.
Why not D: Tempting because candidates sometimes equate having an asset-management system and doing maintenance with automatic eligibility, but the condition-level demonstration is a separate required criterion that was not met. In addition, the general fund cannot capitalize the $1,600,000, it reports capital outlays as expenditures; capitalization occurs in the government-wide statements.
Question 5
Hint
Check each asset class separately against the modified‑approach criteria (asset management system, condition assessments at least every three years, and estimates/actual preservation spending); then remember what the modified approach means for depreciation and capital additions for an eligible class.
Answer C. The paved road class satisfies the modified-approach criteria (asset-management system, condition assessments within the required three-year interval, and spending at estimated levels), so that class may remain under the modified approach and not be depreciated; capital additions for an eligible class are capitalized but are not depreciated while the class remains eligible. The sidewalk class failed the condition-assessment requirement (last assessment was more than three years ago) and did not update preservation estimates, so it does not meet the modified-approach criteria; reconstructive expenditures should be capitalized and the sidewalk class depreciated prospectively.
Why not A: Tempting because it overgeneralizes the rules, but the modified approach is applied by class, a problem with one class does not automatically disqualify other classes that still meet the criteria; reconstruction spending likewise does not invalidate a compliant class, and depreciation resumes prospectively rather than by restatement.
Why not B: Tempting because governments often continue prior policies, but eligibility is evaluated for each asset class each reporting period; sidewalks failed the condition-assessment/estimates requirements, so they no longer qualify for the modified approach.
Why not D: Tempting if one misremembers assessment frequency or relies on prior presentation, but GASB requires condition assessments at least every three years (not annually), so the paved roads, which had assessments within three years, remain eligible while sidewalks, with an assessment older than three years, do not.
Question 6
Hint
First decide whether the road network still qualifies for the modified approach this year. Then separately classify each outlay as preservation versus an addition or improvement.
Answer D. Under GASB, the modified approach is an exception to depreciation for eligible infrastructure assets only if the government, among other things, performs and documents condition assessments at least every 3 years. Because the last complete assessment was 3 years and 8 months before year-end, the exception is not available for the current year. Routine preservation costs remain expenses, while additions and capacity-increasing improvements are capitalized, and the infrastructure assets are subject to depreciation rather than the modified approach.
Why not A: This is tempting because it correctly separates preservation costs from additions and improvements, which is how many candidates remember the modified approach. But it misses the exception trigger: having an asset management system and a disclosed condition level is not enough by itself. The government must also perform condition assessments at least every 3 years, and that requirement was not met.
Why not B: This distractor appeals to a timing-repair mindset, as if the late assessment can be cured shortly after year-end without affecting current-year reporting. That is wrong because the eligibility requirement is based on whether the assessments were performed within the required interval for the year being reported, not on management's future intent. It is also wrong to expense the new turn lane and stronger bridge deck because those are capital additions or improvements, not routine preservation.
Why not C: This choice correctly notices that the city cannot keep using the modified approach, so it will attract candidates who focus only on the assessment failure. But routine crack sealing and pothole patching are maintenance/preservation costs, not capital improvements, so they should be expensed. It is also incomplete to suggest depreciating only the newly capitalized amounts when the network no longer qualifies for the modified approach.
Common questions
What are the GASB modified approach eligibility requirements?
The government needs a current inventory, annual preservation-cost estimates, and complete condition assessments at least every three years. It must also document preservation at or above its established and disclosed condition level.
Can good road condition replace a preservation-cost estimate?
No. Riverbend's roads meet the condition target, but its missing annual preservation estimate means the network does not qualify.
What happens when a government no longer qualifies for the modified approach?
The infrastructure remains capitalized in the government-wide statements. The government begins or resumes depreciation prospectively in the year the requirements are not met.
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.