AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 10 practice questions
Inventory at a Public Warehouse: Confirmation and Follow-Up
A public warehouse's quantity confirmation supports existence, but it does not by itself establish condition, cutoff, or ownership. Compare the same inventory balance as the confirmation response or custodian changes.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on who physically holds the inventory at year-end and which evidence source is outside management.
Answer A. When inventory is material and held by an independent third party, the auditor ordinarily obtains a direct confirmation from that third party about the quantities held at the reporting date. Because the warehouse is independent and there is no reliability concern stated, a confirmation is the most direct and appropriate evidence of existence. This is a standard special-consideration procedure for inventory held by others.
Why not B: Agreement between management's listing and the general ledger provides some internal corroboration but is still management-prepared evidence. For material inventory held by an outside custodian, external confirmation from the custodian is stronger and ordinarily required to verify existence.
Why not C: Vouching to invoices and cost records helps verify acquisition and valuation, but those records do not directly confirm that the inventory physically existed at the third-party warehouse on the year-end date.
Why not D: Subsequent sales offer indirect evidence and can be useful as supplemental procedures, but they are less direct and less complete than obtaining a third-party confirmation of quantities at the reporting date.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Lark Co. has material finished goods held at a public warehouse at December 31, Year 1. The warehouse is independent. Its direct confirmation reports quantities only and agrees with Lark's records. No other procedures address condition, cutoff, or ownership.
Answer: Obtain condition evidence, test year-end cutoff, and inspect ownership documents before concluding on this inventory.
The direct response supports quantities held. It does not establish physical condition, proper recording of year-end movements, or Lark's ownership.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1The warehouse does not respond to the confirmation request before the planned report date.
Answer: Perform alternative procedures for existence and condition, and complete cutoff and ownership testing.
A nonresponse provides no confirmation evidence. Inspect warehouse records and, if practicable, visit or arrange an independent count; do not substitute management's representation.
Change 2The warehouse is owned by Lark's majority shareholder rather than independent.
Answer: Corroborate the related-party confirmation with additional existence procedures, plus the missing condition, cutoff, and ownership work.
Common ownership reduces the response's reliability. Inspect goods or obtain other corroborating evidence rather than relying on confirmed quantities alone.
Change 3The confirmed quantities have unexplained differences from Lark's records instead of agreeing.
Answer: Investigate the quantity differences and expand substantive procedures, while completing condition, cutoff, and ownership testing.
The mismatch raises reliability concerns. Inspect receipts and shipping records, reconcile the differences, and determine whether more evidence or an adjustment is needed.
Key points
- Remember: Check both what the warehouse confirms and whether its response is reliable.
- Inspect goods or independent inspection reports for condition; test year-end receipts and shipments for cutoff.
- Inspect ownership documents for rights; agreement with client records does not fill missing evidence.
How the exam traps you
- Accepting confirmed quantities as proof of condition, cutoff, and ownership. Get condition evidence, test year-end receipts and shipments, and inspect ownership documents.
- Replacing a missing response with management's representation. Inspect warehouse records and visit or arrange an independent count when practicable.
- Trusting a related-party warehouse or ignoring unexplained quantity differences. Corroborate the response and investigate differences before relying on it.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer B. Correct. These procedures address the assertions not covered by the quantity confirmation.
Why not A: Incorrect. Confirmed quantities do not establish condition, cutoff, or ownership.
Why not C: Incorrect. Management's representation cannot replace sufficient appropriate evidence.
Why not D: Incorrect. Personal attendance is not always required; appropriate evidence may come from other procedures.
Question 2
Answer D. Correct. Warehouse records, inspection, or independent counts can address the missing response; other assertions still need testing.
Why not A: Incorrect. The warehouse's independence does not turn client records into sufficient evidence.
Why not B: Incorrect. Management's representation does not replace evidence about physical existence and condition.
Why not C: Incorrect. Alternative procedures may provide sufficient evidence, so an immediate modification is premature.
Question 3
Answer A. Correct. The related-party relationship weakens reliability, so the quantity response needs corroboration.
Why not B: Incorrect. Legal separation does not remove the related-party relationship.
Why not C: Incorrect. Agreement with client records does not resolve the custodian's lack of independence.
Why not D: Incorrect. A related-party response is not automatically unusable; additional procedures may supply sufficient evidence.
Question 4
Answer C. Correct. Reconciliation and supporting receipts and shipping documents help resolve differences and identify needed adjustments.
Why not A: Incorrect. External evidence is not automatically sufficient when unexplained discrepancies undermine reliability.
Why not B: Incorrect. An adjustment requires support; the difference could arise from either set of records.
Why not D: Incorrect. Condition testing does not resolve conflicting quantity records.
Question 2
Hint
Separate the problem into two issues: the count was not at year-end, and a material portion of inventory was held by someone outside the client.
Answer D. Because the auditor observed the count on Dec 20 and significant transactions occurred afterward, the auditor needs to perform roll-forward procedures to reconcile quantities and ensure the Dec 31 balance is supported. In addition, when a material portion of inventory is held by an unrelated third-party custodian, obtaining confirmation from that custodian is appropriate evidence of existence at period-end. Option D addresses both the interim-count roll-forward and the need for third-party confirmation.
Why not A: This is tempting because observation provides strong evidence, but the count was before year-end and significant activity occurred afterward, so relying solely on the Dec 20 observation is insufficient to support the Dec 31 balance. It also fails to obtain direct evidence about inventory held by the third-party warehouse.
Why not B: Subsequent sales and receipts can provide corroborative evidence but do not substitute for properly rolling an interim count forward to year-end when activity is significant, nor do they replace obtaining direct confirmation from an unrelated custodian holding material inventory.
Why not C: Standards permit observation at an interim date if the auditor performs appropriate roll-forward procedures over intervening transactions. Requiring a full Dec 31 count is an unnecessary and burdensome alternative when roll-forward work can provide equivalent evidence, and it still would need to address third-party-held inventory.
Question 3
Hint
Treat client‑held inventory and inventory held by an independent custodian separately; consider what evidence substitutes for attendance at the year‑end count.
Answer C. When the auditor did not observe a material year‑end inventory count, observing a subsequent count and testing intervening transactions back to the balance sheet date provides evidence about existence at year‑end for inventory held by the entity. Inventory held by an independent public warehouse ordinarily requires direct confirmation from the custodian; if confirmation is unavailable or unreliable the auditor should perform appropriate alternative procedures rather than rely solely on client records.
Why not A: Direct observation is persuasive and therefore tempting. But for inventory held by an independent custodian, the auditor ordinarily seeks independent confirmation from the custodian, and any later observation must be related back to year‑end by testing intervening transactions, so observation alone without confirmation or alternative procedures is insufficient.
Why not B: This is tempting because preliminary tests support the perpetual records and confirming third‑party holdings is appropriate. However, for material inventory held by the entity the auditor should not stop at records alone when a subsequent physical observation is available; observing the later count and reconciling intervening transactions gives stronger evidence about existence at year‑end.
Why not D: This may appear attractive because confirmations seem to corroborate quantities. However, confirmations from the client's warehouse personnel are not independent evidence, and they are not an appropriate substitute for observing the subsequent count and testing intervening transactions or for obtaining independent confirmation from a third‑party custodian.
Question 4
Hint
Ask which assertions the warehouse confirmation addresses and whether the 72-hour removal window and record discrepancies increase the need for inspection, cutoff testing, or other substantive procedures.
Answer B. Under GAAS the auditor must obtain sufficient appropriate evidence for inventory held by a third party. A direct confirmation is persuasive about quantities but does not address condition or cutoff, and the 72-hour removal provision plus unresolved perpetual-record discrepancies increase the risk that quantities alone are insufficient. The auditor's best next step is to perform additional procedures (cutoff testing, inspect condition, test controls, and observe or arrange counts if practicable) and consider a reporting modification only if those procedures still fail to produce sufficient appropriate evidence.
Why not A: This is tempting because third-party confirmations are strong evidence about quantities, but it is incorrect here: the confirmation omits condition and cutoff, and the 72-hour removal window and record discrepancies create additional risk that requires further substantive procedures.
Why not C: This statement is factually correct as a later step, but it is not the auditor's best next step. The auditor must first attempt appropriate additional procedures to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence; a modification is appropriate only if those procedures fail.
Why not D: Management representations and reconciliations provide supporting evidence but cannot substitute for independent inspection, observation, or other substantive procedures when condition, existence, or cutoff are in question.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on the type of audit evidence ordinarily required when a material portion of an asset is held outside the client's physical control.
Answer A. When a material portion of inventory is held by an independent third party, auditors ordinarily obtain evidence directly from that third party (commonly via confirmation) about quantities and condition. Client reconciliations and third‑party statements routed through management are relevant but do not replace auditor‑obtained third‑party evidence. If confirmations are insufficient or raise concerns, the auditor performs additional procedures such as inspection or inquiry of the third party.
Why not B: Tempting because independent records and reliable reconciliations reduce risk; however, statements provided through management are not equivalent to evidence obtained directly from the outside holder. For material third‑party‑held inventory, auditor‑obtained third‑party evidence (e.g., confirmation) is ordinarily required.
Why not C: Tempting because observation and testing of perpetual records verify many inventory items, but those procedures do not directly verify existence or condition of goods physically held by an independent warehouse. The material portion held by a third party requires separate auditor consideration and direct third‑party evidence.
Why not D: Tempting because physical inspection provides persuasive evidence, but standards do not mandate personal inspection in every case; confirmation from the third party is ordinarily an appropriate primary procedure and inspection is an alternative if confirmation is insufficient or impractical.
Question 6
Hint
Separate client-held inventory from third-party-held inventory; ask whether an alternative-date observation plus intervening-period testing is practicable for the client-held items and what alternative procedures could provide evidence about condition for third-party-held items.
Answer A. When attendance at the scheduled year-end count is precluded for unforeseen reasons, an alternative-date observation is appropriate when practicable; the auditor should test transactions and records between year-end and the alternative date to address existence and cutoff. A third party's quantity confirmation that omits condition does not by itself provide evidence about condition, so the auditor must perform or obtain alternative procedures (for example, inspection, photographs, client-facilitated access to view inventory, or recent independent inspection reports) to obtain evidence about condition. Prior effective perpetual-inventory controls may support the audit approach but do not replace alternative-date observation and intervening-period testing when practicable.
Why not B: This is tempting because the closure was unforeseen and perpetual records were effective, but if an alternative-date observation is practicable the auditor should perform it and test the intervening period rather than rely only on records; management representations do not substitute for evidence about third-party-held inventory condition.
Why not C: Quantity confirmations address existence but do not provide evidence about condition when the custodian will not comment; condition must be addressed separately with appropriate procedures rather than assumed to be covered by valuation testing alone.
Why not D: A modified opinion may be necessary if alternative procedures cannot provide sufficient appropriate evidence, but an unforeseen inability to attend does not automatically create an unresolvable scope limitation when alternative-date observation and other procedures can be performed.
Common questions
Does a public warehouse confirmation prove inventory condition?
Not if it confirms quantities only. Obtain condition evidence through inspection, independent inspection reports, or other appropriate procedures.
What if a public warehouse does not return an inventory confirmation?
Perform alternative procedures that address existence and condition. Inspect warehouse records and, when practicable, visit the warehouse or arrange for another auditor to observe or test-count the goods.
Can an auditor rely on a related-party warehouse confirmation?
The relationship reduces the confirmation's reliability, so confirmation alone may be insufficient. Corroborate it through inspection or other appropriate evidence.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Specific Matters that Require Special Consideration, worked step by step.
Estimates, Related Parties & Going Concern | CPA AUD TBS on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Specific Matters that Require Special Consideration
- Must an Auditor Attend the Physical Inventory Count?
- AU-C 501 Attorney Letters: Qualified Opinion or Disclaimer?
All Specific Matters that Require Special Consideration practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.