PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 10 practice questions

Inventory at a Public Warehouse: Confirmation and Follow-Up

A public warehouse's quantity confirmation supports existence, but it does not by itself establish condition, cutoff, or ownership. Compare the same inventory balance as the confirmation response or custodian changes.

The ruleFor material inventory at a public warehouse, ordinarily confirm quantities and, when practicable, condition directly with the custodian. Use additional or alternative procedures when a response is incomplete, missing, or unreliable.

Try one first

Delta Co.'s inventory is material to the financial statements. At Year 1 end, all finished goods are stored at an independent public warehouse, and the auditor has no reason to doubt the warehouse's competence or objectivity. Under these facts, what is the correct treatment for obtaining audit evidence about the existence of the stored inventory?
Hint

Focus on who physically holds the inventory at year-end and which evidence source is outside management.

Same scenario, one fact changes

Base case

Lark Co. has material finished goods held at a public warehouse at December 31, Year 1. The warehouse is independent. Its direct confirmation reports quantities only and agrees with Lark's records. No other procedures address condition, cutoff, or ownership.

Answer: Obtain condition evidence, test year-end cutoff, and inspect ownership documents before concluding on this inventory.

The direct response supports quantities held. It does not establish physical condition, proper recording of year-end movements, or Lark's ownership.

Before you open each one, predict the answer.

Change 1The warehouse does not respond to the confirmation request before the planned report date.

Answer: Perform alternative procedures for existence and condition, and complete cutoff and ownership testing.

A nonresponse provides no confirmation evidence. Inspect warehouse records and, if practicable, visit or arrange an independent count; do not substitute management's representation.

Change 2The warehouse is owned by Lark's majority shareholder rather than independent.

Answer: Corroborate the related-party confirmation with additional existence procedures, plus the missing condition, cutoff, and ownership work.

Common ownership reduces the response's reliability. Inspect goods or obtain other corroborating evidence rather than relying on confirmed quantities alone.

Change 3The confirmed quantities have unexplained differences from Lark's records instead of agreeing.

Answer: Investigate the quantity differences and expand substantive procedures, while completing condition, cutoff, and ownership testing.

The mismatch raises reliability concerns. Inspect receipts and shipping records, reconcile the differences, and determine whether more evidence or an adjustment is needed.

Key points

  • Remember: Check both what the warehouse confirms and whether its response is reliable.
  • Inspect goods or independent inspection reports for condition; test year-end receipts and shipments for cutoff.
  • Inspect ownership documents for rights; agreement with client records does not fill missing evidence.

How the exam traps you

  • Accepting confirmed quantities as proof of condition, cutoff, and ownership. Get condition evidence, test year-end receipts and shipments, and inspect ownership documents.
  • Replacing a missing response with management's representation. Inspect warehouse records and visit or arrange an independent count when practicable.
  • Trusting a related-party warehouse or ignoring unexplained quantity differences. Corroborate the response and investigate differences before relying on it.

Now the same facts as questions

Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.

Question 1

Lark Co. has material finished goods held at a public warehouse at December 31, Year 1. The warehouse is independent. Its direct confirmation reports quantities only and agrees with Lark's records. No other procedures address condition, cutoff, or ownership. What should the auditor do next?

Question 2

Same facts, except the warehouse does not respond before the planned report date. What should the auditor do next?

Question 3

Same facts, except the warehouse is owned by Lark's majority shareholder. What should the auditor do next?

Question 4

Same facts, except the confirmed quantities have unexplained differences from Lark's records. What should the auditor do next?

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Falcon Co.'s Dec 31, 20X5 inventory is material. Falcon performed its annual physical count on Dec 20 because production shuts down that day. The auditor attended the Dec 20 count at Falcon's main warehouse and test-counted items there. Falcon maintains perpetual inventory records, and there were significant purchases and sales from Dec 21 through Dec 31. At Dec 31, about 30% of inventory by value was held by an unrelated public warehouse. Assume the public warehouse is considered a reliable custodian and there is no reason to doubt the perpetual records beyond normal audit risk. Which treatment is most appropriate for the auditor to obtain evidence about the Dec 31 inventory balance?
Hint

Separate the problem into two issues: the count was not at year-end, and a material portion of inventory was held by someone outside the client.

Question 3

Gray Co. engaged Miller, CPA, in February Year 2 to audit Gray's December 31, Year 1 financial statements. The year‑end physical inventory count was performed on December 31, Year 1 before Miller was engaged, so Miller did not observe the count. Inventory is material. Approximately 80% of the inventory is stored in Gray's warehouse and 20% is held by an independent public warehouse. Gray maintains perpetual inventory records for both locations, and Miller's preliminary testing indicates the records and post-year‑end transaction documentation are reliable. Miller can observe a physical inventory count in March Year 2. Which audit approach is most appropriate to obtain evidence about inventory existence at December 31, Year 1?
Hint

Treat client‑held inventory and inventory held by an independent custodian separately; consider what evidence substitutes for attendance at the year‑end count.

Question 4

Greenstone Co. stores a material portion of its inventory at an independent public warehouse. At year-end, inventory held there represents 38% of total inventory by value. The auditor receives a direct confirmation from the warehouse stating the quantities on hand at year-end, but the confirmation does not address condition. The storage agreement allows Greenstone to remove goods for up to 72 hours before the warehouse updates its records, and Greenstone had several unresolved perpetual-record discrepancies during Year 2. Assume no other procedures have yet been performed over this warehouse inventory. Under U.S. GAAS, what is the auditor's best next step?
Hint

Ask which assertions the warehouse confirmation addresses and whether the 72-hour removal window and record discrepancies increase the need for inspection, cutoff testing, or other substantive procedures.

Question 5

As of December 31, 20X5, Lark Co.'s inventory is material to the financial statements. Approximately 30% of ending inventory, owned by Lark, is stored at an independent public warehouse (not on consignment). No title dispute has been identified. Lark reconciles the warehouse's monthly statements with its perpetual records, and prior reconciliations were accurate. The auditor plans to observe counts at Lark's own locations but does not plan to contact or visit the warehouse. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Focus on the type of audit evidence ordinarily required when a material portion of an asset is held outside the client's physical control.

Question 6

During the 20X5 audit of Trent Appliances, inventory is material. Seventy-five percent of inventory is stored in Trent's main warehouse and was scheduled to be counted on 12/31/X5; the auditor planned to attend but a city-ordered emergency closure prevented access that day. The warehouse reopened on 1/4/X6, and no receipts or shipments occurred from 12/31/X5 through 1/4/X6. The auditor had previously concluded that controls over perpetual inventory records were effective. The remaining 25% of inventory is held in a public warehouse that confirmed quantities held for Trent at 12/31/X5 but stated it does not comment on inventory condition. Which auditor response is most appropriate to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence about inventory existence and condition at 12/31/X5?
Hint

Separate client-held inventory from third-party-held inventory; ask whether an alternative-date observation plus intervening-period testing is practicable for the client-held items and what alternative procedures could provide evidence about condition for third-party-held items.

Drill all 126 Specific Matters that Require Special Consideration questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Does a public warehouse confirmation prove inventory condition?

Not if it confirms quantities only. Obtain condition evidence through inspection, independent inspection reports, or other appropriate procedures.

What if a public warehouse does not return an inventory confirmation?

Perform alternative procedures that address existence and condition. Inspect warehouse records and, when practicable, visit the warehouse or arrange for another auditor to observe or test-count the goods.

Can an auditor rely on a related-party warehouse confirmation?

The relationship reduces the confirmation's reliability, so confirmation alone may be insufficient. Corroborate it through inspection or other appropriate evidence.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Specific Matters that Require Special Consideration, worked step by step.

Estimates, Related Parties & Going Concern | CPA AUD TBS on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Specific Matters that Require Special Consideration

All Specific Matters that Require Special Consideration practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.