AUD · Ethics and Professional Responsibilities and General Principles · 9 practice questions
AU-C 230: Audit File Changes After the Completion Date
After the documentation completion date, auditors may add explanations but may not delete or discard existing documentation during retention. Follow an omitted revenue cutoff memo from discovery to a properly documented late addition.
Try one first
Hint
Work separately through two questions: Has the documentation completion date passed, and are additions treated the same as deletions after that date?
Answer D. Under AICPA GAAS (AU-C 230 guidance), the documentation completion date is ordinarily no later than 60 days after the report release date. March 15 to May 20 is after that completion date. After the documentation completion date, auditors may add or clarify documentation if they document the reason, date, and who prepared and reviewed the addition, but they may not delete or discard original audit documentation before the end of the retention period.
Why not A: Tempting because the retention period prevents destruction, but incorrect: deletions of original documentation are not permitted after the documentation completion date even if the retention period has not expired; additions are allowed only when properly documented.
Why not B: This overstates the rule: the file is not completely frozen after the documentation completion date, additions or clarifying modifications are permitted when the change is documented; the prohibition is specifically on deleting or discarding existing documentation before retention ends.
Why not C: Appealing if one thinks only administrative cleanup is allowed after completion, but incorrect: adding clarifying documentation after the completion date can be appropriate if the addition is documented (reason, date, preparer, reviewer); removing original workpapers is not allowed.
Step by step
- Confirm the file is complete
For a nonissuer audit under AU-C 230, final file assembly ended April 20. On July 10, an internal inspection finds an omitted revenue cutoff memo; the retention period has not expired.
- Confirm the work already occurred
The cutoff testing, resolution, and final memo were completed before report release. No new procedures are needed, and the report remains unchanged.
- Retain the earlier draft
An earlier draft memo describing the cutoff issue as unresolved remains in the completed file. Do not delete it during the retention period, even if the partner approves.
- Add without replacing
Add the omitted final memo as a clearly identified post-completion addition. Keep the earlier draft intact rather than overwriting it or substituting the final memo.
- Explain the specific reason
Record that the final memo was inadvertently omitted during assembly and is being added to document the cutoff resolution. The unchanged conclusion does not eliminate this requirement.
- Record dates and responsible people
Record July 10 as the actual addition date, identify who made and reviewed the addition, and record when the review occurred. Do not make the addition appear to have been in the file on April 20.
Key points
- Remember: Add the missing explanation, not a replacement that erases the original.
- Keeping the unresolved draft preserves history; it does not reverse the final cutoff conclusion.
- The memo's original preparation date does not establish when it entered the assembled file.
How the exam traps you
- Discarding the draft because the final memo supersedes it. Keep the draft and add the final memo without replacing existing documentation.
- Skipping the reason because the audit conclusion is unchanged. Document the specific reason for the addition, plus when and by whom it was made and reviewed.
- Making the late addition appear to have been present at file completion. Record the actual addition date; do not conceal when the memo entered the file.
Question 2
Hint
Distinguish the report release date, the AU-C 230 documentation completion date (60 days after release), and the retention period; then decide whether each proposed action is an addition that requires documentation or a deletion that is prohibited.
Answer B. AU-C 230 (AICPA nonissuer guidance) calls for assembling the final engagement documentation no later than 60 days after report release (the documentation completion date). Additions to the file after that date are permitted only if the file documents the reason for the addition and when and by whom it was made and reviewed; however, documentation should not be deleted or discarded after the completion date before the end of the retention period. Because 75 days have passed here, the memo may be added only with the required documentation, and the preliminary checklist should not be removed.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates recall that file assembly includes administrative clean-up, but after the 60-day documentation completion date has passed, additions must be documented as to reason, timing, and responsible individuals, and deletions are not permitted before the retention period ends.
Why not C: This distractor plays on the misconception that the file is frozen at report release; AU-C 230 allows later additions if the auditor documents why the addition was made and when and by whom it was made and reviewed, the prohibition is on deleting documentation, not on all later additions.
Why not D: This is tempting because candidates may conflate timely documentation with a ban on later additions and think redundancy justifies removal; in fact, a memo created after the completion date may be added if the required reasons and timing and reviewer information are documented, but removing documentation is not permitted prior to the end of the retention period.
Question 3
Hint
Ask whether the auditor is performing new or additional audit procedures after the report date, or merely adding documentation of work performed before that date.
Answer C. Choice C is correct. AU-C Section 230 requires that when the auditor performs new or additional audit procedures after the date of the auditor's report, the auditor document the circumstances that prompted the subsequent work, the procedures performed, the evidence obtained, the conclusions reached, and the effect on the report (if any), together with who made and reviewed any changes and when. The other choices describe adding documentation of work or evidence that was completed before the report date and therefore generally require only ordinary late-file notation of the change (the reason, preparer, reviewer, and dates).
Why not A: Tempting because specialist consultations are significant, but the consultation and memorandum were prepared before the report date; adding the memorandum documents existing work and typically requires only routine late-file notation rather than the exceptional-circumstances package.
Why not B: This restores evidence that existed before the report date. No new audit procedures are being performed after the report date, so only ordinary documentation of the file modification is generally required.
Why not D: Although reviewer identification and dates are required elements, if the review actually occurred before the report date and the later entry is supported by contemporaneous records, this is a late notation of existing work and falls under ordinary late-file documentation.
Question 4
Hint
First determine whether the discovery occurs before or after the documentation completion date. Then ask what the standards allow for adding existing evidence after that date.
Answer C. Because the discovery occurred after the documentation completion date, the auditor may add existing evidence to the engagement file but must clearly document the reason for the addition and record when and by whom it was made and reviewed. The agreement was obtained and used during fieldwork, so its addition does not create a new subsequent event or require reissuing the report when no new facts or procedures are involved.
Why not A: Incorrect: the auditor should not delete or discard existing documentation after the completion date. The appropriate action is to add the omitted evidence and document the addition rather than replace or remove prior documentation.
Why not B: Tempting because the evidence supported the prior work, but incorrect: additions made after the documentation completion date must be accompanied by documentation of the reason for the addition and when and by whom it was added and reviewed.
Why not D: Incorrect: additions after the documentation completion date are permitted when the evidence was obtained during fieldwork, but such additions must be documented. Oral explanations do not substitute for required written documentation in the engagement file.
Question 5
Hint
Treat this as two questions: what may be added to an assembled file after final assembly, and what may be removed or discarded after final assembly.
Answer A. AU-C 230 allows the auditor to add documentation to an assembled audit file after final assembly when necessary, provided the addition is clearly documented (including the reason for the addition and when and by whom it was added, and reviewed when applicable). Conversely, AU-C 230 prohibits deleting or discarding documentation after final assembly before the end of the applicable retention period (for nonissuers under AICPA standards that retention period is generally not shorter than five years).
Why not B: Tempting because the draft is superseded and contains errors, but incorrect: AU-C 230 does not permit deletion or discarding of documentation after final assembly until the end of the required retention period, even if the document was superseded.
Why not C: Plausible for those who overgeneralize the rule: AU-C 230 prohibits deletions after final assembly but does allow additions if the auditor documents the reason for the late addition and when and by whom it was made.
Why not D: Misleading because reissuing or amending the report is not required to add omitted documentation; the auditor should add the memorandum with the required documentation and continue to preserve existing working papers until the end of the retention period.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on what the standards require when documentation is changed after the file completion date, even if the change only clarifies work already performed.
Answer D. Audit documentation may be added after the documentation completion date, but the auditor must document the specific reason for the addition and record when and by whom it was made and reviewed. The auditor should not delete or discard existing documentation. Because the memorandum only clarifies work already performed and does not change conclusions, properly noting the addition is the most appropriate action.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates may prefer a single final version, but standards prohibit deleting or discarding existing documentation after the completion date; any later additions should preserve the record and explain the reason for the change.
Why not B: Even though conclusions did not change, post-completion additions must be accompanied by documentation of the reason for the addition and details about when and by whom it was made and reviewed; therefore some documentation of the addition is required.
Why not C: This confuses auditor documentation with management representations. The requirement concerns the auditor's engagement documentation; a management signature is not required to add an explanatory memorandum of the auditor's work.
Question 7
Hint
Refer to AU-C 230: late additions are permitted if the file records the reason, date, preparer, and reviewer; prohibited actions include deleting prior documentation, backdating, or making late entries appear original.
Answer D. AU-C 230 permits adding documentation after the engagement-file assembly completion date when appropriate, but requires that late additions be clearly identified and include the reason for the addition and the date and identity of the preparer and reviewer. The standard also disfavors deleting or concealing previously assembled documentation and precludes backdating or making late entries appear original. Thus the auditor may add the concluding memorandum only if the late addition is documented as such and the earlier unresolved memorandum is retained.
Why not A: This is tempting because the substantive procedures were performed earlier, but it is incorrect: AU-C 230 does not permit backdating or creating the impression that late additions were original, nor does it permit removing or concealing previously assembled documentation during the retention period. Late additions must be identified with the reason, date, and identity of preparer and reviewer.
Why not B: This is attractive because missing documentation on a significant matter is serious, but AU-C 230 does not mandate automatic withdrawal or reissuance solely for a missing memo. Withdrawal or reissue would be required only if the deficiency meant the auditor's conclusions were not supportable; ordinarily the auditor should first follow AU-C 230's requirements for properly documenting late additions.
Why not C: This choice plays on the incorrect belief that the file is frozen. AU-C 230 allows late additions when they are properly documented; oral explanations alone do not satisfy the documentation requirements for audit conclusions.
Question 8
Hint
Consider AU-C 230: are additions after the documentation completion date allowed, and what does the standard say about removing existing documentation?
Answer B. Under AICPA AU-C 230, the auditor may add documentation after the documentation completion date to clarify work performed or conclusions reached, but late additions must be clearly identified as additions and should indicate who prepared and reviewed them, when they were made, and why they were necessary. AU-C 230 also indicates that auditors should not delete or discard existing engagement documentation after the documentation completion date. Oral explanations and emails alone are not an adequate substitute for properly identified late additions.
Why not A: This is tempting because the procedures occurred earlier, but backdating additions to appear as though they were prepared on the original performance dates is improper. Late additions must be indicated as later additions and should show who made them and when they were actually added, rather than erasing the fact they were created after the documentation completion date.
Why not C: This overstates the effect of the documentation completion date. While auditors should not delete or discard documentation after that date, AU-C 230 permits properly identified late additions to clarify work and conclusions; relying solely on oral explanations and emails is not adequate documentation.
Why not D: Discarding earlier versions would remove the audit trail and could be viewed as deleting or discarding engagement documentation, which AU-C 230 advises against. The better practice is to retain original materials and add clearly identified late documentation as needed. The idea that revisions merely memorialize work performed before the report date does not justify discarding earlier versions; originals must be retained and any additions clearly identified.
Question 9
Hint
Identify the event that starts the GAAS documentation-completion clock, then ask whether a post-completion change is prohibited entirely or simply subject to documentation requirements.
Answer D. Under AU-C 230 (U.S. GAAS) for a nonissuer audit, the documentation-completion date is ordinarily no later than 60 days after the report release date, the date the auditor grants permission to use the auditor's report and financial statements. Here, the release date is March 15 (when permission was granted), so the 60-day assembly period begins then. An omitted memorandum discovered after that completion date may be added, but the addition must be clearly documented (what was added, who added it, when, and why).
Why not A: This answer erroneously anchors the 60-day period to the report date (March 8). For nonissuers, the clock runs from the report release date (when the auditor permits use). It is also incorrect to say the memorandum cannot be added at all; post-completion additions are permitted if properly documented.
Why not B: GAAS ties the documentation-completion deadline to the auditor's report release date (when permission to use is granted), not to management's external issuance. Also, properly documented additions to the file can be made after the completion date if needed.
Why not C: Forty-five days is the issuer (PCAOB) timing, not the nonissuer GAAS timing. Dual-dating the report is used to extend responsibility for subsequent procedures when new work is performed after the report date; it is not required here because no additional audit procedures are needed and the issue concerns late documentation.
Common questions
Can auditors delete draft workpapers after the documentation completion date?
No. If the draft remains in the completed file, retain it through the applicable retention period, even when a final memo supersedes it.
What must be documented for a late addition under AU-C 230?
Document the specific reason for the addition and when and by whom it was made and reviewed. Identify it as a late addition rather than making it appear original.
Does adding an omitted audit memo require reissuing the report?
Not in this scenario. The cutoff work and conclusion predate report release, no new procedures are needed, and the memo does not change the report.
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Requirements for Engagements Documentation
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.