AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 6 practice questions
Emphasis-of-Matter vs. Other-Matter Under AU-C 706
Under AU-C 706, Emphasis-of-Matter highlights fundamental matters properly presented or disclosed in the statements; Other-Matter addresses matters outside them. Sort Delta Co.'s independent nonissuer audit cases, including exceptions that require a different reporting treatment.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on the current AICPA reporting format when substantial doubt remains but management's disclosure is adequate.
Answer D. When substantial doubt remains but management's disclosure is adequate, the auditor does not modify the opinion solely for that reason. Under AICPA standards for nonissuers, the auditor highlights the matter by including a distinct paragraph/section with the heading 'Substantial Doubt About the Entity's Ability to Continue as a Going Concern.' Because the disclosure is adequate and there are no other issues, an unmodified opinion is appropriate.
Why not A: While auditors add a specific going-concern paragraph, the phrasing in D implies only a generic emphasis-of-matter without the required going-concern heading. The correct practice is to include the distinct paragraph/section with the specific 'Substantial Doubt...' heading to call attention to the uncertainty.
Why not B: This reflects the overgeneralization that any significant uncertainty requires a modified opinion. In fact, adequate disclosure by management means the auditor should not qualify the opinion solely for going-concern uncertainty; instead the auditor issues an unmodified opinion and includes the required going-concern paragraph.
Why not C: An adverse opinion is appropriate for a material and pervasive GAAP departure that makes the statements misleading. Substantial doubt about going concern, when adequately disclosed, does not by itself render the financial statements not fairly presented.
Sort it
The matter is appropriately presented or disclosed and fundamental to understanding the financial statements, with no separate reporting requirement replacing Emphasis-of-Matter.
The matter is outside the statements and helps users understand the audit, the auditor's responsibilities, or the report.
Substantial doubt remains after considering management's plans, and the related disclosure is adequate.
The statements contain a material misstatement, including inadequate disclosure; an added paragraph cannot fix it.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Delta makes a material, justified change from FIFO to weighted-average inventory costing. The change is properly accounted for and disclosed. | Emphasis-of-MatterA material, justified accounting principle change requires Emphasis-of-Matter even when the accounting and disclosure are correct. |
| Delta presents comparative prior-year statements audited by a predecessor. The predecessor's unmodified report will not be reissued. | Other-MatterThe predecessor's audit concerns reporting responsibility, not a financial statement matter. Other-Matter refers to that audit and report. |
| Substantial doubt about Delta's ability to continue as a going concern remains after considering management's plans. Disclosure is adequate. | Separate going-concern sectionRemaining substantial doubt requires its own titled section. Adequate disclosure supports an unmodified opinion, not an Emphasis-of-Matter substitute. |
| Delta uses an accounting method prohibited by GAAP. The resulting misstatement is material but not pervasive, and sufficient appropriate evidence is available. | Modified opinionThe material, nonpervasive GAAP departure requires a qualified opinion. Emphasis-of-Matter cannot make an unacceptable accounting method acceptable. |
| A post-year-end warehouse fire is properly disclosed. The auditor judges it fundamental to understanding Delta's financial statements. | Emphasis-of-MatterThe auditor highlights a fundamental matter already properly disclosed in the statements, without modifying the opinion. |
| Delta presents unaudited prior-year comparative statements alongside its audited current-year statements. | Other-MatterThe unaudited status explains the auditor's responsibilities for the comparative information, not an underlying financial statement event. |
| Delta makes a material, appropriate change from straight-line to double-declining-balance depreciation, accounts for it prospectively, and provides required disclosure. | Emphasis-of-MatterThis is an estimate change effected by a principle change. For reporting, evaluate it like a principle change. |
| Delta's prior-year statements received a predecessor's qualified opinion for omitting the statement of cash flows. That report is not reissued; the current-year audit supports an unmodified opinion. | Other-MatterOther-Matter describes the prior report and qualification. The prior-year qualification does not automatically modify the current-year opinion. |
| Delta properly restates previously issued financial statements to correct a material misstatement and adequately discloses the correction. | Emphasis-of-MatterCorrection of a material misstatement in previously issued statements requires Emphasis-of-Matter referring to the related disclosure. |
| Management's plans alleviate substantial doubt about Delta's ability to continue as a going concern. Disclosure is adequate, and the auditor decides to highlight the matter. | Emphasis-of-MatterBecause doubt is alleviated, the remaining-doubt section is not required. Emphasis-of-Matter highlights the adequately disclosed conditions and plans. |
| Delta's audit report requires an alert restricting its use to management and a specified lender. | Other-MatterThe restriction governs use of the auditor's report, not financial statement presentation. |
| Delta omits required details from a contingency note. The disclosure misstatement is material but not pervasive. | Modified opinionA note's existence does not make disclosure adequate. The material, nonpervasive omission requires a qualified opinion, not Emphasis-of-Matter. |
Key points
- Remember: Emphasis-of-Matter points to the statements; Other-Matter explains the audit or report. Neither replaces required alternative reporting.
- An Emphasis-of-Matter paragraph refers to the related note and states that the opinion is not modified for that matter.
- Material, justified principle changes and properly disclosed corrections of previously issued material misstatements require Emphasis-of-Matter.
- A predecessor's qualified opinion does not automatically qualify Delta's current-year opinion.
How the exam traps you
- Using Emphasis-of-Matter to discuss the predecessor auditor's report. Use Other-Matter when the predecessor's report on comparative statements is not reissued.
- Using Emphasis-of-Matter to fix a material GAAP departure or inadequate disclosure. Modify the opinion when the statements are materially misstated; an added paragraph cannot cure the problem.
- Treating remaining substantial doubt as an Emphasis-of-Matter paragraph. With adequate disclosure, keep the opinion unmodified and use the separate required going-concern section.
Question 2
Hint
CAM/KAM identification is YEAR-BY-YEAR. Prior-year CAMs may continue, drop, or new ones emerge based on current-year facts. Auditor exercises fresh judgment each engagement; no consistency requirement.
Answer D. CAM/KAM identification is a CURRENT-YEAR judgment, evaluated EACH ENGAGEMENT based on the audit's specific circumstances. Neither prior-year CAMs nor a 'one-and-done' rule applies. KEY PRINCIPLES: (1) ANNUAL EVALUATION, each year's audit triggers a fresh evaluation of which matters meet the CAM threshold based on the current year's risk assessment, judgment areas, and audit challenges. (2) CONTINUITY POSSIBLE BUT NOT REQUIRED, a matter that was a CAM in prior years may continue if it remains of most significance; common cases include persistent estimation uncertainty (long-tailed insurance reserves), ongoing complex transactions, and recurring fraud risks. (3) DROPPING A PRIOR CAM is appropriate when conditions change: matter resolved, risk diminished, judgment less significant. (4) NEW CAMs may emerge: business combinations, new regulations, new accounting pronouncements, business-model changes. (5) JUDGMENT-BASED, auditor's professional judgment governs each year independently. Voltaire's Year 3 analysis: with comfortable headroom, the auditor reassesses whether the impairment area remains of MOST significance versus other matters this year. Possibly retained, possibly dropped, depends on judgment. Even when retained, the CAM description may evolve to reflect current-year specifics (new assumptions, different industry conditions). Mechanical copy-paste of prior-year CAM language is poor practice. Answer A is incorrect: CAMs are not 'sticky', no requirement of cross-year consistency. Answer B is incorrect: there is no 'one-time disclosure' rule; many CAMs recur year over year (e.g., goodwill in companies with substantial goodwill). Answer C is incorrect: CAM determination is by the AUDITOR; the audit committee may discuss but does not decide.
Question 3
Hint
CAM/KAM by entity type: PCAOB issuers → CAMs REQUIRED. AICPA private (non-issuers) → KAMs OPTIONAL (only when engaged). ISA listed → KAMs REQUIRED. ISA non-listed → optional.
Answer C. KAM/CAM reporting requirements differ by framework and entity type. PCAOB AS 3101 (CAMs) is REQUIRED for U.S. issuers (public companies registered with the SEC). AICPA SAS 134 (KAMs) applies to private/non-issuer audits, the default report does NOT include KAMs; KAM communication is OPTIONAL and is included only when the auditor is engaged by the client (typically via engagement letter) or required by law/regulation. ISA 701 (KAMs) is required for listed entities under International Standards on Auditing and optional for other entities. Carrington's situation: a U.S. private company audited under AICPA standards. Default: no KAMs in the report. KAMs would only appear if Carrington engaged the auditor to provide them, perhaps because of international stakeholders, lender/investor requests, or audit committee preference. The AICPA does NOT allow the auditor to unilaterally add KAMs to a private-company report; the engagement scope governs. Even when KAMs are not in the report, the auditor still communicates significant matters to those charged with governance under SAS 114, KAM is about PUBLIC reporting, not governance communication. Answer A is incorrect: CAM reporting is required for issuers only. Answer B is incorrect: private-company reports include all standard report elements; only KAMs are optional. Answer D is incorrect: there is a clear distinction between issuer (PCAOB AS 3101) and non-issuer (AICPA SAS 134) reporting.
Question 4
Hint
CAM 'how addressed': HIGH-LEVEL summary of audit procedures, enough for users to understand response, without workpaper-level detail. Reference control testing, key assumption evaluation, specialist use. Avoid: separate opinions, full workpapers, vague boilerplate.
Answer B. The CAM 'how it was addressed' section requires a HIGH-LEVEL summary of the auditor's procedures, informative but not exhaustive. The standard balances transparency (users understand the audit response) with practical limits (don't reveal proprietary procedures, full workpapers, or client confidential information). Appropriate examples: 'we tested the design and operating effectiveness of management's controls'; 'we evaluated management's significant assumptions used in the model, including discount rate, growth rate, volatility'; 'we engaged our valuation specialist to develop an independent estimate of fair value and compared to management's estimate'; 'we performed sensitivity analysis on key assumptions'; 'we compared management's data inputs to source documents'. What to AVOID: full workpaper content (sample sizes, exact tolerances, full model parameters); separate opinions on the CAM area (CAMs do not opine, the audit opinion is on the F/S as a whole); boilerplate without information ('we tested the area' alone is too generic). PCAOB Staff Guidance on CAMs explicitly addresses this: avoid both over-detail (workpaper-level) and under-detail (vague). The right level: enough for an informed reader to understand the auditor's response. When a specialist is used, the CAM may reference the specialist's involvement, conveying that quantitative valuation expertise was applied. Answer A is incorrect: workpaper-level detail violates audit confidentiality and auditor work product. Answer C is incorrect: CAMs do NOT provide separate opinions; the auditor's opinion is on the F/S as a whole. Answer D is incorrect: vague boilerplate fails to inform users, both PCAOB and ISA warn against non-informative descriptions.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on what the auditor learned after fieldwork and whether the auditor extended procedures for all subsequent events or only for one specific event.
Answer A. Dual dating is appropriate when the auditor completes fieldwork and later becomes aware of a subsequent event for which the auditor performs additional procedures limited to that specific event. Dual dating allows the auditor to accept responsibility for procedures through the original report date (March 5) while limiting responsibility for the subsequent-event procedures to the later date (March 11). Using a single later date would extend the auditor's responsibility for all subsequent events to March 11, which did not occur here.
Why not B: This distractor is attractive because the auditor must consider subsequent events before issuance. But dating the entire report March 11 would mean the auditor accepts responsibility for all subsequent events through that date. Because the auditor only performed additional procedures on the fire (and did not extend all subsequent-events work), dual dating is the appropriate choice.
Why not C: This is tempting because the fire is a nonrecognized subsequent event and does not change year-end amounts. However, the auditor performed procedures on the fire after March 5; keeping only the original date would not reflect the added responsibility for that subsequent-event work.
Why not D: Candidates may think a post-year-end incident requires a modified opinion, but a properly disclosed nonrecognized subsequent event that does not require an adjustment does not, by itself, require a qualified opinion. The issue here concerns report dating and scope of responsibility, not an automatic opinion modification.
Question 6
Hint
First decide whether this fact pattern creates a scope limitation or a permitted division of responsibility. Then ask how that classification affects the opinion versus the report wording.
Answer C. When a group auditor elects to refer to a component auditor, the situation is treated as a division of responsibility rather than a scope limitation. If the group auditor is satisfied with the component auditor's competence, independence, and work, the group auditor may still issue an unmodified opinion. The auditor's report should include a reference to the component auditor and indicate the magnitude of the portion audited by that auditor.
Why not A: Incorrect: issuing the consolidated opinion does not eliminate the reporting consequence of electing to divide responsibility. If the group auditor refers to the component auditor, the report should state that reference and indicate the scope/magnitude.
Why not B: This is tempting because the subsidiary is material, but a qualified opinion for not auditing a material portion applies when the group auditor cannot obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence. Here Harbor is satisfied with the component auditor and chose to refer to them, so a qualification is not required.
Why not D: Incorrect: a disclaimer is appropriate only when the auditor cannot obtain sufficient appropriate evidence. Harbor is satisfied with the component auditor's competence and work, and the component auditor's full report need not be presented alongside Harbor's for Harbor to issue an unmodified opinion with an appropriate reference.
Common questions
What is the difference between Emphasis-of-Matter and Other-Matter under AU-C 706?
Emphasis-of-Matter highlights a properly presented or disclosed financial statement matter fundamental to users' understanding. Other-Matter addresses information outside the statements relevant to understanding the audit, the auditor's responsibilities, or the report.
Does an Emphasis-of-Matter or Other-Matter paragraph modify the audit opinion?
No. Delta can receive an unmodified opinion with either paragraph, but a material accounting or disclosure misstatement still requires a modified opinion.
Is a going-concern paragraph an Emphasis-of-Matter paragraph?
When substantial doubt remains with adequate disclosure, use the separate section titled "Substantial Doubt About the Entity's Ability to Continue as a Going Concern." If doubt is alleviated, adequately disclosed conditions may instead receive Emphasis-of-Matter when the auditor chooses to highlight them.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Reports on Auditing Engagements, worked step by step.
Auditor Report Modifications | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Reports on Auditing Engagements
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.