AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 6 practice questions
Changed Prior-Year Audit Opinion: Required Explanation.
When a continuing auditor changes a previously issued opinion on Year 1, the comparative report must explain the change in an Other-Matter paragraph. Follow Cove's correction from a qualified opinion to an unmodified opinion and the required explanation.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on what the auditor must disclose when an updated prior-period opinion is different from the opinion previously issued.
Answer C. When an auditor updates a prior-period opinion and the updated opinion differs from the previously expressed opinion, the report must identify the previous report and explain the change. The explanatory paragraph includes the previous report date, the type of opinion previously expressed, the substantive reasons for the different opinion, and a statement that the updated opinion differs from the previous opinion.
Why not A: This answer treats the paragraph as describing the current conclusion rather than identifying the prior opinion. The required disclosure includes the type of opinion previously expressed and states that the updated opinion differs from the previous opinion.
Why not B: This answer focuses on the basis for the original report. The paragraph must include the previous report date and the substantive reasons the updated opinion is different, not merely the original reasons for modification.
Why not D: This answer mixes the updated conclusion with the original basis for modification. The required paragraph identifies the earlier report and earlier opinion, then explains why the updated opinion differs.
The timeline
- February 20, Year 2The auditor issues Cove's Year 1 report.
The opinion is qualified because Cove omitted a material accrual.
- During the Year 2 auditCove corrects the Year 1 comparative statements.
The revised statements include the omitted accrual and related disclosures.
- March 15, Year 3The continuing auditor completes the audit.
Sufficient appropriate evidence supports an unmodified opinion on Year 1 as corrected.
- Comparative report preparationCompare the updated Year 1 opinion with the previous opinion.
Qualified becomes unmodified. That difference requires an Other-Matter paragraph explaining the change.
- Comparative report issuanceInclude the four required disclosures.
Our report dated February 20, Year 2 expressed a qualified opinion on Year 1 because a material accrual was omitted. Cove corrected the accrual and related disclosures. Our updated Year 1 opinion is unmodified and differs from our previous opinion.
Key points
- Remember: Fixing Year 1 can remove the qualification, but it does not remove the explanation of the changed opinion.
- Use this checklist: old date, old opinion, reason for change, explicit statement that the opinions differ.
- Explain why the opinion changed, not just why the original opinion was qualified.
How the exam traps you
- Treat the correction as eliminating any need to mention the prior qualification. Include an Other-Matter paragraph with all four changed-opinion disclosures.
- Give the current opinion type instead of the previous opinion type. Identify the prior qualified opinion and the earlier report date, February 20, Year 2.
Question 2
Hint
Ask whether the same auditor is now issuing one report on both years together, and what that does to the report date.
Answer D. When the same auditor issues a comparative report covering both years, the prior-year opinion is updated rather than merely reissued. Updating extends the auditor's responsibility and subsequent-event consideration through the current report date for the comparative report. A simple reissuance is not the reporting approach in this situation.
Why not A: This choice assumes updating changes form but not responsibility. Updating requires the auditor to consider events through the current report date, not to stop at the original Year 1 report date.
Why not B: This answer treats the prior opinion as if it were being presented again without a new comparative report by the same auditor. That is the reissuance concept, which does not apply when the auditor is now reporting comparatively on both Year 2 and Year 1.
Why not C: This choice mixes two different ideas. Dual dating is used for a specific subsequent event, while reissuance is not the proper treatment when the same auditor issues a new comparative report covering both periods.
Question 3
Hint
Treat the matters separately: one concerns whether the current opinion on the prior period differs from the previously issued opinion; the other concerns whether a retrospective, material accounting change should be specifically referenced in the report.
Answer A. Two separate reporting matters apply. When the opinion on prior-period financial statements as presented differs from the opinion previously issued, the current report should disclose that changed prior opinion. Separately, a retrospective change in accounting principle that is justified and is material to comparability should be called out in the report by referring to the note describing the change. An unmodified opinion is appropriate, but both communications are required.
Why not B: Tempting because the prior statements were revised, but incorrect: revising prior-period statements does not eliminate the requirement to disclose in the current report that the opinion now expressed differs from the previously issued opinion.
Why not C: Tempting because the accounting change was properly applied and disclosed, but incorrect: when a retrospective accounting change is justified and material to comparability, the auditor should include a paragraph in the report that refers users to the note describing the change.
Why not D: Tempting because the underlying issues were addressed, but incorrect: standards still call for report language when the prior-period opinion differs from the previously issued opinion and when a retrospective change materially affects comparability and is disclosed in a note.
Question 4
Hint
When an updated comparative report changes a prior-period opinion, consider what must be said about the previous opinion and why it changed.
Answer C. When an auditor updates a prior-period opinion and the updated opinion differs from the opinion previously expressed, the current report may express the updated opinion. The report also should address the previously issued qualified opinion, the reasons for that opinion, the change in circumstances, and that the updated opinion differs.
Why not A: This treats the earlier qualified report as the reporting mechanism for the prior period. It fails because the current comparative report updates the opinion and describes the prior qualification and change, rather than including the old report.
Why not B: This assumes the updated unmodified opinion cancels the previously issued report. It fails because the auditor explains the changed opinion and its basis, rather than stating that the previous report was withdrawn.
Why not D: This assumes the correction eliminates any need to discuss the earlier report. It fails because a changed updated opinion requires disclosure about the previously issued opinion and the reasons for the change.
Question 5
Hint
Ask whether the new matter shows the prior-year statements were materially wrong when the original report was issued.
Answer C. New evidence that Year 1 inventory was materially overstated means the prior-year financial statements were materially misstated when originally reported on. If management leaves Year 1 unchanged in the comparative statements, the original unmodified Year 1 opinion is no longer appropriate and must be changed.
Why not A: This answer results from assuming any alteration to prior-period presentation changes the prior opinion. Reclassification for comparability changes presentation only and does not make the original Year 1 opinion inappropriate.
Why not B: This answer comes from confusing a later event with evidence about Year 1 conditions. A Year 2 fire does not show that the Year 1 statements were wrong when originally audited, so it does not require changing the Year 1 opinion.
Why not D: This answer comes from treating any change affecting comparability as a reason to change the prior opinion. A change in estimate is accounted for prospectively and does not mean Year 1 was misstated when originally reported.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on whether the predecessor updated audit work after the original report date.
Answer D. A predecessor auditor who reissues a prior-period report ordinarily keeps the original report date. That date reflects the last day of the predecessor's audit procedures on that prior-period engagement. Because no updating procedures were performed, the date is not changed to a later one.
Why not A: This answer treats the reissued report as if it should align with the later comparative period presented. The predecessor's report still relates to the Year 1 audit and keeps its original date unless the predecessor updates procedures.
Why not B: This answer uses the successor auditor's current reporting date. A predecessor does not adopt the successor's report date when merely reissuing a prior report without performing later procedures.
Why not C: This answer comes from using the balance sheet date instead of the auditor's report date. Audit reports are dated when sufficient appropriate audit evidence has been obtained, not as of the financial statement date.
Common questions
What must an auditor disclose when a prior-year opinion changes?
The Other-Matter paragraph identifies the previous report date, the previous opinion type, the substantive reasons for the change, and that the updated opinion differs.
Does correcting the prior-year error eliminate the changed-opinion explanation?
No. Cove can receive an unmodified Year 1 opinion after correction, but the report still explains the change from qualified to unmodified.
Where does an AICPA auditor explain a changed prior-year opinion?
Use an Other-Matter paragraph. In Cove's comparative report, it identifies the earlier qualified opinion and explains why the updated Year 1 opinion differs.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Comparative Statements and Consistency Between Periods, worked step by step.
AUD Simulation: Comparative Statements and Consistency on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Comparative Statements and Consistency Between Periods
All Comparative Statements and Consistency Between Periods practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.