AUD · Ethics and Professional Responsibilities and General Principles · 7 practice questions
AU-C 265: Who Gets a Written Deficiency Letter?
In a nonissuer audit, significant deficiencies and material weaknesses require timely written communication to both management and those charged with governance. Sort Pine's payment-approval finding by whether its communication meets that requirement.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on which levels of internal control deficiency require a formal written communication and who must receive it.
Answer C. Under AU-C 265, an auditor must communicate significant deficiencies and material weaknesses in writing to management and those charged with governance. A material weakness therefore must be communicated in writing to both groups even if management already is aware of it. Less severe control deficiencies that are not significant deficiencies do not require the same written communication to those charged with governance and may be reported to management orally or in writing at the auditor's discretion.
Why not A: Some auditor communications to those charged with governance can be oral, but a material weakness must be communicated in writing regardless of management's awareness.
Why not B: This is tempting because internal-control issues are important, but AU-C 265 requires written communication only for significant deficiencies and material weaknesses, not for every minor control deficiency.
Why not D: Internal-control deficiencies are communicated separately; an auditor's standard report on the financial statements for a nonissuer does not include descriptive details of material weaknesses, such matters are reported in the communications required by AU-C 265.
Sort it
A timely written communication reaches both appropriate management and those charged with governance.
A significant deficiency or material weakness lacks timely written communication to either required audience.
The control deficiency is neither a significant deficiency nor a material weakness.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Pine, a nonissuer, has an audit committee separate from management. The auditor identifies a significant deficiency in payment-approval controls and promptly communicates it orally only to appropriate management. No written communication is sent. | Written requirement not metThe significant deficiency requires timely written communication to appropriate management and the audit committee. Oral notice to management alone is insufficient. |
| Same facts, except the auditor also sends one timely written communication to appropriate management and the audit committee. | Written requirement metThe timely written communication reaches both required audiences. Separate letters are not necessary. |
| Same facts, except the payment-approval finding is below a significant deficiency but still merits management's attention. | No AU-C 265 written triggerThis lower-severity deficiency may be communicated orally to management. It does not trigger mandatory written communication to both audiences. |
| Same facts, except management already knew about the significant deficiency. | Written requirement not metManagement's prior knowledge does not replace timely written communication to management and the audit committee. |
| Same facts, except the auditor also discusses the significant deficiency orally with the audit committee. | Written requirement not metBoth audiences have heard about the finding, but neither has received the required written communication. |
| Same facts, except the auditor also sends timely written communication of the significant deficiency only to the audit committee. | Written requirement not metAppropriate management must also receive written communication; its earlier oral notice is insufficient. |
| Same facts, except the payment-approval finding is a material weakness rather than a significant deficiency. | Written requirement not metMaterial weaknesses, like significant deficiencies, require timely written communication to appropriate management and the audit committee. Oral communication to management alone is insufficient. |
| Same facts, except Pine's only governors are its owner-managers, all of whom received the oral communication. | Written requirement not metHaving the same people fill both roles does not eliminate the written requirement. One timely written communication to all of these owner-managers would cover both roles. |
| Same facts, except management corrects the significant deficiency before the auditor's report is released. | Written requirement not metCorrection does not cancel the requirement. The significant deficiency identified during the audit still requires timely written communication to both audiences. |
| Same facts, except the auditor confirms that no misstatement occurred. | Written requirement not metNo misstatement is needed. The significant deficiency still requires timely written communication to management and the audit committee; oral notice to management is insufficient. |
Key points
- Remember: Knowing about the problem is not the same as receiving the required written communication.
- One timely letter can cover both audiences if it reaches everyone serving in those roles.
- Identification triggers communication; no actual misstatement is needed.
- Correcting the significant deficiency before report release does not cancel the written requirement.
How the exam traps you
- Treating an oral discussion as sufficient because management already knows. Prior awareness does not replace written communication to management and governance.
- Sending the written communication only to the audit committee. Appropriate management must also receive written communication, even after an oral discussion.
- Skipping the letter because management corrected the significant deficiency. Identification during the audit triggers the written requirement, even if management fixes the problem.
Question 2
Hint
Treat the two obligations separately: internal-control deficiencies require a specified form and recipients, while uncorrected misstatements other than clearly trivial must be brought to those charged with governance.
Answer C. GAAS requires that material weaknesses (and significant deficiencies) in internal control be communicated in writing to management and to those charged with governance. Uncorrected misstatements other than those that are clearly trivial must be communicated to those charged with governance; that communication does not have to be written. Because the full board is identified as those charged with governance, limiting communications to the chair alone does not satisfy the recipient requirement.
Why not A: This plays on the misstatement being immaterial to the opinion, but it is incorrect: GAAS requires the auditor to communicate uncorrected misstatements other than those that are clearly trivial to those charged with governance even when no opinion modification is needed.
Why not B: Tempting because governance oversight is central, but incorrect: GAAS requires a written communication of a material weakness to management as well as to those charged with governance; prior oral awareness by management does not eliminate the written communication requirement.
Why not D: Attractive because some communications are oral and the chair may act as a conduit, but incorrect: the material weakness must be communicated in writing and the communication must reach those charged with governance (the full board), not only the chair.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on which governance communications are merely required versus which ones the standards specifically require to be in writing.
Answer D. AICPA auditing standards require that significant deficiencies and material weaknesses identified during an audit be communicated in writing to management and those charged with governance (see AU-C 265). Other required communications, such as significant difficulties encountered, uncorrected misstatements, and the auditor's views on qualitative accounting practices, must be communicated but are not specifically required to be in writing and may be conveyed orally if the auditor documents the communication.
Why not A: Significant difficulties are an important required communication to those charged with governance, but AICPA standards do not mandate that this be in writing; oral communication is acceptable if the auditor documents it.
Why not B: Uncorrected misstatements must be communicated to those charged with governance, and auditors often present them in writing in practice, but the standards do not specifically require that the communication be in writing.
Why not C: The auditor's views on qualitative accounting practices are required communications, but the standards permit oral communication as long as the auditor appropriately documents the matters.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on both the severity level identified and who must receive the communication when governance is separate from management.
Answer D. Auditing standards require that significant deficiencies identified during an audit be communicated in writing to management and those charged with governance on a timely basis. Because Delta's audit committee is separate from management, the auditor should communicate to both groups. The requirement does not depend on whether a material misstatement occurred.
Why not A: The management representation letter from management does not substitute for the auditor's required written communication of internal control deficiencies to management and those charged with governance.
Why not B: Candidates may think oral communication to management is enough because the issue is less severe than a material weakness, but standards require written communication and that those charged with governance (e.g., the audit committee) be informed when separate from management.
Why not C: This is incorrect because the obligation to communicate is triggered by the identification of a significant deficiency, not by whether it already caused a material misstatement.
Question 5
Hint
Treat the two matters separately: one is a significant finding from the audit process, and the other is an internal control deficiency with a specific communication requirement.
Answer C. AICPA auditing standards require the auditor to communicate significant difficulties encountered during the audit to those charged with governance. AU-C 265 requires that significant deficiencies in internal control be communicated in writing to management and to those charged with governance when they are separate parties. Therefore the audit delay (a significant audit difficulty) should be brought to those charged with governance, and the segregation-of-duties significant deficiency must be communicated in writing to both management and those charged with governance.
Why not A: Tempting because management addresses operational issues, but significant difficulties encountered during the audit are matters for those charged with governance, and a significant deficiency must be communicated in writing rather than only orally.
Why not B: This recognizes the need for written communication of a significant deficiency but is wrong because the significant audit difficulty should be communicated to those charged with governance, and the significant deficiency must also be communicated in writing to management when management and governance are separate.
Why not D: Although conservative, this is incorrect because AU-C 265 requires the significant deficiency to be communicated in writing to management as well when they are separate, and the significant audit difficulty is a matter the auditor should communicate to those charged with governance (writing is not specifically required).
Question 6
Hint
Separate the three items by category: internal control deficiency, audit difficulty, and uncorrected misstatement. Then ask, for each category, who must receive the communication and whether GAAS requires it to be in writing.
Answer A. Under GAAS, significant deficiencies and material weaknesses identified during the audit must be communicated in writing to both management and those charged with governance. GAAS also requires the auditor to communicate significant difficulties encountered during the audit and uncorrected misstatements other than those that are clearly trivial to those charged with governance on a timely basis. Unless another requirement applies, those latter communications do not have to be in writing.
Why not B: This is tempting because all three matters are important audit matters, and students often overgeneralize the written-communication rule. However, GAAS specifically requires written communication to both management and those charged with governance for significant deficiencies and material weaknesses, not for every significant audit matter. Significant difficulties and uncorrected misstatements are required communications to those charged with governance, but GAAS does not generally require them to be in writing.
Why not C: This choice is attractive if a candidate remembers that significant difficulties are important enough to tell those charged with governance and assumes that importance means written communication. But GAAS does not generally require significant difficulties to be in writing, and the uncorrected misstatement must be communicated to those charged with governance because it is not clearly trivial, even though management declined to adjust it.
Why not D: This distractor reflects the mistake of tying governance communications too closely to opinion modification. Significant difficulties encountered during the audit and uncorrected misstatements that are not clearly trivial are required communications to those charged with governance even when the audit opinion is not modified. The communication requirement is broader than just matters that change the opinion.
Question 7
Hint
Focus on who must receive communications about a material weakness and whether the standards require a particular form of communication.
Answer B. Under GAAS (AU-C 265), the auditor must communicate material weaknesses and significant deficiencies in writing to management and those charged with governance. Because Pine has a separate audit committee, the audit committee (as those charged with governance) must receive the written communication in addition to management. Management's intent to remediate does not eliminate the requirement for timely written communication.
Why not A: Tempting because audit committees oversee internal control, but GAAS requires the auditor to communicate material weaknesses in writing to both management and those charged with governance. Omitting management would fail to meet the required recipients.
Why not C: An oral discussion alone is insufficient for a material weakness. The standards require a written communication to document the auditor's finding and inform management and those charged with governance.
Why not D: The requirement to communicate is triggered when the auditor identifies the material weakness during the audit, not postponed until year-end. Waiting could result in untimely or missing required communication.
Common questions
Does AU-C 265 require significant deficiencies and material weaknesses to be communicated in writing?
Yes. Both require timely written communication to appropriate management and those charged with governance, even if no misstatement occurred.
Does correcting a significant deficiency eliminate the written communication requirement?
No. A significant deficiency identified during the audit still requires timely written communication to both audiences, even if corrected before report release.
What if management and those charged with governance are the same people?
One timely written communication to all owner-managers serving in both roles can cover both audiences. Oral communication alone is insufficient.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Communication with Management and Those Charged with Governance, worked step by step.
Audit Communications: Recipient and Form | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Communication with Management and Those Charged with Governance
All Communication with Management and Those Charged with Governance practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.