AUD · Ethics and Professional Responsibilities and General Principles · 6 practice questions
Audit Acceptance and Continuance: Competence and Resources
Accept or continue only when the firm can meet ethical requirements and has, or can obtain, the competence and resources needed to perform the engagement properly. Below: apply that test to an audit requiring valuation expertise.
Try one first
Hint
Think about what the firm must evaluate before saying yes to a client relationship, not what it can sort out later.
Answer C. A firm's acceptance and continuance policies should address three core matters: compliance with relevant ethical requirements (including independence when applicable), the firm's competence and resources to perform the engagement, and the integrity of the client. These assessments should be made before accepting or continuing a client relationship so the system of quality management provides reasonable assurance that only appropriate engagements are accepted.
Why not A: Staffing and technical competence are essential, but client integrity must be considered at the acceptance stage. Postponing that evaluation weakens the firm's quality controls and exposes the firm to unacceptable risk.
Why not B: Profitability is a business consideration but does not override firm-level acceptance criteria; ethical requirements (for example, independence) should be evaluated before acceptance, not deferred to fieldwork.
Why not D: The decision to continue an engagement requires ongoing assessment of client integrity and the firm's ability to comply with ethical requirements; it is not limited to cases of proven dishonesty or withdrawn reports.
Step by step
- Identify the competence gap
A firm is considering an audit involving complex fair value measurements, and independence is clear. Nobody at the firm has sufficient valuation audit experience, and no qualified external resource has been identified.
- Check relevant ethical requirements
Determine whether the firm can comply with relevant ethical requirements, including independence. Independence is clear here, but that alone does not establish that the firm can perform the audit.
- Consider client integrity and access
Assess management's integrity and whether the firm can obtain the information needed for the audit. Decline if these concerns prevent the firm from reasonably expecting to comply with professional standards.
- Verify resources before acceptance
Determine whether qualified valuation help can be obtained when needed to perform the audit properly. The firm does not need every skill internally, but it must assess external competence and availability before accepting.
- Reject promises to fix it later
Do not accept on a promise to locate valuation expertise during fieldwork. Closer supervision cannot replace the missing expertise.
- Decide before committing
Delay or decline acceptance until the firm determines it can obtain the needed expertise in time to perform the audit properly. For a recurring audit, apply the same test before continuance: determine whether the necessary competence and resources will be available before deciding to continue.
Key points
- Remember: independence clears one requirement; it does not fill a competence gap.
- Qualified external help can fill the gap if the firm determines that help will be available when needed.
- Apply the same readiness test to recurring audits before deciding to continue.
How the exam traps you
- Independence is clear, so the firm can accept. Also assess client integrity and the firm's competence, capabilities, and resources.
- Accept now and find valuation expertise during fieldwork. Determine before acceptance that qualified help can be obtained when needed.
- Closer supervision will compensate for missing expertise. Supervision cannot replace valuation competence that the firm and its available resources lack.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on the source of the breakdown, not merely where the problem was discovered or where its effects appeared.
Answer A. Resources is the best classification. A firm's resources include the technological and methodological tools and timely access to those tools needed to perform engagements. Here the root cause was that personnel were not given timely access to the updated software and templates, even though the symptom appeared in engagement files and was detected later by monitoring.
Why not B: This choice is tempting because acceptance and continuance considers whether the firm can perform engagements competently, but the stem explicitly states the clients were properly accepted and continued. The failure described arose after continuance due to access to updated tools, so resources is the more direct classification.
Why not C: This distractor points to the symptom, workpapers not showing the revised forms, which makes it attractive. However, the stem identifies a root-cause access problem (timely availability of updated software/templates), which points to resources rather than engagement performance as the primary weakness.
Why not D: Monitoring and remediation relates to the firm's processes for identifying deficiencies and responding to them, and it did uncover the issue. But monitoring was the detector, not the underlying cause; the primary breakdown was the firm's failure to provide timely access to updated tools (resources).
Question 3
Hint
Focus on what the policy is primarily designed to monitor and enforce across the firm.
Answer C. Firm-wide policies that identify, evaluate, and address independence matters belong to the 'relevant ethical requirements' component of a firm's system of quality management. Independence is a core ethical requirement, so annual confirmations and reporting of financial interests are controls to monitor and enforce that requirement across the firm.
Why not A: Governance and leadership is tempting because firm leadership sets the tone and is responsible for quality. However, the policies described specifically address compliance with independence rules, which are classified under relevant ethical requirements rather than the leadership component itself.
Why not B: Engagement performance relates to the direction, supervision, and review of specific engagements. The stem describes firm-wide independence policies, not engagement-level procedures, so engagement performance is not the best classification.
Why not D: Acceptance and continuance covers decisions about taking or retaining clients, which can be affected by independence matters. Still, the described annual confirmations and reporting are ongoing firm-wide compliance measures, so they fit more directly under relevant ethical requirements.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on who is disqualified from inspecting a completed engagement under the firm's monitoring process and whether small‑firm scalability or peer review eliminates that disqualification.
Answer B. Under AICPA Quality Management Standards, a firm's monitoring and remediation process should include inspections of completed engagements performed with appropriate objectivity. Because the manager served as the engagement quality reviewer for that same engagement, the manager should not inspect that engagement; someone who did not participate in the engagement should perform the inspection. Small‑firm scalability affects how a firm obtains qualified resources but does not remove the prohibition against an individual inspecting an engagement in which they were involved.
Why not A: This is tempting because an engagement quality reviewer is often separate from the engagement team and peer review provides external oversight. It is wrong because serving as the engagement quality reviewer for the same engagement compromises the objectivity required to inspect that engagement, and peer review does not substitute for the firm's own objective inspection of completed engagements.
Why not C: This distractor is attractive because narrowing scope seems to reduce self‑review risk. It is wrong because the disqualification focuses on who performs the inspection (prior participation or EQR role), not merely which parts of the file are reviewed.
Why not D: This is tempting if a candidate overreads scalability as allowing cost‑ or practicality‑based exceptions. It is wrong because scalability changes how a firm obtains qualified resources but does not permit a person who participated in the engagement to inspect that same engagement.
Question 5
Hint
Focus first on the acceptance and continuance decision, not on safeguards that would apply only after a client is accepted.
Answer B. A firm's quality management system includes policies and procedures for acceptance and continuance of client relationships and specific engagements. Management integrity is a core preacceptance consideration, and the firm should not accept an engagement if it cannot reasonably expect to perform the work with quality and in compliance with professional and legal requirements. Extra staffing or extra review does not fix a client acceptance problem rooted in integrity concerns.
Why not A: Stronger staffing can address some engagement risks, but it does not cure concerns about management integrity. If integrity doubts mean the firm cannot reasonably expect to comply with standards, the firm should decline rather than attempt to staff around the problem.
Why not C: Acceptance and continuance judgments must be made before starting the engagement. The stem states the firm already has sufficient information to evaluate the issue preacceptance, so beginning audit work before deciding is inappropriate.
Why not D: An engagement quality review relates to engagement performance and cannot cure a fundamental client-acceptance issue caused by management integrity concerns. Requiring extra review does not justify accepting a client the firm cannot expect to serve in compliance with standards.
Question 6
Hint
Which element of a firm's system of quality management is responsible for determining, before acceptance, whether the firm has the competence and resources to perform a new, specialized engagement?
Answer C. A firm's acceptance-and-continuance decisions should include whether the firm can perform the engagement in accordance with professional standards and applicable requirements, which includes assessing competence and resource availability (including external specialists and necessary training) before acceptance. The firm accepted a specialized ERISA audit without making that pre-acceptance determination, so relying on plans to address gaps during fieldwork is too late.
Why not A: This distractor appeals to those who view engagement-level supervision as a fix. Engagement performance controls (supervision, consultation, review) are necessary but do not replace the firm-level duty to determine competence and resource sufficiency before accepting a specialized engagement.
Why not B: This is tempting because monitoring is important for post-engagement improvement, but monitoring is a post-acceptance activity and cannot substitute for the required pre-acceptance assessment of competence and resource availability.
Why not D: Candidates sometimes conflate competence with independence. The fact pattern states independence is satisfied; lack of specialized experience primarily raises competence and resource concerns addressed by acceptance-and-continuance, not necessarily an independence impairment.
Common questions
Can a CPA firm accept an audit without the required expertise?
Only if it determines before acceptance that it can obtain the necessary competence and resources. In the valuation example, no qualified outside help has been identified, so acceptance should be delayed or declined.
Is independence enough to accept an audit client?
No. The firm must also consider client integrity and determine whether it has, or can obtain, the competence, capabilities, and resources needed to perform the audit properly.
Does the competence and resources test apply to audit continuance?
Yes. Before continuing a recurring audit, determine whether the necessary competence and resources will be available. Prior acceptance does not replace the current continuance assessment.
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on A Firm's System of Quality Management
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.